6 ms·
Luckily, any degradation can all be predicted ahead of time. A 60kwh car battery might cost $10k, and allow 2000 charge cycles. So each kwh cycled into and ou
by londons_explore 4y ago
Luckily, any degradation can all be predicted ahead of time.
A 60kwh car battery might cost $10k, and allow 2000 charge cycles. So each kwh cycled into and out of the battery costs 8 cents.
So a smart algorithm can decide it's worth draining the battery back into the grid if the profit to be made is more than 8 cents.
Buuuut... Delaying charging till later is free. So another car owner's car might see on the futures market that delaying charging starting from 6pm till 11pm might save a few cents.
Obviously that means it's most economically efficient for every owner to do grid balancing merely by smartly delaying charges - and in turn price fluctuations will rarely exceed 8 cents.
The component that is missing to make this happen is cars which have code to automate this process, and markets in place that have API's to let the car buy and sell energy, and futures in energy, by the kwh. Users need not understand how it works - they just tick the tickbox which says 'charge and discharge smartly to minimize electricity costs'.
Today, those markets are typically only open to big players, cars don't have a tickbox, and wall chargers typically won't let a car put power into the grid.
- Yizahi 4y agoNow that's an interesting idea. Let's see how it will unfold globally. Maybe it will indeed be painless feature.
- Maxion 4y agoThis can be done by using a smart AC charger. In europe (At least) the company Easee makes AC chargeres that are WiFi / 4G enabled. In Sweden (And Norway) you can connect them to a service like Tibber, which allows you to automatically enable/disable charging with the electricity price, assuming you have a spot price electricity contract. https://tibber.com/en/product/easee https://tibber.com/en/product/easee Easee chargers also have a pretty bitching API, so you can also make your own automations using e.g. home assistant or what have you.
- danuker 4y agoIt worries me that if industrial-purpose batteries cost the same and have similar degradation, grid services will also decide not to charge/discharge if the profit is less than 8 cents. This tells me that Li-Ion batteries are far from the ideal medium for grid storage.
- devmor 4y agoBatteries are extremely inefficient. Capacitors are much more resilient in terms of charge cycles (by orders of magnitude). If one were to build a "facility" to hold short term load, that's likely what they'd use. They just can't be used in cars because they're incredibly volatile and don't hold a charge for a long period of time.
- kragen 4y agocapacitors are very low energy density and very high cost per joule of storage so they are never used this way
- antipotoad 4y agoThe idea of super-capacitors in cars is positively horrifying, knowing how explosive just the small ones can be. At grid level though, is there anything that speaks against them? Edit: to answer my own question, they look pretty good [1]. Significantly lower storage density than batteries (roughly 50Wh/L versus 420Wh/L for Li-ion), but still dense enough for this to be workable at grid level. The linked presentation proposes converting decommissioned power plants into grid-level capacitor storage facilities, since the transmission switchyards are often intact. Furthermore, all the technology is available today, and when built, capacitors require almost zero maintenance. [1]: https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/piprod/documents/Session_D_Miller_rev.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/piprod/documents/Ses...
- londons_explore 4y agoTodays grids don't have much need for energy storage on the sub-10 second timeframe. Ie. there is rarely any money to be made by taking power from the grid now and returning it in 10 seconds. For technical reasons, thats because the 'spinning reserve' - which is momentum of every synchronous motor and generator across the nation - already adequately handles this. Also, large generation stations are required to have a 'load line' which damps high frequency oscillations. The load line can best be described as 'whenever the grid frequency starts slowing down, generators must put more energy in automatically'. Things like wind and solar typically don't have the ability to do that. For human reasons, it's because electricity markets tend to be minute by minute at most. For all those reasons, I don't think you'll make any money with capacitor energy storage banks (not to be confused with capacitors for grid scale power factor correction, which can be profitable).
