5 ms·

What annotations software is this? All news should be reported this way when source documents are available. Edit: scrolled to the bottom of the page and found

What annotations software is this? All news should be reported this way when source documents are available. Edit: scrolled to the bottom of the page and found https://github.com/molly/annotate https://github.com/molly/annotate

jtbayly 4y ago
So it's just the front-end, relying on you to manually write all the HTML. I'd love some software to make generating these (or similar) annotated documents easily. Any ideas?
- batmenace 4y ago
  Fermat's Library offers something that comes relatively close https://fermatslibrary.com/margins https://fermatslibrary.com/margins
  - bradgessler 4y ago
    Slightly tangential: is there software that converts multi-LaTeX PDFs into responsive HTML in a reasonable way? I'd read more of these papers if they were more viewable on a phone-size viewport.
    - Eisenstein 4y ago
      Pandoc?
- bradgessler 4y ago
  Yeah I was thinking the same thing. A GUI where the original text material is loaded, then you highlight it and write the annotations. Bonus of each annotation could be tweeted/tooted/whatevered and include open graph screenshots of the annotation. Also, I'm sure you didn't mean to trivialize the project, but it's more than "just a front end". The design is what's really great about it.
  - cma 4y ago
    Sounds similar to Ted Nelson's Xanadu project.
- linusha 4y ago
  You might find https://web.hypothes.is/ https://web.hypothes.is/ helpful.
  - Denzel 4y ago
    Does Hypothesis require a cloud account that syncs your annotations? If so, these products are a non-starter for any corporate environment, which is unfortunate. Obsidian gets this right. Most software these days doesn't which is a shame.
- sorokod 4y ago
  Cool idea, why don't you have a go at it and share the outcome on HN.
- lofatdairy 4y ago
  I assume there's probably a way to modify or configure MD-based SSGs to produce side notes instead of footnotes. Hilariously I think you could use RMD because that has built-in sidenote functionality but it would probably require some manual effort to produce those nice highlights. That said, Molly is also making use of footnotes inside her margin notes, so if that's the goal my suggestions might not work.
- kees_ 4y ago
  This is what my fork of her project does https://github.com/kees-/annotate https://github.com/kees-/annotate :) Well, all it does is generate her identical format from a spec. Like @bradgessler said a gui to coerce annotations to that format from highlighting would be awesome
chubot 4y ago
Agreed this is awesome! The author understands how to use the web: HTML, CSS, and JS (which is unfortunately rare in 2023)
jzelinskie 4y ago
My team recently built NextJS-based site with sets of annotations on the research paper our project is based on (Google Zanzibar): https://authzed.com/zanzibar https://authzed.com/zanzibar https://github.com/authzed/zanzibar-annotated https://github.com/authzed/zanzibar-annotated Could be easily forked and used for other purposes. Happy to facilitate if we get any requests in the GitHub issues.
- molly0x57 4y ago
  This is super cool!
ibebrett86 4y ago
https://kaimerra.com/kaimerra-graffiti https://kaimerra.com/kaimerra-graffiti I had worked on a tool for hosting collaborative editing of these kinds of things, but we are currently evaluating whether we should pursue it further.

jtbayly 4y ago

So it's just the front-end, relying on you to manually write all the HTML. I'd love some software to make generating these (or similar) annotated documents easily. Any ideas?

batmenace 4y ago
Fermat's Library offers something that comes relatively close https://fermatslibrary.com/margins https://fermatslibrary.com/margins
- bradgessler 4y ago
  Slightly tangential: is there software that converts multi-LaTeX PDFs into responsive HTML in a reasonable way? I'd read more of these papers if they were more viewable on a phone-size viewport.
  - Eisenstein 4y ago
    Pandoc?
bradgessler 4y ago
Yeah I was thinking the same thing. A GUI where the original text material is loaded, then you highlight it and write the annotations. Bonus of each annotation could be tweeted/tooted/whatevered and include open graph screenshots of the annotation. Also, I'm sure you didn't mean to trivialize the project, but it's more than "just a front end". The design is what's really great about it.
- cma 4y ago
  Sounds similar to Ted Nelson's Xanadu project.
linusha 4y ago
You might find https://web.hypothes.is/ https://web.hypothes.is/ helpful.
- Denzel 4y ago
  Does Hypothesis require a cloud account that syncs your annotations? If so, these products are a non-starter for any corporate environment, which is unfortunate. Obsidian gets this right. Most software these days doesn't which is a shame.
sorokod 4y ago
Cool idea, why don't you have a go at it and share the outcome on HN.
lofatdairy 4y ago
I assume there's probably a way to modify or configure MD-based SSGs to produce side notes instead of footnotes. Hilariously I think you could use RMD because that has built-in sidenote functionality but it would probably require some manual effort to produce those nice highlights. That said, Molly is also making use of footnotes inside her margin notes, so if that's the goal my suggestions might not work.
kees_ 4y ago
This is what my fork of her project does https://github.com/kees-/annotate https://github.com/kees-/annotate :) Well, all it does is generate her identical format from a spec. Like @bradgessler said a gui to coerce annotations to that format from highlighting would be awesome

chubot 4y ago

Agreed this is awesome! The author understands how to use the web: HTML, CSS, and JS (which is unfortunately rare in 2023)

jzelinskie 4y ago

My team recently built NextJS-based site with sets of annotations on the research paper our project is based on (Google Zanzibar): https://authzed.com/zanzibar https://authzed.com/zanzibar https://github.com/authzed/zanzibar-annotated https://github.com/authzed/zanzibar-annotated Could be easily forked and used for other purposes. Happy to facilitate if we get any requests in the GitHub issues.

molly0x57 4y ago
This is super cool!

ibebrett86 4y ago

https://kaimerra.com/kaimerra-graffiti https://kaimerra.com/kaimerra-graffiti I had worked on a tool for hosting collaborative editing of these kinds of things, but we are currently evaluating whether we should pursue it further.