3 ms·
> But saving is especially difficult right now because on top of student debt, housing and food costs remain high even as inflation has started to cool. Statem
by kelnos 4y ago
> But saving is especially difficult right now because on top of student debt, housing and food costs remain high even as inflation has started to cool.
Statements like this are weird to me, because "cooling inflation" doesn't mean "prices are dropping", and suggests that the author doesn't really understand basic economic concepts. When inflation raises the price of something, that's it: that's the new price. Absent other innovations to make it cheaper (more efficient production or logistics, etc.), the price will not go back down. The hope, of course, is that once inflation is under control, wages will rise to counteract its effects.
> Theresa Fairless [...] said paying off student loans was her priority. Ms. Fairless graduated from college in 2018 with about $25,900 in government loans and $50,000 in personal loans.
Now I don't know the details of her loans, but this was a mistake I made in my 20s: if your interest rate is low, your priority should be saving and investing, not paying off the loans. Obviously you still need to make the minimum payments.
Granted, investing has not been great over the past year, so it probably has been a good idea to pay down debt more aggressively than in prior years.
I had a government college loan at 3.5% that I absolutely should not have paid off early. I had a private loan as well that was variable, and I think when I paid it off it was a little over 4%. Still questionable; maybe should have put the extra cash toward investments rather than the loan. But at the time I didn't really know what I was doing, and was also worried about the variable rate rising too much.
(Her loan amounts are also in line with what I had... well, I guess technically lower than mine, considering inflation over the past 20 years.)
A couple paragraphs down it talks about how she is saving and investing, has a $10k emergency fund, and is still able to give her mom some money to help her out. So... it seems like she's doing just fine? Seems better off than a ton of people, anyway.
- nkjnlknlk 4y ago> The hope, of course, is that once inflation is under control, wages will rise to counteract its effects. I see where you're going with your statement but I believe the wage-price spiral being a major cause of _this_ inflation is not a fact. :)
- paulpauper 4y agobecause "cooling inflation" It's an intentionally vague description that lets the NYTs writer off the hook for not having to be more specific about something which is more complicated and doesn't understand that well.
- mhb 4y agoI had a government college loan at 3.5% that I absolutely should not have paid off early. Why? You knew of a better opportunity to make a risk-free 3.5% (less any tax deduction)?
- fnfjfk 4y agoAny decent index fund? “Risk free” is too high a bar for any investment, compare the expected outcome instead.
- mhb 4y agoPaying off the loan is risk-free. Expected value of an index fund is not obviously better. But you knew that.
- fnfjfk 4y agohttps://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042415/what-average-annual-return-sp-500.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/042415/what-average... Sure, if you have exactly zero risk tolerance, pay off a low interest rate loan. But based on history, you will almost certainly lose over the long term of a decade or more.
- mhb 4y agoI don't really disagree, but it's not as obvious as it seems in hindsight. 3.5% (which OP says became 4%) isn't a low interest rate when inflation and other low risk options (e.g., CDs) are <1%. Also, your article says: "Adjusted for inflation, the historical average annual return is only around 8.5%. There is an additional problem posed by the question of whether that inflation-adjusted average is accurate since the adjustment is made using the inflation figures from the Consumer Price Index (CPI), the index which some analysts believe vastly understates the true inflation rate." So maybe the stock index average to use is more like 2x the loan interest.
- tedunangst 4y agoIf you have subsequent expenses that require credit card debt, or a car loan, it's better to have cash savings available to reduce that. You can't unpay a 3.5% loan to get back money to pay off a 20% loan.
- travisjungroth 4y agoOn the "cooling inflation" part, there's a different interpretation of what she's saying that I think is actually true and meaningful. Even though the rate of broad increase of the price of services and goods has declined recently (inflation has started to cool), the ratio between housing + food costs and income is still elevated (housing and food costs remain high). The alternative is possible, that housing and food costs would remain steady or even decline while other prices increased, bringing the ratios back to more historic levels. But, this doesn't seem to be happening.