3 ms·
This seems a really week connection. > In bacteria grown in well-oxygenated laboratory conditions, the antidepressants caused the cells to generate reactive ox
by malfist 4y ago
This seems a really week connection.
> In bacteria grown in well-oxygenated laboratory conditions, the antidepressants caused the cells to generate reactive oxygen species: toxic molecules that activated the microbe’s defence mechanisms. Most prominently, this activated the bacteria’s efflux pump systems, a general expulsion system that many bacteria use to eliminate various molecules, including antibiotics. This probably explains how the bacteria could withstand the antibiotics without having specific resistance genes.
So the study was:
* Done in a petri dish
* Done in an environment dissimilar to the human body
* Showed an adaptation to the environment unrelated to antibiotic resistance
Showing adaptation "efflux pumps" for oxygen removal and claiming it's applicable to antibiotics seems like claiming yoga mats are made from jet fuel because they both contain water.
It would be really interesting if they tested a null here which I don't see noted anywhere. If the adaptation happened in the oxygen rich environment without the antibiotic it would indicate that antibiotics are not causal.
- psychphysic 4y agoIt seems the mechanism is general enough that green tea, spices that are lauded for harming bacteria might be making them more virulent
- cratermoon 4y agoThis article mentions that a study was done in humans and found no effect. https://english.elpais.com/science-tech/2023-01-24/study-suggests-use-of-antidepressants-generates-resistance-to-antibiotics.html https://english.elpais.com/science-tech/2023-01-24/study-sug...