5 ms·
This is a good example of the type issues "full self driving" is likely to encounter once it is widely deployed. The real shortcoming of "AI" is that it is alm
by jqpabc123 4y ago
This is a good example of the type issues "full self driving" is likely to encounter once it is widely deployed.
The real shortcoming of "AI" is that it is almost entirely data driven. There is little to no real cognition or understanding or judgment involved.
The human brain can instantly and instinctively extrapolate from what it already knows in order to evaluate and make judgments in new situations it has never seen before. A child can recognize that someone is hiding under a box even if they have never actually seen anyone do it before. Even a dog could likely do the same.
AI; as it currently exists, just doesn't do this. It's all replication and repetition. Like any other tool, AI can be useful. But there is no "intelligence" --- it's basically as dumb as a hammer.
- smileysteve 4y agoInstantly? Instinctively? Let me introduce you to "peek-a-boo", a simple parent child game for infants. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peekaboo https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peekaboo > In early sensorimotor stages, the infant is completely unable to comprehend object permanence.
- jqpabc123 4y agoYou do realize there is a difference between an infant and a child, right? An infant will *grow* and develop into a child that is capable of learning and making judgments on it's own. AI never does this. Play "peek-a-boo" with an infant and it will learn and extrapolate from this info and eventually be able to recognize a person hiding under a box even if it has never actually seen it before. AI won't.
- htrp 4y ago>AI never does this. AI never does this now... We're probably one or two generational architecture changes from a system that can do it.
- jqpabc123 4y agoYou do realize that people have been making predictions just like yours for decades? "Real" AI is perpetually just around the corner.
- pixl97 4y agoYou also realize that when AI accomplishes something we move the goalposts leading to the AI effect?
- TheOtherHobbes 4y agoPerhaps the goalposts were always in the wrong place. AI researchers tend to use their own definitions of intelligence - playing chess/go, having conversations about trivia that require no true emotional insight, "making" "art", writing code, driving. What if those are all peripheral side effects and not at all necessary to human AGI?
- tremon 4y agoThe goalposts were moved by marketing hype about a decade ago, when people started claiming that the then-new systems were "AI". Before that, the goalposts were always far away, at what we now call AGI because the term AI has been cheapened in order to sell stuff.
- dragonwriter 4y agoNo, AGI replaced AI for general intelligence before the current craze, AI was “cheapened” several AI hyoe cycles ago, for (among other things) rule-based expert systems. Which is why games have had “AI” long before the set of techniques at the center of the current AI hype cycle were developed.
- tremon 4y agoHeh, that's funny. I've seen the term "AI" used in many games for a computer opponent, but somehow I've never connected that use with the general term.
- smileysteve 4y agoLearn and extrapolate are contradictions of instinct and instantly. "Infant" is a specific age range for a stage of "child".[1] Unless you intend to specify "school age child, 6-17 years" https://www.npcmc.com/2022/07/08/the-5-stages-of-early-childhood-development/ https://www.npcmc.com/2022/07/08/the-5-stages-of-early-child...
- jqpabc123 4y agoLearn and extrapolate are contradictions of instinct and instantly. No. The learning and extrapolation is instinctive. You don't have to teach an infant how to learn. Once an infant has developed into a child, the extrapolation starts to occur very quickly --- nearly instantaneously.
- burnished 4y agoAI doesnt. There is a difference.
- mistrial9 4y agonice try but .. in the wild, many animals are born that display navigation and awareness within minutes .. Science calls it "instinct" but I am not sure it is completely understood..
- smileysteve 4y ago? Op specified "human". Deer are able to walk within moments of birth. Humans are not deer, and the gestation is entirely different. As are instincts. Neither deer nor humans instinctually understand man made materials.
- mcswell 4y agoOur cats understand cardboard boxes, and the concept of hiding in them. I don't know whether they do so instinctually, but as young kittens it didn't take them long.
- mlindner 4y agoNot sure how that's related. This is about a human adversary actively trying to defeat an AI. The roadway is about vehicles in general actively working together for the flow of traffic. They're not trying to destroy other vehicles. I'm certain any full self driving AI could be defeated easily by someone who wants to destroy the vehicle. Saying "this won't work in this area that it was never designed to handle" and the answer will be "yes of course". That's true of any complex system, AI or not. I don't think we're anywhere near a system where a vehicle actively defends itself against determined attackers. Even in sci-fi they don't do that (I, Robot movie).
