5 ms·
Where I see VR go the most wrong is, particularly when business people get involved, is the mistake of trying to recreate reality. I have at least a Library of
by hinkley 4y ago
Where I see VR go the most wrong is, particularly when business people get involved, is the mistake of trying to recreate reality. I have at least a Library of Congress on my computer, which I can access without having to deal with Euclidean Geometry. I don't schlep through miles of shelves looking for something. I just look for it. That's profoundly important to the reasons why we went to digital from analog.
If you want to make VR "work", you have to also have non-Euclidean Geometry. Things need to be smaller on the outside. You need to be able to affect the "world" through intention, not action. In a word, you need magic. Which dovetails pretty well with video games.
- wkat4242 4y agoThe trying to create reality is simply recreating familiar paradigms to help new users hat a foothold. You can't jump right into the most modern user interface. Even voor advanced users. This is why a 'modern' desktop still mimicks a messy desk from a 70s office worker. The very easiest computers skipped that step due to technical limitations but the mainstream users had a hard time grokking them. Only with the mobile phone have we started to really leave that behind. VR will be similarly rooted in the past until people find their footing and embrace new ways to interact. And why meeting rooms in VR have to have chairs, tables and people have to draw on virtual whiteboards instead of just in the space in front of them in 3D. The tech is getting there, but our minds take even more time.
- duxup 4y agoDoes anyone want that? A meeting room? They are familiar sure, but who wants to put on a headset for a meeting…. I feel like being familiar here is also being uninteresting.
- chaostheory 4y agoConversely, who wants to look at flat boxes of people on a flat screen? Imo the best use case for VR isn’t in replacing reality. Its best use case is to mimic reality for people who are remote. VR meetings are way better than zoom or teams video meetings. I can also tell you that VR ping pong or VR mini golf are both way better than just having a FaceTime call. People who refuse to even try modern VR aren’t going to come to this realization.
- cableshaft 4y agoVR ping pong (Elevens) and VR mini golf (Walkabout Mini Golf) are awesome. Feels pretty damn close to the real thing, close enough I think skills gained there would translate to the physical game. And you don't need good weather, have to travel, or have to wait for other players to play the mini golf. Also being a video game allows Walkabout to do some courses that just wouldn't be feasible (not physically possible or too expensive to build) in real life, like the Myst puzzle one, or that one hole that's based on M.C. Escher's Relativity that alters gravity depending on where your ball is at. Still need to play them multiplayer, but I want to. I watched a game played in VR which was basically an interview with the creator of Myst and that was a lot of fun[1]. I think this is what you're referring to, meetings being more fun over a game of mini-golf than just a Zoom call. [1]: https://youtu.be/LhScgbtUos4 https://youtu.be/LhScgbtUos4
- kibwen 4y agoIn the 70s, it made sense to use metaphors based on experience with the physical world, because we had no alternative. Here in the 2020s, you can skip the clunky skeuomorphism and just assume experience with the digital world. The problem is that VR has always been sold in terms of being a replacement for the physical world, and as it turns out, that's just plain worse than the digital equivalents that we already have. I don't need a VR library full of fake volumes of Encyclopedia Brittanica, because I already have Wikipedia, whose UX is far more convenient, and would only be made worse by imposing a physical metaphor. Unfortunately, anyone who's sunk a few tens of billions of dollars into VR will naturally be resistant to the idea that the spaces that they've so painstakingly made are worse than what they were intended to replace. Why would I want to strap this phone to my face? Nobody has yet found an answer to that question, aside from a handful of first-person video games.
- chaostheory 4y ago> Why would I want to strap this phone to my face? This is VR’s biggest problem. Normal people aren’t willing to put on a bucket on their face, even if it represents the future. Instead most people would rather form all kinds of weird and untrue speculation. Case in point: “I don't need a VR library full of fake volumes of Encyclopedia Brittanica, because I already have Wikipedia” No one has actually built a library in VR because the screen resolution is too poor for reading large amounts of text. All you’ve proved is that you still haven’t tried modern VR.
