5 ms·
Arizona legislature changes rules on retaining correspondence
- kneebonian 4y ago[flagged]
- seanw444 4y agoRepublicans bad, Joe Biden won the election, yada yada... I just want an open government, man. Why is that too much to ask?
- munificent 4y ago> Why is that too much to ask? Because corrupt people want to be corrupt.
- AuthorizedCust 4y agoWhen party X acts wrongly, it hands a win to party Y. Here, the Arizona GOP is handing Arizona Democrats an easy moral victory. When you no longer support something as essential as open records, you’ve sunk to despotism. Open records should generally be like a ratchet: once clicked, you can’t go back.
- duxup 4y agoI’ve found, to my disappointment, that important but subtle nuances of government don’t seem to motivate voters :(
- irrational 4y agosubtle?
- duxup 4y agoYes, my bad.
- snarf21 4y agoWho will watch the watchers? This should reiterate to everyone that the real enemy is not an R or a D but power at any cost and the money that enables it.
- Fezzik 4y agoFrom the very beginning of the article this resulted from “new rules adopted by majority Republicans over vigorous opposition from minority Democrats.” Which is not to exempt Democrats from any due criticism, but this is in fact a problem from only one side of the aisle.
- bluGill 4y agoIs it, or is the minority of Democrats only not doing it because the Republicans are, but they would be happy to do it if they were a majority - and the minority Republicans would scream about how bad it was. I wish the above cynicism wasn't well warranted in many cases.
- munk-a 4y agoI think we're coming up on and partially into a serious issue here though - when the partisanship gets to a certain point "X acts wrongly" is no longer accepted as fact or viewed important by the X voters. At a certain point "X acts wrongly" is viewed (either by the voters or by partisan media) as so inconsequential compared to the "evils" of Y that X remains the correct choice. There is always some level of this - that's perfectly natural, in our minds a lot of things go into decisions. However, we've reached the point where corruption, embracing antivax, and pursuing underage partners - all amongst a plethora of other examples... those are no longer ills strong enough to lower X below the level of Y in the eyes of a very significant portion of the electorship.
- TylerE 4y agoIt's even worse than that. X voters don't think X is wrong, and they're being persecuted by Y.
- tshaddox 4y ago> At a certain point "X acts wrongly" is viewed (either by the voters or by partisan media) as so inconsequential compared to the "evils" of Y that X remains the correct choice. Surely that can be a valid conclusion of a reasonable person though, right? Party X can just actually be better than Party Y and that can still be true when Party X does some bad things. In my view, this doesn't become problematic partisanship until a significant chunk of value someone is getting from their party comes from their own sense of identity as a supporter of that party, because that sense of identity has nothing to do with the policies or other actions of the party in question: it's by definition completely divorced from any serious political estimation of the virtues and ills of a party.
- munk-a 4y agoI completely agree with you about it being a valid conclusion from a reasonable person. I think we all do that to some extent - we're always softer on "our team"... but it's also quite rational to look at a minor corruption scandal and feel it's outweighed by a politician's view on some highly sensitive topic like reproductive rights. The issue is that we're taking it to extremes.
- tptacek 4y agoWell then, a surprising number of states are despotic, because deliberative process privilege is indeed textbook public records law.
- BaseballPhysics 4y ago> Here, the Arizona GOP is handing the Arizona Democrats an easy moral victory. You're assuming morals play any role in the modern world of extreme partisan politics. If the last 6 years has proven anything, it's that partisan affiliation is more powerful than morals or good governance for at least 40% of the US population.
- munk-a 4y ago> for at least 40% of the US population. I think the GOP hardline is about 35% of the population - those are voters politicians could eat babies in front of without losing their votes. I think politics is pretty symmetrical (but not fully) so I think it's pretty safe to bump your estimate up to 60% of the US population... depending on how cynical you are I don't think 80% is out of the question. People who don't just look at D or R on a ballot are in the minority of American voters.