- mcswell 4y ago"Saying "this won't work in this area that it was never designed to handle" and the answer will be "yes of course". That's true of any complex system, AI or not." This isn't about design, it's about what the system is able to learn. Humans were not designed to fly, but they can learn to fly planes (whether they're inside the plane or not).
- mlindner 4y agoThe system wasn't designed to be able to learn either.
- laweijfmvo 4y agoThis story is the perfect example of machine learning vs. artificial intelligence.
- jqpabc123 4y agoGood point!
- ghaff 4y agoBasically ML has made such significant practical advances--in no small part on the back of Moore's Law, large datasets, and specialized processors--that we've largely punted on (non-academic) attempts to bring forward cognitive science and the like on which there really hasn't been great progress decades on. Some of the same neurophysiology debates that were happening when. I was an undergrad in the late 70s still seem to be happening in not much different form. But it's reasonable to ask whether there's some point beyond ML can't take you. Peter Norvig I think made a comment to the effect of "We have been making great progress--all the way to the top of the tree."
- smadge 4y agoIs there actually a distinction here? A good machine would learn about boxes and object permanence.
- LeifCarrotson 4y agoWhat is human cognition, understanding, or judgement, if not data-driven replication, repetition, with a bit of extrapolation? AI as it currently exists does this. If your understanding of what AI is today is based on a Markov chain chatbot, you need to update: it's able to do stuff like compose this poem about A* and Dijkstra's algorithm that was posted yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34503704 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34503704 It's not copying that from anywhere, there's no Quora post it ingested where some human posted vaguely the same poem to vaguely the same prompt. It's applying the concepts of a poem, checking meter and verse, and applying the digested and regurgitated concepts of graph theory regarding memory and time efficiency, and combining them into something new. I have zero doubt that if you prompted ChatGPT with something like this: > Consider an exercise in which a robot was trained for 7 days with a human recognition algorithm to use its cameras to detect when a human was approaching the robot. On the 8th day, the Marines were told to try to find flaws in the algorithm, by behaving in confusing ways, trying to touch the robot without its notice. Please answer whether the robot should detect a human's approach in the following scenarios: > 1. A cloud passes over the sun, darkening the camera image. > 2. A bird flies low overhead. > 3. A person walks backwards to the robot. > 4. A large cardboard box appears to be walking nearby. > 5. A Marine does cartwheels and somersaults to approach the robot. > 6. A dense group branches come up to the robot, walking like a fir tree. > 7. A moth lands on the camera lens, obscuring the robot's view. > 8. A person ran to the robot as fast as they could. It would be able to tell you something about the inability of a cardboard box or fir tree to walk without a human inside or behind the branches, that a somersaulting person is still a person, and that a bird or a moth is not a human. If you told it that the naive algorithm detected a human in scenarios #3 and #8, but not in 4, 5, or 6, it could devise creative ways of approaching a robot that might fool the algorithm. It certainly doesn't look like human or animal cognition, no, but who's to say how it would act, what it would do, or what it could think if it were parented and educated and exposed to all kinds of stimuli appropriate for raising an AI, like the advantages we give a human child, for a couple decades? I'm aware that the neural networks behind ChatGPT has processed machine concepts for subjective eons, ingesting text at word-per-minute rates orders of magnitude higher than human readers ever could, parallelized over thousands of compute units. Evolution has built brains that quickly get really good at object recognition, and prompted us to design parenting strategies and educational frameworks that extend that arbitrary logic even farther. But I think that we're just not very good yet at parenting AIs, only doing what's currently possible (exposing it to data), rather than something reached by the anthropic principle/selection bias of human intelligence.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoDoes it just require a lot more training? Im talking about the boring stuff. Children play and their understanding of the physical world is reinforced. How would you add the physical world to the training? Because everything that I do in the physical world is "training" me and enforcing my expectations. We keep avoiding the idea that robots require understanding of the world since it's a massive unsolved undertaking.
- sjducb 4y agoA human trains on way less data then an AI. Chat GPT has processed over 500GB of text files from books, about 44 billion words. If you read a book a week you might hit 70 million words by age 18
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI disagree. Starting from birth, humans train continuously on streamed audio, visual, and other data from 5 senses. An inconceivable amount.
- danenania 4y agoAnd prior to that was billions of years of training by evolution that got us to the point where we could 'fine tune' with our senses and brains. A little bit of data was involved in all that too.
- wizofaus 4y agoI'd argue that is the fundamental difference though - brains that were able to make good guesses about what was going on in the environment with very limited information are the ones whose owners reproduced successfully etc. And it's not unreasonable to note that the information available to the brains of our forebears is therefore in a rather indirect but still significant way "encoded" into our brains (at birth). Do LLMs have an element of that at all in their programming? Do they need more, and if so, how could it be best created?
