8 ms·
How Intel’s Medfield will dismantle ARM
- Symmetry 15y agoI'm sort of biased towards ARM, but I'm still very impressed by how well Intel is doing. The history of computers is littered with the corpses of the companies that brought down by competitors with cheaper, not as good solutions. Look at 3.5" hard drives, x86 vs the RISC machines, etc. And mostly they failed to do anything because competing when they still could would have eaten into their profit margins. But here Intel is devoting actual resources to a smaller, cheaper, less powerful offering.
- SlipperySlope 15y agoIntel's SoC Atom part will not, in my opinion, be priced below ARM parts competing for a particular manufacturer's design. Intel is a high margin company and I think will sell high-priced Medfield on the basis of higher performance. Intel is the high-priced market incumbent in this case - and may well be disrupted soon by certain ARM low-power servers.
- pedalpete 15y agoThe spec's I don't think tell the story here. It's going to come down to price and marketing. Intel still has some very strong brand recognition with their 'intel inside' campaign, and though most people don't actively look for intel chips when buying a computer, they do recognize when the computer they are buying has it, and it makes them feel comforted (much like McAfee or Norton etc. etc) The hardware manufacturers will build on a competitive price point. I suspect Moto's dedication to Intel was driven more by price than by performance. Not to say that I don't believe intel will perform, and I also disgree with the article, and I think javascript performance is hugely important to the end user.
- dlevine 15y agoI'm guessing that Intel cut Motorola a really sweet deal to get them to sign an exclusive contract. The decision probably had little to do with Intel being a better platform, and more to do with cost per chip. Let's face it - Windows 8 running on ARM was a pretty big wake up call to Intel. They knew that they had to have a major win, or risk getting disrupted in the near future. So they called up Sanjay Jha, and figured out what it was going to take to get an exclusive contract. When you look at it, Medfield is 3 year-old desktop chip technology, which itself wasn't exactly new (the Atom had some improvements, but wasn't a radical departure from what preceded it). Intel isn't bringing anything new to the table - they just keep shrinking the same old chips, and reducing power requirements. At the core, they are still a PC chip company - they just figure out how to shoehorn those chips into smaller and smaller platforms. The new ARM-based devices (such as Tegra 3) are actually much more innovative and better-suited to mobile devices than Medfield. I think that we will see a lot more innovation in chip design from ARM licensees going forward (such as the low-power 5th core on the Tegra 3), and this will eventually disrupt Intel from the bottom up.
- rbanffy 15y ago> Windows 8 running on ARM was a pretty big wake up call to Intel. Windows 8 stil hasn't shipped, won't ship for quite some time and won't run most current Windows PC software. Don't forget non-x86 Windows NT ran on MIPS, PPC, Alpha and Itanic (and i960, Clipper and SPARC, IIRC) processors and it mostly failed because it couldn't run software compiled for x86's.
- mikeash 15y agoIt also failed because, to within a small margin of error, nobody owned MIPS, PPC, Alpha, or Itanium systems. ARM systems, on the other hand, are selling tens or maybe even hundreds of millions a year right now.
- rbanffy 15y agoAnd for the foreseeable future none will be able to boot Windows 8. Unless Microsoft wants to ship an installer that jailbreaks and installs W8 on iPads.
- mikeash 15y agoSure, but there's still an established concept of "ship an ARM tablet and get people to develop for it". In other words, there's no Wintel monopoly to contend with as there was before. I think that's largely what NT-on-not-Intel fell victim to, despite coming from one of the Wintel companies.
- rat87 15y agoI wouldn't be surprised at all if they come out with windows phone 8 based on windows 8 and not windows mobile. That way they could have one os for phones/tablets/pc's/ect. They could use their market/repository as a way to force people to modify uis. Since all of the 3rd party apps are written in a version of silverlight(they haven't dropped this restriction yet right?) it should have few incompatibilities.
- np1782 15y ago
- rbanffy 15y agoExaggerated title and claims attract impressions. News at 11.
- qdog 15y agoARM produces a design people incorporate into their chips. I'm not entirely certain you cannot take an ARM core and enhance it if you pay the right fees (when I worked on them, I don't think we did, but we just need a core to do management for our hardware-based video decoder). Not sure if IBM fabricates any chips for people right now, but we used UMC and TSMC, so it's really not about ARM for the manufacturing process, it's about those two companies. I don't know what UMC and TSMC are advertising as their current process, it might be a little behind Intel, but I'm sure they'll continue to shrink processes. The question is why would an x86 processor need to be put on your phone? I guess because the history of Intel so far is all x86, their other processor lines have all been phased out (I hesitate to say failed, but that might be the right word). Intel really doesn't want to compete on low-power, low-margin chips, they like making money on the desktop and server. From my limited experience, ARM is vastly easier to work on than x86, as far as assembly programming is concerned. I personally hope this chip fails, because I'd prefer not to have x86 polluting the world anymore than it already has.