- phpisthebest 4y agoNo, it is more like 23+/-5% of population is hard line Democrat, 23+/-5% of the population is hard line Republican, people in both of those groups will vote the party no matter what, "politicians could eat babies in front of without losing their votes" from either camp 54% of the population are combination of Independents or Single Issue Voters. That is what sets the outcome of national elections
- vkou 4y agoIf moral victories could actually turn into political victories, this country would have purged the entirety of one party, and most of the other party decades ago. Instead, winning is seen as more important than doing the right thing, and, well, we get the exact consequence of those values.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Alupis 4y ago> Here, the Arizona GOP is handing Arizona Democrats an easy moral victory. Right, and just like with the Georgia voting laws, it doesn't matter that a bunch of other states already have similar laws and/or the new law is a return to the status quo - it only matters when it's the "other side" that does it. Now, that's what motivates people to vote, apparently.
- hcurtiss 4y agoI've worked with legislators in a variety of capacities. In my view, this is a good thing. In order to compromise, politicians need to be able to speak freely with one-another and with the public about matters that may not on their face be terribly politic. I attribute a great deal of the current polarization to the fact that politicians cannot have private conversations. Personally, I would favor more exemptions. The open government/pure democracy types hammer on their right to know everything their elected representatives are doing, but I don't see it that way. I send them to get the best outcomes they can for their constituents. I'll judge them on the end result and either send them back, or send somebody else. But the idea that I need to see all their texts and emails is, in my view, ridiculous. Worse, it means nobody can take nuanced/compromising positions. And that's bad for America.
- thinking4real 4y ago“The government doesn’t respect your privacy, but you should respect its privacy” Seriously?
- ancientworldnow 4y agoIt is in fact possible to communicate outside of email or other digitally recorded mediums.
- SamReidHughes 4y agoThat adds another hurdle and is generally just undermining ability of legislators to communicate.
- irrational 4y agoGetting up and walking down the hall is a hurdle?
- miguelazo 4y agoPublic servants should have nothing to hide if they're actually representing the public's interests.
- tptacek 4y agoThere are similar exemptions in other states. Illinois has a very toothy FOIA law (5 day deadline for responses, few exemptions, and fee recovery for court cases, s much so that you can sometimes get a FOIA suit done on contingency). But legislative deliberation is exempt. (I'm in the middle of a FOIA controversy in Illinois about this issue.)
- ceejayoz 4y agoDeliberation tends to be specifically and broadly exempt. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deliberative_process_privilege https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deliberative_process_privilege
- livueta 4y agoThe WA legislature is, unfortunately, trying something similar - again: https://archive.is/jY1ba https://archive.is/jY1ba > When Washington legislators tried to exempt themselves from the Public Records Act nearly five years ago, thousands of Washingtonians angrily emailed or phoned Gov. Jay Inslee’s office. Inslee vetoed the measure. We considered SB 6617 a dead letter. Forever. > But now the Washington Legislature is asserting that legislators have a previously unknown personal privilege to withhold from public disclosure the documents they use in their work for the people.
- ibejoeb 4y agoThankfully it's toothy. In a place that operates black sites for American citizens, it's gotta be. https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/oct/19/homan-square-chicago-police-disappeared-thousands https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/oct/19/homan-square...
- chaps 4y agoA sibbling comment pointed out that deliberative process is widely abused and yes, absolutely it is. Almost sued the IL Senate a bunch of years back when they tried to argue that email metadata was exempt under legislative deliberation. They conceded before it got there, but not before sending us a dense letter on some.. remarkably fancy.. paper telling that was basically them airing their grievances about having to give the metadata. If you haven't seen, alderfolk in Chicago are in a weird place as well. Since aldermanic offices aren't gov offices, records within those offices are exempt. It's gotten down to just a few in the past few years, but there were a tonnn of alderfolk whose official city email account were private domains, aol, msn, etc. The PAC has been very weak-handed in pushing against aldermanic office issues. Similar happened with the mayor's office trying to argue that a pro bono consultant's emails were exempt because they were sent from her private account. Sued and won on that, but that's all to say.. there's still work to do.