- Animats 4y agoThat's where Apple comes in. Apple convinced people that wearing iDweebs in their ears in public was OK.
- acdha 4y agoI think that illustrates the scale of the problem: wearing headphones in public was already normalized at least as far back as the Walkman craze, AirPods are arguably the most successful AR experience on the market with their unobtrusive experience, and they’re towards the higher end of the price range but not outliers for a premium product. It is not unreasonable to fear that personal AR isn’t going to get popular until goggles are comparable in size to regular glasses.
- wkat4242 4y agoSorry for the many autocorrect errors, it was late.. It's too late to edit it now. The correct post should have read like this: The trying to create reality is simply recreating familiar paradigms to help new users get a foothold. You can't jump right into the most modern user interface. Even for advanced users. This is why a 'modern' desktop still mimicks a messy desk from a 70s office worker. The very earliest computers skipped that step due to technical limitations but the mainstream users had a hard time grokking them. Only with the mobile phone have we started to really leave that behind. VR will be similarly rooted in the past until people find their footing and embrace new ways to interact. And why meeting rooms in VR have to have chairs, tables and people have to draw on virtual whiteboards instead of just in the space in front of them in 3D. The tech is getting there, but our minds take even more time.
- duxup 4y agoThere was an article a while back where there was some debate about how the metaverse had failed to provide a stadium like quality experience with thousands of attendees, rather they created a sort of conference room experience. I couldn’t help but think that I wanted neither and the folks pushing this idea were people who wanted conference rooms or stadiums of people watching them, but I’m not sure anyone else would be interested.
- SLHamlet 4y agoJenova Chen, creator of Journey, got 4000 avatars per server into a show over the holidays: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TrOZgyBPF90&list=PPSV https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TrOZgyBPF90&list=PPSV
- peterclary 4y agoSome of this is people wanting to recreate the artificial scarcity of the real world so that they can profit from it, see the recent land rush in some nascent proto-Metaverse platforms, where people are betting that their purchase will have some medium-term value and an appreciating long-term value. But this is also similar to the idea that some people want their MMORPGs to have a single, non-sharded instance, where everybody can play at once, which sounds hellish to me TBH. Millions of people all competing for the same items, quests, etc. If you were offered a VR version of Disneyland, which would you prefer? One where there were very few people and you could walk more or less directly onto the rides? Or one where the streets are packed and the queue times are multiple-hours long? The rush to reproduce these less desirable experiences in VR is utterly depressing, and for that matter the descriptions of The Street in Snow Crash didn't sound that appealing to me either.
- hinkley 4y agoThere's a happy medium where the scarcity is logarithmic rather than volume versus area (what is that, n^2/3?). You could have a row of clubs on The Street that are proportional to each other but not to their interiors. All clubs are 5 meters wide. Large clubs are 7 meters wide, and massive clubs go to 10. You can look at the outside and predict what's going on beneath without walking by a SuperWalmart. And then I believe it's in Neverwhere (?) where parts of the spaces of the Underground are borrowed from other places. So the average density is always the same but pockets can still be made.
- hinkley 4y agoContinuing this thought instead of editing: If you're worried about how to handle physics, a really simple solution here would be to slice your VR onto multiple planes of existence, from outside to inside. You have a virtual street full of fifty businesses, you can lay out the insides of the business into a Euclidean space, and then doorways are wormholes from a less dense plane to a more dense one, so you can walk around the block faster than you can walk through one of the buildings. Recurse that for as many layers of tesseract as you want to implement (why not rooms in the building that are bigger than the inside of the building too?). But once you've broken 1:1 people are going to want to change their minds, so you might be better off using some sort of graph to represent space instead of a 3d matrix.
- klondike_klive 4y agoI remember my mind being blown in the videogame Descent on (I think) the Playstation - you fly your ship into a little cube and enter a vast space. It's how I imagine people would have felt playing Pac Man with its screen wrapping - a thing that's only possible (in realtime at least) in videogames. You're watching a world being created with new physics.