4 ms·
And yet “average” people buy and sell MacBooks every day without imagining, let alone experiencing those problems. It is only thieves and ideologues who actual
by brookst 4y ago
And yet “average” people buy and sell MacBooks every day without imagining, let alone experiencing those problems.
It is only thieves and ideologues who actually experience any difficulty. And while I’m all for righteous purity, I am also happy knowing that the thief who stole my MacBook from Spaces coworking in San Jose (do not ever use Spaces!) will get nothing for the risk they took, and/or that a buyer taking a too good to be true deal will get a brick.
Yes, I like this world better than the free-open-insecure alternative.
- tshaddox 4y ago> And while I’m all for righteous purity, I am also happy knowing that the thief who stole my MacBook from Spaces coworking in San Jose (do not ever use Spaces!) will get nothing for the risk they took, and/or that a buyer taking a too good to be true deal will get a brick. That might be a minor consolation, but the bigger point is that this will (hopefully) significantly disrupt the market for shady used MacBook sales and thus the incentive to target MacBooks for theft.
- zakki 4y agoThere is n=1 up there that someone is not stealing his laptop. He just forgot his firmware password. His Find My account still showing the device, but Apple doesn’t want to unlock it because he lost his receipt.
- sbuk 4y agoIt's unfortunate, for sure, but the warnings are abundant; in not so many words don't forget these passwords or the consequences will be dire. Losing receipts for big ticket items is, I'm afraid to say, irresponsible. File the hard copy, or scan and save in multiple secure locations. The burden of proof of ownership is on the owner, it cannot be any other way. Heck, I'm sure a credit card receipt would do. Find it on a bank statement and go to small claims in the worst case.
- brookst 4y agoSure. And that sucks. But do is it worth incentivizing the theft of n = many laptops? This is the government encryption backdoor all over again. There is no such thing as a security backdoor that can be used only by good guys. If Apple can’t determine someone is the legitimate owner of a locked device, they have two choices: allow thieves to unlock devices, resulting in more theft. Or decline to unlock for some legitimate owners who chose to lock their device and not take precautions. It’s a tough choice, but I think Apple is making the right one here. You may disagree, and that’s fine.
- olliej 4y agoOk, so what is the metric Apple should use for deciding whether someone has lost their password or someone has stolen a laptop? Or should Apple just remove the activation lock feature, that was added specifically in response to large amounts of theft because we don’t think those thefts are going to happen any more?