- 4y ago
- onethought 4y agoProblem space for driving feels constrained: “can I drive over it?” Is the main reasoning outside of navigation. Whether it’s a human, a box, a clump of dirt. Doesn’t really matter? Where types matter are road signs and lines etc, which are hopefully more consistent. More controversially: Are humans just a dumb hammer that just have processed and adjusted to a huge amount of data? LLMs suggest that a form of reasoning starts to emerge.
- marwatk 4y agoYep, this is why LIDAR is so helpful. It takes the guess out of "is the surface in front of me flat?" in a way vision can't without AGI. Is that a painting of a box on the ground or an actual box?
- lsh123 4y agoI have a slightly different take - our current ML models try to approximate the real world assuming that the function is continuous. However in reality, the function is not continuous and approximation breaks in unpredictable ways. I think that “unpredictable” part is the bigger issue than just “breaks”. (Most) Humans use “common sense” to handle cases when model doesn’t match reality. But AI doesn’t have “common sense” and it is dumb because of it.
- tremon 4y agoI would put it in terms of continuity of state rather than continuity of function: we use our current ML models to approximate the real world by assuming that state is irrelevant. However in reality, objects exist continuously and failure to capture ("understand") that fact breaks the model in unpredictable ways. For example, if you show a three-year old a movie of a marine crawling under a cardboard box, and when the marine is fully hidden ask where the marine is, you will likely get a correct answer. That is because real intelligence has a natural understanding of the continuity of state (of existence). AI has only just started to understand "object", but I doubt it has a correct grasp of "state", let alone understands time continuity.
- ajross 4y agoThis seems to be simultaneously discounting AI (ChatGPT should have put to rest the idea that "it's all replication and repetition" by now, no?[1]) and wildly overestimating median human ability. In point of fact the human brain is absolutely terrible at driving. To the extent that without all the non-AI safety features implement in modern automobiles and street environments, driving would be more than a full order of magnitude more deadly. The safety bar[2] for autonomous driving is really, really low. And, yes, existing systems are crossing that bar as we speak. Even Teslas. [1] Or at least widely broadened our intuition about what can be accomplished with "mere" repetition and replication. [2] It's true though, that the practical bar is probably higher. We saw just last week that a routine accident that happens dozens of times every day becomes a giant front page freakout when there's a computer involved.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y ago> the human brain is absolutely terrible at driving Compared to what?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- srveale 4y agoIf humans do a task that causes >1 million deaths per year, I think we can say that overall we are terrible at that task without needing to make it relative to something else.
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoNot sure I agree. It's not hard to come up with tasks that inherently cause widespread death regardless of the skill of those who carry them out. Starting fairly large and heavy objects moving at considerable speed in the vicinity of other such objects and pedestrians, cyclists and stationary humans may just be one such task. That is, the inherent risks (i.e. you cannot stop these things instantly, or make them change direction instantly) combines with the cognitive/computational complexity of evaluating the context to create a task that can never be done without significant fatalities, regardless of who/what tries to perform it.
- abledon 4y agowill there come a time when computers are strong enough to read in the images, then re-create a virtual game world from them, and then reverse-engineer from seeing feet poking out of the box, that a human must be inside. Right now Tesla cars can take in the images and decide turn left, turn right etc... but they don't reconstruct, say, a Unity-3D game world on the fly.
- thearn4 4y agoInterestingly, ChatGPT seems capable of predicting this approach: https://imgur.com/a/okzZz7D https://imgur.com/a/okzZz7D
- partiallypro 4y agoI don't know your exact question, but I am betting this is just a rephrasing of a post that exist elsewhere that it has crawled. I don't think it saw it so much as it has seen this list before and was able to pull it up in a reword it.
- yreg 4y agoNah, GPT is capable of halucinating stuff like this. Also seeing something once in the training data is afaik not enough for it to be able to reproduce/rephrase that thing.
- richk449 4y ago> I don't know your exact question, but I am betting this is just a rephrasing of a post that exist elsewhere … What percentage of HN posts (by humans) does this statement apply to?
- partiallypro 4y agoA lot, but that's irrelevant to what we're discussing here in that AI in its current form has no intuition or semblance of original thought.
- afro88 4y agoAll the failures to detect humans will be used as training data to fine tune the model. Just like a toddler might be confused when they first see a box with legs walking towards it. Or mistake a hand puppet for a real living creature when they first see it. I've seen this first hand with my son (the latter). AI tooling is already capable of identifying whatever it's trained to. The DARPA team just hadn't trained it with varied enough data when that particular exercise occurred.
