3 ms·
I think Christopher Tolkien pretty much did this. And what was great was the way he edited (with his father's blessing), did a small amount of continuation, as
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
I think Christopher Tolkien pretty much did this. And what was great was the way he edited (with his father's blessing), did a small amount of continuation, as well as published the original notes, so we could all see the authorial process.
However in Tolkien's case, there was an explicit father son work relationship that was grounded in their mutual love and family life, and the fact that both had similar education, etc.
My understanding is Brian Herbert was estranged from his father and they had a bad relationship.
And Brian Herbert brought in an outside writer (Kevin J Anderson) to do a lot (most?) of the actual writing.
The world of Dune fans would have been better served if Herbert had simply published his father's notes, maybe with some annotations or reflections.
Given the above, and as hasn't provided those notes and documents he apparently found, and as the plot veers quite a bit in tone from what Frank Herbert seemed to me to have in mind, I actually have a hard time believing the notes he is apparently working from actually exist.
Further, the published works he has created are really not good.