3 ms·
It doesn't matter if the NXDOMAIN is forged or not (or whether forgery is detected or not). It's not like you can unforge and extract the original IP from such
by tedunangst 15y ago
It doesn't matter if the NXDOMAIN is forged or not (or whether forgery is detected or not). It's not like you can unforge and extract the original IP from such a response. Your browser can flash all the red warning lights it wants, you're not going to connect to the naughty site. DNSSEC does absolutely nothing to impede DNS blacklisting.
- wmf 15y agoThat's never been the issue. When people claim that "SOPA breaks DNSSEC" (note they don't say the reverse) they mean that a SOPA blockage looks the same as a MITM attack from the client's perspective. As I've explained earlier, ISPs can choose to make it look like a DNS server outage instead of an MITM; this might produce fewer misleading errors in the browser. SOPA works fine as written, it just makes DNS debugging harder. "Users running secure applications have a need to distinguish between policy-based failures and failures caused, for example, by the presence of an attack or a hostile network, or else downgrade attacks would likely be prolific." http://www.circleid.com/pdf/PROTECT-IP-Technical-Whitepaper-Final.pdf http://www.circleid.com/pdf/PROTECT-IP-Technical-Whitepaper-...