4 ms·
It's disheartening because it's a great loss to everybody. Almost none of the people that were generating images in a style of some artist will contact this art
by scotty79 4y ago
It's disheartening because it's a great loss to everybody. Almost none of the people that were generating images in a style of some artist will contact this artist and pay to have an image created.
So many artists styles could have gone viral and actually bring those artists some work from the people who tried the AI commercially and got results that weren't completely satisfactory. Now barely anyone will ever have any contact with their art (relatively speaking vs scenario of virality).
Basically the only people who win are the lawyers and handful of artists that were mislead by lawyers primitive argumentation. Everybody else looses. First and foremost artists and art lovers but also AI researchers and hardware manufacturers.
- Avicebron 4y agoThey could have gone viral because an AI recreated their art style to the degree that they could? And therefore people would abandon the AI to pay the artist individually? I'm not sure I follow, wouldn't those people just us the AI to continue creating what they want unless you think that driving the artist to compete monetarily with an AI will somehow work in the artist's favor?
- scotty79 4y ago> They could have gone viral because an AI recreated their art style to the degree that they could? I didn't know of any artist (except for long dead ones) that I saw the names of in prompts. > And therefore people would abandon the AI to pay the artist individually? If you have particular commercial needs you discovered through the use of AI you might want to go to the source, not for everything, but for some things. It might be easier to explain some of the stuff you need to a live human than to AI. AI images are still very imperfect and prompts are not easy to create.
- l33tman 4y agoI had absolute zero interest in digital art before, now I have some and would at least react to the artists often mentioned in prompts. They didn't get any money from me before, but the chance is > 0.0 now at least, I might at some point commission some original digital art and now I would checkout both the AI and the humans. Before this I might instead have opted for a stock photo for $5. But who knows how the numbers turn out in the long run. I don't think the artists is the group that's going to get the most annoyed in the next couple of years - copy writers and programmers, 3D artists, basically anybody who's doing grunt work.. I think the main problem with all of this is that it has entered our lives so fast, compared to other revolutions.
- HelloMcFly 4y ago> So many artists styles could have gone viral and actually bring those artists some work from the people who tried the AI commercially and got results that weren't completely satisfactory. I think it's quite presumptuous to unequivocally state that artists lose with this. Is it a complicated situation? Yes, of course, too complicated for such certainty. That's a wonderful thing to believe, but it's just as plausible (I'd argue far, far more plausible as the tech improves) that clients who would formerly pay for their work no longer have to.
- scotty79 4y agoIt's absolute and total loss for every artist for nearly any artist that won't voluntarily opt-in. When you consider laws regarding organ donors you might appreciate how socially harmful might be wrong defaults.
- scotty79 4y ago> but it's just as plausible (I'd argue far, far more plausible as the tech improves) that clients who would formerly pay for their work no longer have to. With the volume of AI art generated was an even single actual case of that?
- haswell 4y agoThis reads like you know what’s best for artists and takes their point of view completely for granted. As a photographer, I can’t claim to have or require a fraction of the skills used by creators of hand-made art. And even I am not excited about some AI slurping up my best work and commoditizing it. > So many artists styles could have gone viral and actually bring those artists some work I’ve seen this sentiment, but it does not match the reality we see play out on the web every day. The amount of literal content stealing and “creative reposting” that happens with absolutely zero attribution to the actual artist is quite extensive. It makes no sense to me that the introduction of an AI tool would suddenly solve the problem of attribution instead of just make it far easier to steal content while making it harder to detect or take action against such theft.
- hooverd 4y agoOn top of that, deliberately training models to copy an artists work and antagonizing the artist about it.
- scotty79 4y ago> This reads like you know what’s best for artists and takes their point of view completely for granted. I think I know that little better than lawyers do. Even if only because I had zero financial incentive when I formed my opinions. > As a photographer, I can’t claim to have or require a fraction of the skills used by creators of hand-made art. And even I am not excited about some AI slurping up my best work and commoditizing it. I know it doesn't feel great. But your art has already been commoditized. There are hundreds photographers perfectly capable of replicating your style and many of them do it completely accidentally. The value of your art is a personal element not the content itself. What's valuable is your service and the name you made for yourself. AI gives an artist a ticket to a lottery that can strongly boost their name without doing any additional service. > The amount of literal content stealing and “creative reposting” that happens with absolutely zero attribution to the actual artist is quite extensive. I wonder how much money you've lost due to that. Besides, attribution is naturally built into those "plagiarist" prompts for AI. As for prompts that don't mention specific authors ... you shouldn't kid yourself that AI won't be able to completely naturally recreate your style from styles similar to yours even it it never seen yours. After all that's what you did to create your style. You created a variation on similar styles you saw during your education as an artist. > ... just make it far easier to steal content while making it harder to detect or take action against such theft. steal, theft ... what do artists actually loose in those brazen robberies? Copyright conglomerates created language that doesn't reflect reality. But it reflects most primitive human instincts evolved in the world of scarcity not abundance.
- likeclockwork 4y agoPeople keep trying to compensate artists with exposure.