4 ms·
If you really can't figure out the difference between the two, I suggest you go have a long think about it. Modern, western governments, for instance, generall
by davidw 15y ago
If you really can't figure out the difference between the two, I suggest you go have a long think about it.
Modern, western governments, for instance, generally do not do things like dissolve children in acid.
We get that you don't think there should be any government or whatever libertopian ideas you have, but let's try a bit harder.
- grandalf 15y agoOne should not need to be "libertopian" to find many of the actions of governments abhorrent. I imagine you are OK with "sanctions" that cause children to starve and to watch their psychologically destroyed parents crumble under the (very much intended) pressure of the sanctions to overturn a dictatorship. Over the past few decades, the US government has committed horrible atrocities against civilian populations of a variety of nations. Much of this was "indirect", its indirectness a virtue in terms of "economy of force". There is absolutely no moral high ground enjoyed by governments compared to mafia or other criminal organizations, it's just a matter of how elaborate the propaganda effort has been to create the perception that the acts are just... and in many cases there is lots of doublespeak employed to prevent the brains of observers from drawing the obvious connection. Torture is called "enhanced interrogation" Disrupting a society with bombs is called "preserving the stability of a region". Running secret assassination programs is called "covert operations"
- davidw 15y ago> There is absolutely no moral high ground enjoyed by governments compared to mafia You're conflating an occupying army with a democratically elected government staying within its borders. That seems like a huge leap to make, and is spoken like someone with no exposure to the realities of organized crime and its deleterious effects on society. If you look at this chart: http://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regioni_d%27Italia#Dati_economici http://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regioni_d%27Italia#Dati_economi... and rank it by 'PIL Pro Capite' (Per capita GDP), the correlation with organized crime is fairly strong, whereas the country and government are the same. Migration from South to North continues to far exceed North to South: apparently people prefer better government and less crime to the opposite. This sort of sophomoric intellectual exercise doesn't do justice to what you believe in.
- grandalf 15y agoThere are many examples of people being loyal to local gangsters and paying fees each month in exchange for "protection" from a rival group. Governments run the same scheme at a larger scale. Sure they "provide" things, but it's simply by taking money from people and paying other people to do work, meanwhile enriching the officers of government and creating entrenched wealth and power. Sure, there are occasionally coordination problems that are solved by governments, but far more coordination problems are solved by private organizations and firms. Any institution that has the ability to project force wherever it wants (via an armed hitman or a smart bomb) is going to tend toward corrupt behavior. Your comment mentions governments acting within their borders which is an arbitrary distinction. Most of the atrocities committed by the US government happen overseas and the American public is misled about the level of brutality being inflicted. There will always be some gangsters who are preferred to others, and perhaps some "politicians" are preferred to gangsters. But this is a distinction of degree not of kind.
- jbooth 15y agoIf there's no difference, perhaps you'd like to elucidate on the difference between, say, Sweden and the average 3rd/4th world nation? I mean, with the reach of Sweden's government, it's gotta be a hellhole, right? This line of argument is generally referred to as "jumping the shark". Obviously there's a difference.
- grandalf 15y agoOk, I'll answer: Sweden: The president travels by motorcade with posh limos and armed agents, guns hidden but ready. 3rd world regime: The leader travels around in an SUV with machine-gun wielding guards. Why do both leaders need to travel accompanied by such a display of force? The pageantry of such displays intimidate rivals. The mistake those in the thread disagreeing with me are making is to assume that just b/c governments are less often observed to blatantly harass their own citizens, they are more civilized than the small time crooks whose lack of power occasionally necessitates messier tactics. National boundaries should be thrown out the window. Obama has ordered the death of thousands during his regime and his minions have carried out the orders with precision. The rest of us (citizens) are equivalent to distant relatives sitting at the dinner table with Tony Soprano exchanging smalltalk, complicit and abetting every single action and willfully ignorant of all the (mostly brown skinned) people being exterminated.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]