5 ms·
Given all the discussion about "supply chain security", heading in this direction is surprising. I guess it means we automate away the creative part and leave t
by pjc50 4y ago
Given all the discussion about "supply chain security", heading in this direction is surprising. I guess it means we automate away the creative part and leave the humans to the duller work of validation. Everyone's going to become a software tester.
- krono 4y ago> Futurists in 1950: Automation will free mankind from meaningless tedium to focus on creative pursuits only humans can master. > Techbros in 2023: We coded AI to write all your books, music, and TV so you can focus on the meaningless tedium of your cubicle farm. From this popular tweet by @stealthygeek https://twitter.com/stealthygeek/status/1618997354199400449 https://twitter.com/stealthygeek/status/1618997354199400449
- ren_engineer 4y agoturns out math and blue collar labor is much harder to automate than "creative" tasks. Watching people who thump their chest about being progressive and supporting science turn into luddites due to having to face the harsh reality that their skills aren't that special is funny honestly. Are they going to follow the luddites and call for people to storm data centers and smash the GPUs?
- popinman322 4y agoProperly creative work still isn't automated. The current generation of systems can only generate content within the codomain (semantic space) they were trained on; they're interpolating and need more work to extrapolate. Most creative work companies need can likely be substantially automated either now or soon. Most creative work individuals want will take much longer to automate. Things like movies, where even humans can't robustly figure out which ideas will work, will take more human discretion.
- ren_engineer 4y agowho know how it will progress, but I can see the ability to churn out "MVP movies" where AI actors and voice actors are used and scenes are generated. There is already stuff to create sequences of images that create videos based on prompts Hollywood studios are already using game engines like Unreal to create virtual sets in real-time. I could see some sort of hobbyist pipeline being created that will get a decent starting point made. Workflow would be like this: >use GPT to generate scenes and ideas >GPT then used to create multiple different scripts, human chooses the best for each scene >AI voice synthesizer used to do the dialogue >Stable diffusion or equivalent used to create multiple 3D models for characters, finishing touches by human >models then used by game engine to act out the scene, not sure how much of this can be done via AI >live action stuff can use deep fake technology with any random person being deep faked to look like the AI generated unique character I can see some crazy animated/CGI movies being produced much cheaper than traditional Hollywood style used now. We could see indie projects with the look of much bigger budget projects thanks to automation. It will level the playing field somewhat and allow people with better ideas to flourish, rather than just people with connections to get funding from studios.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"We could see indie projects with the look of much bigger budget projects thanks to automation" Or we could see creative work drown in massive numbers of half automated generic garbage. But to be honest, most of the movies today seem to be generic and it is very hard already, to find the gold nuggets. So yes, there is also great potential, but I am less confident that it will level the field and rather make true artists stay niche.
- wongarsu 4y agoThere is a decent argument that the current generation of AI isn't creative but merely automating the "tedious part". Midjourney can create an amazing image if I ask it to make a bunny made from multicolored glass, with volumetric lighting, octane render, 8k. But wasn't the creative act here the idea to make a bunny out of glass and shine a cool light on it, rather than the execution of that idea? The problem of course is that for the most part, the current creative community (whether paid or unpaid) is much more about execution and craftsmanship than creativity. Ideas are a some a dozen, and having exceptionally great ideas mostly matter for the top 2%. The rest is mostly shining in execution, which AI is rapidly attacking right now
- avgcorrection 4y agoA question for when you are finished reveling in their misery: what is the upside of this purported development?
- Der_Einzige 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if AI researchers are targets for murder in the cyberpunk future we are flung into. Moreover, math is NOT hard for AI. Anytime the LLM detects a numerical math problem, it should be smart enough to go to a calculator and enter the numbers and give you the answer. This is not hard to implement and I'm sure someone has already done this.
- franga2000 4y agoThe main problems with software supply chain security are that developers using libraries don't read their code and that that code can be changed later by the author. Neither of those are problems with "AI"-generated code - it lives right in your source files and you have to be actively avoiding reading it to miss critical issues that you're familiar with.
- pjc50 4y ago> have to be actively avoiding reading it A question of volume, surely? It might be OK for snippets, but once you've added a million lines of AI code to your codebase, when are you going to get around to reading it? Like libraries, you hit a button and add thousands to millions of LOC. If it appears to work, are you going to read it?
- sanderjd 4y agoReading the AI code and understanding it would be a harder task than writing it yourself, in my opinion. And that will only be more true over time if it becomes more common to have prompt writing skills than code writing skills.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dinvlad 4y agoI’d even argue the next logical step would be FPGA-type programming where there isn’t really a human-readable program anymore, but just a model loaded into hardware.
- sanderjd 4y agoYeah. I think AI generated code that humans are supposedly reviewing seems like an unstable equilibrium, which will end up swinging one direction or the other.
- 4y ago
- yowzadave 4y agoIsn’t this the same pattern that other fields have followed as they gradually became more automated? A hundred years ago, a cobbler was a skilled craftsperson who combined creative problem-solving with a variety of techniques to hand-make shoes to the precise specifications of each foot. Today, shoes are made in a factory, with humans limited to watching the line to catch the occasional defect.
- minusf 4y agothere are still handmade shoes and suits. if i could afford them, i wouldnt buy mass produced stuff where i have to fit into the producers sizing chart. a big part of me not liking windows and preferring the open source world was also not wanting to use the lowest common denominator quality operating system and applications. handmade, handcrafted stuff will be always head and shoulders above the rest, software included.
- DennisP 4y agoFor now at least, I think it's more likely to automate the boring parts of programming so we can stay focused on the creative stuff. It'd be like the first result of a quick google search always gives a concise blog post covering the exact language features and library calls we're looking for.
- skybrian 4y agoWell, code reviewer anyway. Might be a good idea to add “includes unit tests” in the prompt?