3 ms·
I don't. Information comes with many different rights: copy-right is the right to make copies; "moral rights" were mentioned in a few of my UK job contracts an
by ben_w 4y ago
I don't.
Information comes with many different rights: copy-right is the right to make copies; "moral rights" were mentioned in a few of my UK job contracts and that's "the right to be identified as the author of a work"; database rights are for collections of statements of fact that are not eligible for copyright but which were deemed to be worth protecting anyway for much the same reasons.
Even if copyright is totally eliminated from law by the mere existence of these AI[0], we may well retain the aforementioned "moral rights". And even if it is totally legal, there's also a strong possibility of it being considered gauche to use an AI trained on the works of those that don't like this.
[0] https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/10/09/an-end-to-copyright/ https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/10/09/an-end-to-c...
- hnfong 4y agoMoral rights is indeed "the right to be identified as the author of a work". I don't think it means the author has a right to all similar styles. If I can legally ask somebody to paint me something in the style of a famous (living) artist, that person presumably having seen and studied their famous works for a while, why should I not be able to ask the AI to do the same thing? (I understand there might be people who think even a human person emulating the style of another artist is morally wrong, but at least that's a consistent argument)
- ben_w 4y agoMoral arguments aren't very consistent, in my experience — when I first heard someone suggest that people start with feelings and then create a narrative (not necessarily coherent) to fit those feelings, a lot of the weird things started to make a lot more sense. I'm told that for people who think Rolex watches are important, a fake Rolex is much worse than not having a Rolex at all: the item is a signal much like a peacock tail, the signal is de-valued by making things easy.
- blibble 4y agoit's quite common in UK contracts of employment to try and transfer the moral rights to the Employer but this isn't enforceable, they cannot be transferred