- trashtester 4y ago> Buuuut... Delaying charging till later is free. This functionality is already there. > So each kwh cycled into and out of the battery costs 8 cents. This is quite much. If you add other infra overhead, feeding power back into the grid is not going to produce much revenue for the individual unless the selling price is maybe 20 cents above the price when charging. On the other hand, something that MAY make more sense, is if the car battery can be used to provide power to the owner's own house during short price peaks. This might allow some savings even in stable grids, but the killer app would be in grids that have rolling blackouts during high demand periods. And even for grids where blackouts are infrequent, if your car can serve as large UPS for your house (combined with a large capacitor to keep the power stable), such functionality in the charger may be worth the cost of the hardware for many people. (Bringing the number of units up and hence the cost per unit down over time.) Still, though, for grid stability it is probably much better to use dedicated batteries as part of the grid itself than to use car batteries.
- shagie 4y ago> And even for grids where blackouts are infrequent, if your car can serve as large UPS for your house (combined with a large capacitor to keep the power stable), such functionality in the charger may be worth the cost of the hardware for many people. (Bringing the number of units up and hence the cost per unit down over time.) https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/downloads/tesla-new-vehicle-limited-warranty-en-us.pdf https://www.tesla.com/sites/default/files/downloads/tesla-ne... > Warranty Limitations > This New Vehicle Limited Warranty does not cover any vehicle damage or malfunction directly or indirectly caused by, due to or resulting from normal wear or deterioration, abuse, misuse, negligence, accident, improper maintenance, operation, storage or transport, including, but not limited to, any of the following: > ... > Using the vehicle as a stationary power source
- ben-schaaf 4y ago> All model year 2013 and newer Nissan Leafs are approved for use with the FE-15 bidirectional charger, and the automaker states that battery warranties will not be affected. https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/12/23349971/nissan-leaf-bidirectional-charging-approved-v2h-v2g-fermata-energy https://www.theverge.com/2022/9/12/23349971/nissan-leaf-bidi...
- svggrfgovgf 4y agoPeople value things differently. You'd have to pay me way more than the 8 cents/kwh it cost me to use my battery. I'd want to be heavily compensated for the inconvenience of replacing the battery or car prematurely.
- martin-adams 4y agoPlus the reduced range between new and replacement.
- weard_beard 4y agoPlus my time and inconvenience of not having full range transport at all times. The time of someone who can currently afford an EV is more expensive than the time of someone who cannot.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoIf I had a LiFePo4 battery that's good for 750,000 km I'd be willing to accept less than 8c because there's no way the rest of the car is going to last 750,000 km.
- sokoloff 4y agoYou'd be willing to take around a penny per km of battery lifespan? I accept your decision at face-value, but it hardly seems worth it to me. That might just inevitably conclude in "OK, I guess others are willing to ask a lower price than I am, so I won't be in a position to participate in a V2G scheme."
- japaneseminisub 4y agoFrom GPs post its actually $5 plus 8c per KW. That seems more reasonable for the owner, but no utility co would pay it.
- dmurray 4y ago> A 60kwh car battery might cost $10k, and allow 2000 charge cycles. So each kwh cycled into and out of the battery costs 8 cents. If you can really treat the whole cost of the battery as X cents per charge cycle, disregarding the lifetime of the car/battery, this won't work at grid scale. Someone else will build a storage facility that just charges and discharges batteries, and they will outcompete rational EV owners, because they will have economies of scale and battery banks designed for this use. It only makes sense if the EV owner can somehow get charge capacity "for free" - eg the car will be EOL after 1000 charges but the battery lasts 2000 - he should sell the extra 1000. Or alternatively if getting 8c now is better than getting 1 charge in several years time (plausible if interest rates, energy futures prices etc are right). However, this could be wrong. The same logic says rooftop solar can't exist without special subsidies, and a lot of people disagree with me there.
- iso1210 4y agoThis does work today at grid scale, people use their home batteries (either on wheels or not) to charge/discharge to the grid in the UK all the time. If someone builds that storage facility to do it commercially then great. > rooftop solar can't exist without special subsidies Yet it does
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sokoloff 4y agoThere are special subsidies for rooftop solar here in the US (Solar Investment Tax Credit). Are there not subsidies for solar where you live? https://www.seia.org/initiatives/solar-investment-tax-credit-itc https://www.seia.org/initiatives/solar-investment-tax-credit... > The solar Investment Tax Credit (ITC) is one of the most important federal policy mechanisms to support the growth of solar energy in the United States. Since the ITC was enacted in 2006, the U.S. solar industry has grown by more than 200x - creating hundreds of thousands of jobs and investing billions of dollars in the U.S. economy in the process.
