3 ms·
Devil's advocate: If small teams _always_ and _unconditionally_ are so much more efficient, why do we still have the likes of, say, IBM, Hyundai, Microsoft, or
by Someone 15y ago
Devil's advocate:
If small teams _always_ and _unconditionally_ are so much more efficient, why do we still have the likes of, say, IBM, Hyundai, Microsoft, or ant colonies?
I think that it partly is because large teams do a lot of things that small teams deem unnecessary, such as documenting design choices, pre-estimating demand/bandwidth requirements etc, making sure one complies with legislation, etc. Not all of that is necessarily waste.
Another large part of the difference, I think, is due to the difference between programming and engineering. Many small teams, especially at smaller companies, program, while almost all larger teams engineer. Programming produces way more functionality per man month than engineering does (for an example, read GNU's well-engineered hello world source code).
So, I think the main rule should be "only start engineering if you have to". Large team size is, for a large part, just a side effect of the decision to engineer.
- gwern 15y agoLots of reasons. Small efficient companies can be much more easily killed by variance / randomness than huge bloated monsters. Successful small companies tend to become large companies, laying the seeds of doom. Successful small companies may just be bought out by the large companies - you can't buy a large company until you are a large company, but the same is not true of small companies. And so on.