5 ms·
One way to avoid the problems of devices no longer supported by drivers is to use open source software and put pressure on vendors. Linux was gaining ground on
by neilv 4y ago
One way to avoid the problems of devices no longer supported by drivers is to use open source software and put pressure on vendors.
Linux was gaining ground on open source drivers this for a while, but then it seemed like we started to backslide.
Open source works best if more people treat it like a marriage commitment, not the occasional random holiday fling.
- hvs 4y agoThis is nice-sounding, but ultimately there is almost no incentive for hardware manufacturers to open source their drivers. Linux isn't a large market and macOS and Windows users generally aren't concerned with it. On top of that, many of these products (though maybe not the one in particular) is basically disposable. The way this is handled in industry is to have 20-year-old computer running Windows XP that is just for a specific product that only has drivers for one version of Windows.
- neilv 4y agoIf more people committed to open source, there would be more pressure on hardware vendors. I suppose all that's needed is for a good chunk of Windows and Mac users to stop thinking of open source as only Vegas flings of opportunity, and more like a life partner.
- Gigachad 4y agoHas this ever worked? Even now it seems that hardly any vendors put out linux software and when they do it's garbage that tries to import shared libraries that existed on ubuntu 13.04 or something. Almost all the hardware support on linux came from people in the linux space reverse engineering and developing those drivers which are then in a state that can be upstreamed. The wine/proton project has had far far more impact than decades of posting on game forums asking for a linux build.
- zokier 4y ago> Almost all the hardware support on linux came from people in the linux space reverse engineering and developing those drivers which are then in a state that can be upstreamed. Almost all sounds like exaggeration, Intel&AMD have done a lot, and even ARM vendors have contributed lot of drivers. See for example LWN author stats for employers, plenty of HW vendors there: https://lwn.net/Articles/902854/ https://lwn.net/Articles/902854/
- kaoD 4y agoAs I see it open source killed free software. We don't need open source, we need free software. Stallman was right, as he always is with these things. It's a meaningful distinction and the fact that open source mindshare won is what effectively killed any momentum that free software had. Software freedom completely disappeared from the public discourse and it was not fortuitous.
- Gigachad 4y agoOpen source (OSI definition) is exactly the same thing as Free Software (FSF definition) so your comment makes no sense without clarifying further. Are you perhaps referring to Source Available software vs OS/FS? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Source-available_software
- kaoD 4y agoThat's a great comment to prove my point on how software freedom is completely absent from public discourse :) I'll let Stallman speak for me: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point....
- Gigachad 4y agoStallman made up his own definition of open source which is different than the common definition. The OSI best sums it up here https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd their definition is essentially the same as the FSF essential freedoms. Without classifying "Stallman's definition of Open Source" people will assume something much like the OSI one. What Stallman calls Open Source is what the rest of the world calls Source Available. Stallman shows his lack of communication skills again here by endlessly fighting to redefine words for no purpose.
- kaoD 4y ago> What Stallman calls Open Source is what the rest of the world calls Source Available That's absolutely wrong, as clearly explained in the article I linked to.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoThe reason is probably that there are way way less devices in use now. Graphics cards are made by 2+1 companies (nvidia, amd and somewhat intel), webcams are uvc compatible, mice and keyboards are "driverless", there are less and less printers and scanners in use, and even those are wireless, noone uses digital cameras with need for gphoto2 anymore (either mobile phones or pro equipment and a card reader), flash drivers are all the same, soundcards are mostly onboard now, screens are all the same, etc... so no critical mass to bother companies anymore. Back in the time you had a bunch of soundcars, palm pilots with activesync, lpt printers, usb printers, scsi printers, zip, jazz drives, etc. The only pain currently are unstable wifi drivers, because there are still quite a few chipset makers) and well.. custom equipment used by a handful of people, such as op here.
- Gigachad 4y agoThere are less external devices you’d plug in, but internal hardware is still a huge battle. Internal laptop webcams usually don’t work on day one, finger print scanners usually don’t work, suspend and sleep is big problem for most new laptops.
- lmm 4y agoLinux is even worse at maintaining compatibility with old drivers. Opening your source doesn't help when the OS doesn't offer a stable API; you can try to get your driver into the kernel tree, but that takes forever, has high code quality standards, and can still lead to you getting rejected essentially arbitrarily. So you can publish a driver that will work on linux version xyz, but that requires udev and systemd and glibc and everything else to be of versions that match.
- somat 4y agobut in linux it does not matter as much, you have the source, it is unpleasant to update it to a different api but not actually that hard, much easier than when all you have is a binary blob that you want to get running on your system.
- IgorPartola 4y agoIs high code quality a thing we should not expect out of hardware drivers?
- lmm 4y ago"Should" or not, the reality is it's rare. Rejecting low-quality hardware drivers tends to mean ending up with no drivers rather than with high-quality ones.