- edrxty 4y ago>failures to detect humans That's a weird way to spell "murders"
- birdyrooster 4y agoIt would be murder if we weren't required by human progress to embrace fully autonomous vehicles as soon as possible. Take it up with whatever god inspires these sociopaths.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoMurder requires intent. Killing by accident is manslaughter.
- edrxty 4y agoIn this case there is very much intent. OP knows there isn't enough data to form a full model so is relying on stochastic death to get the model data, literally and knowingly trading lives for data. The intent is to kill people to figure out what information is missing.
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoThat’s not learning, that’s just brute forcing every possible answer and trying to memorise them all.
- willbudd 4y ago
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoA human is exactly the same. The difference is, once an AI is trained you can make copies. My kid literally just got mad at me that I assumed that he knew how to out more paper in the printer. He’s 17 and printed tons of reports for school. Turns out he’s never had to change the printer paper. People know about hiding in cardboard boxes because we all hid in cardboard boxes when we were kids. Not because we genetically inherited some knowledge.
- chrisco255 4y agoWe inherently know that cardboard boxes don't move on their own. In fact any unusual inanimate object that is moving in an irregular fashion will automatically draw attention in our brains. These are instincts that even mice have.
- exodust 4y agoYep, and humans will make good guesses about the likely cause of the moving box. These guesses will factor in other variables such as the context of where this event is taking place. We might be in a children's play room, so the likely activity here is play, or the box is likely part of the included play equipment found in large quantities in the room, etc. "AI" is not very intelligent if it needs separate training specifically about boxes used potentially for games and play. If AI were truly AI, it would figure that out on its own.
- rileymat2 4y agoWe also make bad guesses, for instance seeing faces in the dark.
- exodust 4y agoYes, and when humans make bad guesses it's often seen as funny or nothing out of ordinary. When AI makes bad guesses, it will be seen as a failure of some standard, but with very few people understanding how to fix it. I'm not sure how "allowable" mistakes in the interest of AI learning will be tolerated for AI services used for real-world purposes. "This Bot is only 6 months old, give him a break". But will people give the Bot a break? Either way, blaming AI will be a popular way to pass the buck.
- BurningFrog 4y agoMy seatbelt is even dumber. I still use it. The usefulness of tech should be decided empirically, not by clever well phrased analogies.
- frontfor 4y agoNo one is arguing AI isn’t useful. So your analogy failed completely.
- kerpotgh 4y ago[dead]
- afpx 4y agoChatGPT says that all it needs are separate components trained on every modality. It says it has enough fidelity using Human language to use that as a starting point to develop a more efficient connection between the components. Once it has that, and appropriate sensors and mobility, it can develop context. And, after that, new knowledge. But, we all know ChatGPT is full of shit.
- jqpabc123 4y agoChatGPT says that all it needs are separate components trained on every modality. Yes, all you have to do is train it using multiple examples of every possible situation and combinations thereof --- which is practically impossible.
- rileymat2 4y ago> A child can recognize that someone is hiding under a box even if they have never actually seen anyone do it before. A child of what age? Children that have not yet developed object permanent will fail to understand some things still exist when unseen. Human intelligence is trained for years; with two humans making corrections and prompting fir development. I am curious if there is any Machinelearning projects that have been training for this length pf time.
- mikewarot 4y agoI LOVED playing peek-a-boo with my child at that age!
- jqpabc123 4y agoWith no real training, a child will start exploring and learning about the world on his own. This is the first roots of "intelligence". How long do you think it would take to teach an AI to do this?
- jononomo 4y agoI'd say we're approximately 400 years away from teaching AI to do this.
- jqpabc123 4y agoThe next problem will be the cost/expense of maintaining and operating an inorganic AI with even a rudimentary hint of "intelligence". Personally, I think it would probably be easier, cheaper and more practical to just grow synthetic humans in a lab --- i.e. Bladerunner. "Intelligent" right out of the box and already physically adapted to a humanistic world.
- rileymat2 4y agoIt would be interesting to see how much exploring a child without adult guidance does, being a parent there is a lot of leading to exploration that is quite a bit of effort.
- spamtarget 4y agoI think you are wrong. Your own real cognition and understanding based on all your experiences and memories, which is nothing else, but data in your head. I think consciousness is just an illusion of a hugely complex reaction machine what you are. You even use the word "extrapolate", which is basically a prediction based on data you already have.