3 ms·
Why are there fewer voters who would vote for denser housing for themselves while inflicting some pain on NIMBYs, than the NIMBY voters? I suspect two things.
by nine_k 4y ago
Why are there fewer voters who would vote for denser housing for themselves while inflicting some pain on NIMBYs, than the NIMBY voters?
I suspect two things. One is that NIMBYs are often more well-off and can inflict more pain on the politician who would oppose them than would be the gain from the pro-density crowd support. Another, sadder, is that enough of those who complain about housing not being affordable would like to become NIMBYs themselves, but can't yet afford that.
- CalRobert 4y agoFor local rules it's also because you need to live there to vote.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Why are there fewer voters who would vote for denser housing for themselves while inflicting some pain on NIMBYs, than the NIMBY voters? Because wealth predicts propensity to vote. (Also, to the extent decisions are made locally, the people that would live in area but are excluded by housing affordability don’t get a vote. In fact, often a major reasons for the NIMBY policies isn't financial, but keeping the outsiders outside. For instance, when you've got a nice segregated community created by overtly racist policies that you are no longer allowed to employ, the main way to slow the erosion of what you worked so hard to achieve is to make it hard for new people to move in.)
- JeremyNT 4y ago> Because wealth predicts propensity to vote. And to elaborate on this, real estate owners already have "skin in the game." They fully understand the negative impact of a policy that is obviously meant to reduce the value of their investment and vote/lobby against it. For the non-real-estate owners, it's way less obvious why they should mobilize or care. It's tough to get terribly excited about economic policy that is intended to gradually improve the housing problem by making it less attractive for the capital class to horde their assets forever. These effects are longer term and nebulous/uncertain for somebody who needs somewhere to live NOW.