4 ms·
Two cases that could break Big Tech's hold on the internet. These cases are not going to stop anyone from publishing their own content via internet, but they m
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
Two cases that could break Big Tech's hold on the internet.
These cases are not going to stop anyone from publishing their own content via internet, but they might affect Big Tech intermediaries that publish only other people's content and produce no content themselves.
These cases will not stop traditional media organisations that employ journalists from fact-checking and publishing the content they produce.
Even if these cases are decided favourably to the defendants, "tech" companies will continue to publish low quality, low-brow, incendiary, false, "clickbait" content. That is what gets eyeballs. Section 230 is not incentivising them to moderate, as it was intended. Advertising is incentivising them to allow anything that garners more views and "engagement". Section 230 is only providing them with immunity from all manner of litigation around any moderation. There is no incentive to fact-check anything. Even "recommending" terrorrist group videos is apprently fair game.
If they have zero obligation to moderate and no incentive to fact-check, because they have immunity under 230, i.e., Google wins against Gonzalez, then they can grow their once modest websites to gigantic, overpowering size, with a disproportionate amount of influence on the open web.^1
Reframing the situation, the gigantic websites now call themselves "platforms", sharecroppers and serfs are "publishers" and "creators".
Grab a stake in the "Metaverse".
You cannot break something that is already broken.
1. For Big Tech this web feudalism is the Holy Grail. Grow the audience size and reap the advertising revenue. Obviously any proposed change, an improved interpretation of Section 230, that could threaten this status quo is unacceptable to them. But they are not the majority of web users. Was the web created so that a few websites could control the majority of traffic. In their view, yes. That is the only way the web can operate. How convenient.
- nindalf 4y agoRemember that most content written by most people actually happens in these platforms owned and moderated by someone else. You say it won’t stop anyone but how many people currently posting on Twitter, Facebook, YouTube and TikTok are capable of creating their own websites, posting the content there, paying for the cost of hardware and bandwidth and also finding an audience somehow? 0.1%? 0.01%? The rest of your comment is equally wrong (perhaps even low quality, low brow, incendiary, false), but I have little time to fact check it.
- joeyh 4y agoThey would hop on a p2p or federated social network in a heartbeat if it were the only option. The fact that the CDA and 230 have tilted the internet away from those, by propping up currently large businesses does not mean that's the only way the internet can work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lliamander 4y ago> Section 230 is not incentivising them to fact-check and moderate, as it was intended. I think you misunderstand the intent of section 230. The vision of the bill was to support an internet of relatively free an unconstrained speech. No one expected these platforms to "fact-check" anything, and the moderation was not rule on who was right or wrong, but to mainly give them leeway to keep out genuinely illegal (and to a lesser extent, obscene) content.
- tzs 4y ago> The vision of the bill was to support an internet of relatively free an unconstrained speech. No one expected these platforms to "fact-check" anything, and the moderation was not rule on who was right or wrong, but to mainly give them leeway to keep out genuinely illegal (and to a lesser extent, obscene) content. How did you reach that conclusion?
- lliamander 4y agoReading the text of the law and the history of how and why it was drafted.
- zinekeller 4y agoYou replying that is as hilarious as that time NPR posted the constitution in Twitter - many, many people thought that NPR is either rebelling or being forced to (in a presumed coup).
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeran_v._America_Online,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zeran_v._America_Online,_Inc. This was neither illegal nor obscene content. However it had a severe effect on a third party. Arguably, not as severe as the effect that the terrorist group videos that Google recommended had on the Gonzalez family.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoIt is relatively common to see HN thread discussions that complain about some form of "censorship" by Big Tech, or, more generally, about "free speech" issues (real or imagined) with respect to Big Tech websites. Perhaps it is worthwhile to ask ourselves what is it that allows such "censorhip" or threats to "free seech" to happen. A few ideas: 1. Big Tech's position as intermediaries, aka "middlemen". Web users and to some degree internet users (cf. "tech" workers) are not expected to communicate with each directly without using Big Tech to do it. All web traffic must be observable by Bog Tech in ways that allow Big Tech to sells its "online advertising services". End result: "Surveillance capitalism". 2. Section 230. Without this immunity from litigation, arguably Big Tech could not "censor" successfully. If they could do so, then why would they oppose any changes to Section 230 interpetation. Of course, neither "censorship" nor "free speech" is really the correct word to describe the activity Big Tech is engaging in that draws controversy. Big Tech promotes certain content. It does not matter how they do it, whether they measure "popularity" or whether they accept payment for placement of ads that look like search results, or "targeted" ads or whatever. In Gonzalez, the facts are around "recommendations". Unsolicited promotion of certain content to certain users. This is done not at the request of the user, it is not optional. It's done for Google's benefit. These companies that profit from surveillance and associated advertising are not "neutral". They are not "dumb pipes". Given that they are under no contractual obligations to any web user, only a fool would claim they are "critical infrastructure". They are surveillance, data collection and advertising companies. Does Big Tech need Section 230 protection in order to continue to pull this off. When Section 230 was enacted, there were no "tech" companies. Online service providers such as Compuserve, Prodigy and for a while AOL all charged fees. There were contracts between these companies and their users. There was customer service. Users were not ad targets, they were not "the product", they were customers. Users could sue these companies for not performing the job that they were being paid to do. Then came Section 230. People always envisioned that the internet would be used for commerce. However today "tech" companies and most importantly "Big Tech" try to make all web activity commercial. Everything anyone does using the internet is surveilled with an eye toward its commercial significance, if any. And that practice is itself, the surveillance of all internet activity, even academic or recreational use, is considered a "business model". Users pay nothing. Why would anyone pay to be surveilled and served with targeted ads. Advertisers pay for the surveillance. Don't be evil. Everyone anticipated selling widgets^FN1 over the internet. No one envisioned "tech" companies. Websites with no products for sale that conduct surveillance and collect data about web users as a "business model" and, unsuprisingly, in most cases, cannot turn a profit. No one envisioned a few gigantic websites with billions of pages doing this that manage engorge themselves with advertiser spend and take over the web. What (who) is Section 230 really for. If centralisation and single points of failure are undesirable, and Big Tech represents centralisation and gatekeeper chokepoints that can and do "fail", then perhaps it's worth considering that Section 230 protection for Big Tech is what allows this status quo to continue and for the situation to worsen. FN1. In Bezos' case, books.