- 4y ago
- EGreg 4y agoPeople measure stuff in terms of $ when they should be looking at the global resources on the planet, the garbage and the externalized costs. Until we move to a resource-based economy that takes these into account, we’ll be destroying the planet while on paper the carbon credit accounting looks perfect.
- punnerud 4y agoThis already exist in Norway with the company Tibber, that have more than 400.000 users. They do just that, let you connect your EV so they adjust the charging and guarantee a lower price. The market they can buy and sell this capacity is called an “aggregator”, and they can earn more money on this then selling just power.
- mercutio2 4y agoThis is “let a large entity suck up much of the arbitrage value, with a small fraction going to you”, and already exists in most countries. Seems quite different from “your household is an autonomous actor and you get almost all of the arbitrage value of reducing peak consumption”, which would be a radically different system (but ignores who’s going to pay for distribution, which is getting closer and closer to being the dominant cost of the grid).
- pjc50 4y ago> Delaying charging till later is free. So another car owner's car might see on the futures market that delaying charging starting from 6pm till 11pm might save a few cents. Yeah, I think that's far more likely. I can also see the possibility of a grid-mandated signal for "please, stop charging for five minutes, we're at capacity".
- staringback 4y agoLet's hope you don't need to go anywhere urgently in the middle of the night... oops not enough battery to make it!
- schiffern 4y agoThis is why you have an "always charge immediately to X%" option in the UI. You set this to whatever range an unexpected trip might require. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34518188 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34518188 If your life is so chaotic that this doesn't work for some reason, don't turn on V1G
- tzs 4y ago> A 60kwh car battery might cost $10k, and allow 2000 charge cycles After those 2000 cycles is the battery completely dead, or does it still work but at a reduced capacity? If it does still work at a reduced capacity, does continued use reduce the capacity to 0 after a while, or does is plateau at some fixed reduced capacity and stop further degrading?
- thrashh 4y agoIt may be calculable, but is it economical? That 8 cents isn't free. If the power company pays, that means customers pay. If customers don't pay, society has to pay. There are other power storage solutions like pumped hydro that don't have to deal with battery chemistry degradation, for example, but they have higher investment costs. This study is great but a energy storage comparison study that calculates total cost would tell us much more. Wouldn't be surprised if the Department of Energy already has or is [1] [1] They do a lot of these studies already. i.e. https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/ae17da3d-e8a5-4163-a3ec-2e6fb0b5677d/Projected-Costs-of-Generating-Electricity-2020.pdf https://iea.blob.core.windows.net/assets/ae17da3d-e8a5-4163-...
- singhrac 4y agoThe spread between wholesale energy prices between high and low renewable times (with low-compared-to-future renewable penetration) is around $20/MW (it’s not $2 and it’s not usually $200), or about $0.02/kwh, so this isn’t a viable return. I doubt selling into the grid will ever get you retail prices in return (someone had to maintain load power lines). I think people worry a lot about market access when it doesn’t make sense. The market operators cannot handle the settlement and operations overhead of microscale power generators. They are not offering reliable commitments, and the metering just doesn’t exist at the small scale. Your local PG&E equivalent isn’t equipped to operate an efficient power market, I don’t think. For context - a “small” scale solar power plant is in the 10s of MWs, which >1000x bigger then a car battery at full output. Utility-scale storage is also in the same ballpark.
- whazor 4y agoHere in EU, day ahead prices that are available to me as consumer are now ranging from €0.18/kWh to €0.34/kWh in the same day (winter). So that is 16 cents per kWh diff to profit from. I guess there is some energy loss with charging and de-charging. Since prices a per day, announced the day before, the algorithm is not that complicated. Also, if I install solar panels, the electricity just goes back into the grid, and I would get money for it. For the car it would be the same, just reverse the electricity into the grid. So it is mostly just the connecting the day-ahead prices, plus the cars and wall chargers returning electricity of-course.
- enslavedrobot 4y agoThe number of cycles a battery can sustain strongly depends on its state of charge and depth of discharge. A cars battery can cycle between 30 and 70% charge for 20000 cycles or 0.8 cents/kWh according to your calculation.