10 ms·
> Stability AI has already announced that it is removing users’ ability to request images in a particular artist’s style and further, that future releases of St
by scotty79 4y ago
> Stability AI has already announced that it is removing users’ ability to request images in a particular artist’s style and further, that future releases of Stable Diffusion will comply with any artist’s requests to remove their images from the training dataset.
This is incredibly disheartening. Who knows how long will it take to progress the tech to the point where anyone will be able to train and run models unrestricted without dealing with lawyer nonsense.
- RandomLensman 4y agoRent seeking by owners of AI machines is OK, but not by copyright owners?
- Kiro 4y agoYes. Abolish all copyright. Are we hackers or not?
- manigandham 4y agoWho is “we”?
- Kiro 4y agoParticipants on a site called Hacker News.
- t433 4y agoSpoiler alert: They're not! This is really Venture Capital News, and accordingly they've appropriated the whole "hacker" image in an attempt at authenticity.
- kragen 4y agopg did originally call it 'startup news' but i don't think you have standing to accuse him of 'appropriating' the term 'hacker' until you've hacked together something of comparable significance to on lisp or viaweb
- TylerE 4y agoYou understand that completely kills OSS as a concept, right?
- krapp 4y agoFree and open source software licenses are redundant in a world where copyright and intellectual property laws don't exist, and no form of media (including software) can legally be owned by anyone.
- kmeisthax 4y agoCasual reminder that the endgame of the GPL was to make software copyright unenforceable.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 4y agoWhy would that be? Huge amount of OSS is released under fully permissive licenses.
- jen20 4y ago“Permissive” provided the code is attributed, which the products you advocate for do not do.
- jeroenhd 4y agoPermissive licenses like "if you use this code you must also make your code available under the same license" form the basis of the world's most often used open source software. Open licenses are not the same as abolishing copyright.
- scotty79 4y agoThose are not permissive licenses. Those are copyleft licenses. As I said, a lot of software uses permissive ones. https://blog.ipleaders.in/permissive-license-copyleft-possible-distinctions/ https://blog.ipleaders.in/permissive-license-copyleft-possib...
- matheusmoreira 4y agoYou have my respect.
- adamsmith143 4y agoI think creating art in the style of an artist is well covered by Fair Use.
- RandomLensman 4y agoEven if it were (which I am not competent to speak on), should that help to enrich some large corporation, for example?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoMake a mouse cartoon in the style of Disney and tell me how well that goes down.
- yokem55 4y agoThat's because you run into trademark laws, not copyright. Not to mention, if you can make the case that your art of the mouse is Parody, then it falls squarely under fair use.
- lxgr 4y agoPlagiarism is very much a matter of copyright, not trademark infringement: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_songs_subject_to_plagiarism_disputes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_songs_subject_to_plagi...
- matheusmoreira 4y agoHere you go. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuphead https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cuphead > The game's creators, brothers Chad and Jared Moldenhauer, took inspiration from the rubber hose style of the golden age of American animation and the surrealist qualities of works of Walt Disney Animation Studios, Fleischer Studios, Warner Bros. Cartoons, MGM Cartoon Studio and Walter Lantz Productions.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoThere is a conspicuous lack of mice in that cartoon.
- healsdata 4y agoI'm not sure I understand the point you're making. Its disheartening that artists can opt-out of having a computer algorithm make derivative versions of their creations? I'm probably on the opposite side of the fence. I do find it disheartening that it's opt-out instead of opt-in. The training set should be limited to public domain and CC-0 until such a time it can comply with attribution; then other CC works could be incorporated.
- t433 4y agoAll art is derivative.
- haswell 4y agoThe definition of “derivative” and its historical context look nothing like the new reality created by generative AI. To continue blindly applying historical understanding to fundamentally new technologies creates huge blind spots, and I’d argue similar to pretending that the creation of ever more destructive weaponry requires no changes to the rules of engagement in warfare. The game has changed.
- scotty79 4y agoIt's disheartening because it's a great loss to everybody. Almost none of the people that were generating images in a style of some artist will contact this artist and pay to have an image created. So many artists styles could have gone viral and actually bring those artists some work from the people who tried the AI commercially and got results that weren't completely satisfactory. Now barely anyone will ever have any contact with their art (relatively speaking vs scenario of virality). Basically the only people who win are the lawyers and handful of artists that were mislead by lawyers primitive argumentation. Everybody else looses. First and foremost artists and art lovers but also AI researchers and hardware manufacturers.
- Avicebron 4y agoThey could have gone viral because an AI recreated their art style to the degree that they could? And therefore people would abandon the AI to pay the artist individually? I'm not sure I follow, wouldn't those people just us the AI to continue creating what they want unless you think that driving the artist to compete monetarily with an AI will somehow work in the artist's favor?
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIt would be a spectacularly shitty world where IP protection is only granted to entities with a legal budget that eclipses the GDP of Antigua, and not to smaller independent creators. The ends of having an useful model like stable diffusion doesn't really justify just ignoring the IP rights of tens of thousands of creators who were already having a pretty rough time making ends meet. That's just a shitty thing to do.
- msla 4y agoIt's already the case that independent creators get their works pulled on bogus copyright claims. Copyright law isn't friendly to small creators, and big creators use it as a cudgel with absolutely no consequences.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoAnd because things are bad we should go ahead and make them worse?
- aliqot 4y agoWhere are all these self trained artists who learned their craft in a bubble, devoid of outside influence from other artists? Is it because there's a better paintbrush now, or is it because that paintbrush is not the 'real' way? This reminds me of the backlash against the wacom community on deviantart in the early days.
- antiterra 4y agoA computer program is not a person, so the argument that stable diffusion does what a person does is of limited relevance.