- SamReidHughes 4y agoThis is the correct move -- having their communications publicly accessible undermines legislator's ability to do their job.
- nerdponx 4y agoHow so?
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoI'll try to steelman it. Legislation is all about compromise (or at least it was, back when legislators worked). There's a lot of give and take, of people modifying positions they didn't hold all that tightly in order to gain on the positions that they really care about. That means that people say one thing on day 1, say something differently on day 5, and vote still a third way on day 10. If you're going to "expose" all of that, you can make every one of them look like a hypocrite with zero principles. In many cases that may be true, but you can make it look far worse than it is. And if you do that, then nobody can work with any give and take, for fear that the press will destroy them. As I said, I think that's the steelman. That doesn't necessarily mean that I believe it...
- dekken_ 4y agoYou may state whatever you like, it doesn't mean it's true
- guelo 4y agoOnly legislators but no other government entity? They are supposed to work for us. Your boss has access to your emails.
- SamReidHughes 4y agoThe executive branch needs its records accessible, at least to the legislature, so that the legislature can see what it's doing. FOIA laws are an extension of this concept to the general public. They are the ones carrying the stick, and they need visibility. When we negotiate treaties, private conversations between leaders are useful and productive. The same goes when negotiating laws. Voters already have the most important visibility into legislative output: the laws that get passed and how their representative voted.
- guelo 4y ago[flagged]
- irrational 4y agoBecoming? I thought we left becoming behind years ago.
- guelo 4y agoI was flagged. You're not allowed to criticize the GOP on HN :(
- lr4444lr 4y agoThis is not an accurate headline. They exempted specific communications, for which analogous provisions have long existed in other states.
- anigbrowl 4y agoI can revert it to the more anodyne original ('Legislature changes rules for retaining correspondence'), but I thought he first line of the article better summarized the contested nature of the change.
- tptacek 4y agoIt depends on whether you want to perfectly represent the article or make the threads less of a debacle. I'd dial the title way back if you care more about the latter.
- lcnPylGDnU4H9OF 4y agoI don't sign in to my work email on my devices so I can tell my employer with a straight face that my device isn't their device. If legislators are really worried about their personal communications being leaked, they should keep those separate from their work communications.
- EMM_386 4y ago> One of the most well-known of those efforts was a series of emails that Virginia Thomas, wife of U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas and a supporter of former President Donald Trump, sent to a host of state Republican House and Senate members just days after Biden won the election. She urged members to throw out Biden's delegates to the Electoral College and replace them with a GOP slate. This is serious stuff and the "solution" in this case is to prevent people from getting the emails via FOIA? Isn't the entire point of the FOIA to allow for more transparency in government?
- bluGill 4y agoTransparency needs to be balanced with the need for some conversations to be easy and transident. If you can get my email, that means i have to spend several days writing them - following the full process I learned in 3rd grade: rough draft, review, final draft... These have to be on different days (just look at anything I write here - they often look great when I write them, but a day latter I see all the stupid mistakes in grammar and spelling). What I didn't learn in 3rd grade but is required is a separate lawyer to review everything as well. The above process needs to apply even for the simple "are you free for lunch today". Or instead I can just quit using email and drop back to phone calls (which few people ever record), or face to face conversations - which again are never recorded. Just because we can save emails forever doesn't mean we should.
- gamblor956 4y agoFar-right "conservative" activists use work phones to plot to overthrow government. They fail, and get caught. Rational solution: investigate, and proceed with normal criminal process if appropriate, to deter future such behavior. Far-right "conservative" solution: ban long-term retention of communications data so that future far-right attempts to overthrow the government can't be prosecuted. You really can't make this up.