- rsynnott 15y ago> I'm not entirely certain you cannot take an ARM core and enhance it if you pay the right fees You can. There are at least two licenses, a core license and an architecture license. Qualcomm has an architecture license; the Scorpion (Snapdragon's ARM core) is an ARMv7 core somewhat similar to an A8, but is not actually an A8. Companies with core licenses have also modified them; the Samsung/Apple/Intrinsity Hummingbird/A4 used an A8 core modified by Intrinsity to work efficiently at 1GHz; TI later followed suit. Intrinsity's main business model, in fact, was optimization of other peoples' core designs.
- qdog 15y agoOk, cool, I should have looked it up, but the sentence in the article was "Except for Qualcomm, which makes its own ARM-compatible cores, every other ARM chip on the market uses reference CPU cores", which I didn't think was true (and I don't think 'compatible' is the right word for Qualcomm, probably 'extended' ?). Also, he talks about this future 22nm process from intel for 2013, as though the other fabs are going to sit at 28nm forever (even though Intel is also currently at 28nm). It just seems like a poorly written article, or someone who copied a little too much from Intel's PR.
- rfugger 15y agoIn short, if Motorola didn’t think that Medfield was competitive, it wouldn’t have agreed to make a bunch of Medfield-powered phones and tablets. Either that, or Intel paid it a bunch of money to make it worth their while.
- vosper 15y agoExactly, or they're just making a mistake - like Logitech did with their Google TV boxes, which cost them $100m in operating profits.
- rsynnott 15y agoYep; I'd be particularly suspicious of this given that the two companies involved are Lenovo, which doesn't have a significant smartphone market anyway, and has a huge PC market, and Motorola, which is in reasonably dire financial straits. If HTC, or, for that matter, Apple, were a launch partner, that might be more promising.
- AndrewDucker 15y agoThis feels rather overblown to me. Intel is entering a market. Agreed. This will mean that ARM has to compete with them. Agreed. This will be good for the consumer. Agreed. And Intel will completely wipe the floor with the current market monopolist. Nope, sorry, you lost me there. Sure, they _might_ be able to outflank ARM, but they haven't managed to do that so far, and ARM are the experts in this space. Intel have tried to outflank experts before, and their graphics processors don't seem to be the market leaders.
- joss82 15y agoI agree with you. This article sounds like Intel PR to me.
- phren0logy 15y agoSpot on! ARM should worry, but really Intel doesn't have a great track record here. And ARM does. Also, ARM has been scaling up pretty well, and the graphics cores on those chips are arguably better than what Intel has ever been able to turn out. Summary: We'll see, and it will be fun to watch.
- tpurves 15y agoanandtech provided a more level-headed analysis. Intel's new design performs well and beats ARM designs - that have already been in market for a year already. This years ARM designs based on A15 are quite likely to be as good or better. A1,5 the next generation arm, is wider (more parallel decode and execution units than Atom) and is out-of-order further increasing instructions-per-cycle (at the expense of some complexity and die size). This is like the architectural difference between 486 and pentium. At least on paper, the A15 should be notably faster than Atom if at similar clock speeds (MHz).
- InclinedPlane 15y agoThis is the nature of the beast in today's tech journalism. Every story is cast as some sort of Manichean struggle. It's more than a little bit silly. We can follow the competition between tech companies without imagining that one or the other is sure to go out of business soon.
- 15y ago
- SlipperySlope 15y agoThe article overstates the case against ARM in the mobile marketplace. Counterpoints not mentioned are: 1. The single company Intel can never match the wide variety of SoC (System on a Chip) components that the diverse ARM fabricators will offer. 2. The ARM fabricators will remain close behind Intel with regard to lithography generations. 3. Intel's Medfield has not been independently benchmarked on shipping mobile devices. 4. Industry partnerships established for the previous Intel mobile part did not create any notable results. 5. In order to dismantle ARM, Intel would have to significantly underprice commodity ARM fabricators - which would destroy Intel's historical margins. Note that Intel sold off a former ARM-compatible division - XScale - for this reason. 6. Furthermore some ARM partners plan to invade the x86 server market with low power, but capable alternatives to Intel servers, thus enlarging the potential ARM market and possibly counter-disrupting Intel's highest margin business.
- mbreese 15y agoI think that #1 is the more important "pro" for ARM, while #4 is the most important "con" for Intel. How many times have we seen Intel announce a hardware partnership with a company (especially in mobile) that ultimately went nowhere? I think this comes down to, I'll believe it when I see the devices shipping.
- r00fus 15y agoFurthermore, the major proprietary player (Apple) will likely never give up on their ARM chip to favor Intel. Unlike in the 80s where IBM used Intel chips and Microsoft software and created two heirs to their monopoly, this time will be wildly different. ARM (and the mobile market) will crush Intel. Intel is seriously late to the game here, and never took performace/watt seriously for decades, and ARM is going to disrupt them hard.
