2 ms·
> Can't every possible property we can conceive of a subset be constructed in a similar fashion such that the superset contains at least the same number of elem
by lmm 4y ago
> Can't every possible property we can conceive of a subset be constructed in a similar fashion such that the superset contains at least the same number of elements and never less?
What do you mean? A superset always contains at least the same number of elements as a subset, by definition. A superset generally has fewer or at least weaker properties; "colour is one of A, B or C" is a weaker property than "colour is A", and there's no real difference between that and saying the superset doesn't have the property at all (I could say "my subset consists of shiny marbles; my subset has the property that they're shiny and my superset does not have that property", or I could say "my subset has the property that shininess is true, and my superset has the property that shininess is true or false", and there isn't really any difference once you get down to the set-theoretic level - a property is just a boolean-valued function). The only superset that has exactly the same properties as the set itself is the set itself (since "is a member of the subset" is a valid property).
- antihipocrat 4y agoOk, how about I define a new property that my superset contains a 'rainbow' of colors. The subset has only one of the colors, it doesn't contain the rainbow property. The original post claimed that the superset always has the same or fewer properties. I was questioning whether this was true. You've mentioned that it is generally true, which seems like a better way to describe the concept. -- edit: I understand now, in my example above the subset must contain a property by which it could be identified. The original rainbow property is lost but a new one is gained.
- lmm 4y ago> Ok, how about I define a new property that my superset contains a 'rainbow' of colors. The subset has only one of the colors, it doesn't contain the rainbow property. You're mixing levels. The property is something satisfied by members of the set, not by the set as a whole.