3 ms·
> In fact, any specific piece of art can be removed and it will still work the same and this is also incredibly important. This is provably false: if any speci
by jacquesm 4y ago
> In fact, any specific piece of art can be removed and it will still work the same and this is also incredibly important.
This is provably false: if any specific piece can be removed and there is no difference then you can keep doing that until there is no art left. I'd bet a very substantial amount of money that the output at that point will definitely have changed. Induction is a powerful thing.
- williamcotton 4y agoI didn’t say remove all the art, I said remove a specific piece of art. No one needs to do thought experiments. Remove all the plaintiff’s works, retrain the model, and the model is still just as useful. Or if we want to do thought experiments, randomly remove any thousand images and the tool is still just as useful. If it’s random, not specific images, that are removed, then it is non-specific images that power the tool… yes, millions of those images, so a specific quantity is required but no specific works.