- mrsebastian 15y agoInteresting that you mention Apple/ARM -- don't forget that, eventually, Apple had no choice but to shift from PowerPC chips in its laptops and desktops to Intel. The performance difference was just too vast. I am fairly sure that the same thing will now happen with x86 and ARM -- it just depends on the timeline.
- rsynnott 15y agoHmm. Does Android have fat binaries for the NDK? I can see Motorola et al getting a lot of complaints about games not working...
- georgemcbay 15y agoAndroid doesn't use 'fat binaries' by the strict definition of the term, but the APK format that apps are shipped in can include multiple individual builds of both the main app and required libraries so you could pack x86 and ARM builds in a single APK. FWIW, there are already Android devices out there on x86 -- all of the currently shipping Google TV devices are built around Atom. The NDK isn't officially supported on those GTV platforms but it isn't difficult to get it working in practice. Also, any complaints for this would probably be directed at Google (though I guess Google and Moto will be the same company soon anyway) because arch filtering is generally handled by the Android Market, so for users with these devices they just won't see the games showing up at all on their local install of the Android Market (since the market will be filtering out anything NDK based that doesn't have an included x86 build), so it looks like a market issue (if they already know the game exists), not an app issue.
- rsynnott 15y agoIn my experience, the average user is only dimly aware, if at all, of Google's involvement.
- bluesnowmonkey 15y ago> Consumers, for the first time ever, will actually have a choice — just like AMD and Intel on the desktop, you will be able to pick a smartphone or tablet with a CPU that best suits your needs. Consumers don't particularly care what CPU is in their smartphone or tablet.
- gringomorcego 15y agololololololol To me, the articles main support for the rise of Intel as a mobile chip competitor are: 1). Motorola made a deal 2). Intel can leverage their own manufacturing process/plants The first is stupid. Considering how much Motorola bent over for Microsoft, this is probably more Microsoft doing Intel a solid to get into the market rather than a purely "logical" financial long-term decision by Motorola. The second I can't really argue about with any real knowledge. However, upgrading plants is fucking expensive. By ARM separating themselves from that portion of the chip business, they have basically enabled a secondary competitive market of improving ARM designs. Intel has locked themselves into the position of Overseer of all-best-designs, and whether or not this is true, it will lead to comparative stagnation in innovation. I'm might be wrong, but I honestly think that Intel will lose simply because their mentality depends too much on an idea of limited competition. They are too used to AMD and legacy slaves; the switch to open-source and web-based systems will lead to insane competition and crunch their profit margins like a nutcracker.
- ck2 15y ago14nm in two years? Whoa. That's going to be huge for the server market. Imagine 24 cores per chip with the same power draw as they have today for six cores.
- SlipperySlope 15y agoActually, I think the Moore's law benefits of continued chip feature shrinkage will be felt most strongly in personal devices. For example, to perform voice recognition, Siri must send the raw waveform to a cloud server for processing, because the local CPU and RAM are insufficient for acoustic and language modeling. With a couple more CPU generations, i.e. say four years, I expect mobile devices to perform these sort of calculations locally. Beyond speech recognition is machine vision - object/scene detection and recognition. Currently, wireless bandwidth limitations preclude a realtime cloud-based facility for machine vision, but more capable mobile device CPU/GPUs could enable local processing. In general, Moore's law progress enables less expensive cloud servers to perform the same tasks, but that same progress enables mobile devices to perform new categories of tasks!
- Someone 15y ago"Currently, wireless bandwidth limitations preclude a realtime cloud-based facility for machine vision" I do not think that is all what stops it. Just as speech recognition, machine vision is quite different from computer graphics. We _know_ how to make graphics orders of magnitude better; just look at Pixar's latest movie. 'All' we have to do to bring that to your phone is do it more efficiently. For speech recognition and machine vision, I am less optimistic. Reason? I never hear about, say, "almost perfect, but it takes a 1000 CPUs a day to process a second of sound" for speech recognition or object recognition. I wonder why that is? Is it because there are problems we haven't solved yet, or because nobody approaches the problem from that side?
- SlipperySlope 15y agoFor clarity... I am an AI developer. Recently I added a feature to my dialog system so that if I have not typed anything into the dialog web app in a while, the system begins capturing frames from the webcam and performing face detection using JavaCV. If a face is detected, then face recognition is performed on the clipped greyscale face. If the face best matches mine from the training examples, then the system uses Google speech-to-text synthesis to say hello to me, "hello Stephen". A smartphone cannot practically do this because JavaCV will not run fast enough on an ARM CPU and wireless bandwidth limitations preclude sending whole realtime captured phonecam frames to a server. But, when Moore's Law permits, JavaCV will run on the mobile CPU/GPU combination - and my phone could say hello to me when it recognizes me. I know that Google is working on face-recognition phone-unlocks - but I wonder if their implementation involves a cloud server and one-time sending of a captured frame?