- usrbinbash 4y agoIs it? The model learns concepts from images, not the images itself. It has developed general solutions explaining light, colors, composition, objects and their relation to one another, facial features and too many more concepts to even begin enumerating them. How is this different from a human studying art, literature, music, etc. to learn concepts and then apply them in creating new pictures, novels or songs?
- antiterra 4y agoIt is different simply because it’s not a human. We can and often do assign laws that affect the automation of something a human can do. For example, installing a device on a firearm that repeatedly pulls the trigger creates a machine gun that is highly restricted legally, regardless of whether a human can easily pull the trigger at the same rate. Further, just because we can talk about how artists, at a high level do the same thing as AI image generators, the actual mechanism is not exactly the same and is therefore still subject to distinct regulation. Even if you were able to somehow establish that computer programs should have the same rights as people (since they are made and used by people,) you’re still not out of the woods. Much debate remains about what creativity and originality means when talking about human generated content in an IP sense, and adding the programmatic aspect doesn’t simplify things. (eg The Sina Qua Non of Copyright is Uniqueness, Not Originality https://tiplj.org/wp-content/uploads/Volumes/v20/v20p327.pdf https://tiplj.org/wp-content/uploads/Volumes/v20/v20p327.pdf)
- haswell 4y ago> Who knows how long will it take to progress the tech to the point where anyone will be able to train and run models unrestricted without dealing with lawyer nonsense. These are orthogonal issues at this point. The one concern I do have is that the “lawyer nonsense” (read: AI companies playing fast and loose with current laws) will stack the regulatory deck against AI technology unnecessarily - essentially because of an unforced error that brings negative attention to the technology. Put another way, these companies are asking to have a spotlight put on them by being so flippant about copyright and ethics issues. This spotlight could have been avoided with better behavior, and the tech would still appear magical and remain one of the most impactful jumps in tech in decades.
- ok123456 4y agoIt's not 'playing fast and loose'. It's an area where there are no existing laws. We're not going to stop AI because some furry deviant art artist complains loudly online.
- haswell 4y agoAre the existing laws written in a way that is favorable to generative AI? No. But the laws do exist. Whether or not one believes those laws apply to generative AI seems to be based on one's belief in how similar that AI software is to humans. I'd argue that systematically ingesting 2.3 billion images is not remotely human (one of a myriad of reasons the comparisons break down), and that it is a long stretch to claim that this falls into the realm of fair use as originally envisioned. It is this insistence that the software is human enough to be granted human-like status that is playing fast and loose with the definitions of things, ranging from consciousness, to learning, to the interpretation of those concepts relative to current laws. I believe new laws will be written, and old laws will be updated. There's no question that the current legal system is not well equipped for various generative AI systems. But I don't think the current laws have nothing to say. And I'd still argue that this conversation can be separated from the one about indiscriminately slurping up artist's content. > We're not going to stop AI because some furry deviant art artist complains loudly online. Please don't argue against straw men. There are legitimate concerns from artists across disciplines and genres, and this isn't just isolated shrieking. Artist backlash is frankly one of the most natural outcomes I could imagine from a system that uses their work without permission. Many of the people who are complaining loudly are not against AI, just against the use of their work without consent or attribution. I'm both extremely excited about the possibilities the software unlocks and concerned about the implications. AI can exist without ignoring the rights of artists.
- antiterra 4y agoChatGPT has shown that attempting to train the model to decline certain types of requests is of limited effectiveness and readily circumvented. The ability to make custom checkpoints and tools like Dreambooth will further limit these restrictions.
- mk_stjames 4y agoI think this is why it was very important that their first release of the model weights (the v1.4 model) was and will continue to be very important. While training an entire model from scratch requires an insane amount of data and compute right now (and will continue to be out of reach of individuals for some years I think), fine-tuning the model can be done on a consumer graphics card (they call it Dreambooth)... and I believe we will see further refinements that allow more and more useful tuning and features being built by individuals on top that original model, making it more and more powerful for specific uses. So even if future efforts change the functionality, or nerf the output in some way, there will always be people developing tools on the original weights. That cat is out of the bag.
- GaryNumanVevo 4y agoStrongly disagree, IP law (despite it's misuse by a certain mouse mascot'd company) is extremely important and protecting artists work and their livelihood. The price floor on art commissions is already very low and AI effectively makes that cost zero, while providing zero compensation to the thousands of artists. Without their work, there's no Stability AI. From an ethical standpoint Stability is in the wrong, and from a legal one I think the class has a very strong case to recover damages.
- astrange 4y agoStableDiffusion is not based on art commissions. You can search https://rom1504.github.io/clip-retrieval/ https://rom1504.github.io/clip-retrieval/ and see what kind of nonsense it usually has trained on.
- GaryNumanVevo 4y agoIt most definitely is, LAION-5B contains a large amount of copyrighted works from DeviantArt, ArtStation, etc.
- astrange 4y agoAre those all commissions? The aesthetic subset is .05% Artstation: https://laion-aesthetic.datasette.io/laion-aesthetic-6pls/images?_sort=rowid&url__contains=artstation https://laion-aesthetic.datasette.io/laion-aesthetic-6pls/im... Not sure if that's a large amount or not. They could've used robots.txt if they didn't want to be indexed.
- GaryNumanVevo 4y ago> Note that this is only a small subset of the total training data: about 2% of the 600 million images used to train the most recent three checkpoints, and only 0.5% of the 2.3 billion images that it was first trained on. [1] That dataset only covers "aesthetic" clip terms as well. Not to mention a lot of images come from Pinterest and other aggregators. [1] https://waxy.org/2022/08/exploring-12-million-of-the-images-used-to-train-stable-diffusions-image-generator/ https://waxy.org/2022/08/exploring-12-million-of-the-images-...