3 ms·
It is remarkable how many HN readers have strong opinions, strongly held about how to do a job that they haven't done, nor ever seen done. The job of a legisla
by jfengel 4y ago
It is remarkable how many HN readers have strong opinions, strongly held about how to do a job that they haven't done, nor ever seen done.
The job of a legislator is famously sausage-making: something that's gross even if the final product is acceptable. If it was done the way an outsider demanded it be done, it wouldn't be done at all.
There's legitimate disagreement on whether legislators' communications are viable public records. But I'd think that disagreement would be a lot more meaningful if it were held among people who had at least some idea what the job entailed.
- rahimnathwani 4y ago"But I'd think that disagreement would be a lot more meaningful if it were held among people who had at least some idea what the job entailed." You know what would help me get such an idea? Access to emails, calendars and other records.
- jfengel 4y agoNone of that is likely to mean much without the context. It's like reading a cutting edge journal article without having taken high school science.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoWhat is the minimum level of knowledge you think I need, before I can understanding the meaning of a legislator's records?