3 ms·
Why companies can’t quit Jack Welch’s much-hated employee-ranking system
- cratermoon 4y agoThe quotes from Dick Grote seem to suggest that it's possible to use stack-ranking sensibly, but the article doesn't clarify.
- credit_guy 4y agoThis is bogus. Maybe Jack Welch used this system, but humans just like to grade on a curve. Ever since we are kids. Who's the greatest martial artist of all times? Bruce Lee (or Jackie Chan). Who's the greatest basketball player? Obviously Michael Jordan. And next? LeBron, or maybe Curry. We rank people. That's what we do. Jack Welch did not invent that.
- acdha 4y agoIt’s not that simple: the problem with stack ranking is that it overrides human judgement by _forcing_ some people into the under-performing category. This is basically comes back to Goodhart’s law: if you turn management into a simple algorithm, you create a powerful incentive for people to game the metrics, ranging from the type of work you select or how you report it to sabotaging a coworker or even managers hiring someone marginal so they can jettison them rather than one of their favored employees. The problem is that lack of discretion, and that was what Jack Welch made famous while he successfully turned GE into a formerly great company.
- hd95489 4y agoTo me it would make sense to stack rank company wide, if you dropped employees to the bottom 10% you would get back filled out of the bottom 50%. As such you would only ever drop true underperforming employees.
- mjfl 4y agoIn Jack Welch's words, it's more merciful to do this, than keep someone around for a decade, and then suddenly fire them (because their performance has been terrible, below 10th percentile, for 10 years). It allows them to find a job where they fit better, sooner, instead of feeling surprised and betrayed late in their career.
- notfromhere 4y agoJack Welch is not a business genius. His antics blew up GE and the company has never recovered. His reputation has no connection with the reality of what his tenure did to the company. Unfortunately, we're all stuck with a bunch of Jack Welch acolytes running corporate America.
- mjfl 4y agoor did Jeff Immelt squander it? It took almost 20 years for GE to fall apart, after all. I think that's more likely. At the end of Jack's tenure, GE was one of the biggest, most profitable companies in the world.
- acdha 4y agoHe introduced financialization, which turned GE from a company which made useful things to an unregulated bank pursuing high-risk strategies. He promoted the idea that companies should only be loyal to shareholders, and in addition to cutting jobs he pushed offshore which hollowed out American manufacturing and cities, and helped build countries like China into strong competitors. That’s his legacy, not his successor’s.
- musicale 4y agoSo many things wrong with that, it's amazing anyone could say it with a straight face.
- andrewstuart 4y agoWhy do employees need to be ranked at all?
- musicale 4y agoOn face value it makes perfect sense, because why would you want to lay off your top performers? As noted in the article the main downside are that it incentivizes a range of destructive and anti-social behaviors.
- etempleton 4y agoThe issue is it works at first. You get rid of the worst performers and the people no one can stand. But after that, everyone knows the game. Everyone starts sucking up to their boss. If some kind of peer review or 360 review is also present employees are encouraged to create pacts to review each other well. You don’t need to be the best, but, just not the worst. You throw your coworker under the bus for the team missing the deadline. Everyone becomes paranoid. Productivity drops because everyone is spending 25 percent of their time and brain power on office politics. The poor saps that don’t are the ones fired.
- etempleton 4y agoSo you can eventually justify firing them.