3 ms·
Is that 'They also consumed less power' correct? http://datasheet.digchip.com/205/205-00367-0-970.pdf http://datasheet.digchip.com/205/205-00367-0-970.pdf give
by Someone 15y ago
Is that 'They also consumed less power' correct?
http://datasheet.digchip.com/205/205-00367-0-970.pdf http://datasheet.digchip.com/205/205-00367-0-970.pdf gives typical power dissipation as 42W @1.8 GHz, 1.3v
For a later design, http://datasheets.chipdb.org/IBM/PowerPC/970/PowerPC-970FX.pdf http://datasheets.chipdb.org/IBM/PowerPC/970/PowerPC-970FX.p..., section 3.1.5 gives 60W for the 2.2 GHz version at 105 degrees Celsius.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Pentium_4_microprocessors http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Intel_Pentium_4_micropr... gives comparable values for the TDP for 2002-era Pentiums.
I get the impression that IBM's data is real max (but 'Maximum power at 85 C is the ONLY value that is guaranteed by Manufacturing Test.'), while TDP may be lower than max (Reading http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_Design_Power http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermal_Design_Power)
Or am I overlooking a factor for #CPUs?
I always thought the water cooling was either an effort to decrease noise or over engineering or preparation for more cores and/or more speed (either of which were a necessity to keep up with Intel chips).
- mikeash 15y agoI think you're comparing things a little too early. In 2002, things were still very much up in the air. In hindsight, the PowerPC first started showing signs of real trouble when Apple had to de-rate the entire Power Mac G4 line by 50MHz between the initial announcement and the first ship, but it still did fairly well for quite a while. It wasn't until close to the switch when the promised 3.0GHz G5 failed to materialize that the differences really got big. The Intel switch wasn't announced until 2005 and didn't happen until 2006. I don't have hard data, but as far as I know, once Macs went Intel, they all got significantly faster and cooler. This was most visible at the top of the line. The last Power Mac G5 had the liquid cooling system and the top end ran four cores at 2.5GHz. I don't know about the liquid cooled model in particular, but the G5s in general were notorious for being noisy due to fans. The first Mac Pro which replaced it ran 8 cores at 3.0GHz and was known to be astonishingly silent. I personally used one as my main work computer for years and it was impossible to get the fans to run fast enough to be audible unless you disabled the smart controls by e.g. leaving a kernel panic on the screen for a while. Obviously, this could be due to more advanced thermal design as well, but even allowing for that, you have twice as many cores, running at a higher clock rate, vastly faster in most real-world use, and with a much simpler cooling system. The laptops had a similar story. The PowerBook G4s would get astonishingly hot, while the MacBooks were much less bad (although still not great initially).