4 ms·
The Fairtax prebate alleviates the burden on the working poor, but the regressiveness shifts up to the middle class. The wealthy still don't consume most of th
by jfengel 4y ago
The Fairtax prebate alleviates the burden on the working poor, but the regressiveness shifts up to the middle class.
The wealthy still don't consume most of their income. As the article you link to points out, "you wouldn’t be taxed on your interest, dividends and capital gains" -- the things that wealthy people do with their money. The burden of running the country would fall on the middle class, raising their taxes from what they are now, and decreasing it on the wealthiest.
Economists only prefer consumption taxes on things they're trying to diminish, like producing carbon. On everything else, they want consumption. It's what keeps the economy going; it's the essence of GDP. Consumption increases the velocity of money and keeps people employed. Sitting on your cash causes deflation, which most economists consider very dangerous.
- verdverm 4y agoCorporations would pay the most. "The burden of running the country" would not fall on the middle class to support the country. The class based arguments are very unimaginative. Why can't a consumption tax have progressive components? For example, if you buy a single-family residential property over $500k, the rate is higher, $1M higher, etc.. Buying a yacht? higher rate. Buying food? lower rate. A consumption tax does not have to be a flat, blankly applied tax.
- jfengel 4y agoI am referring to the Fairtax mentioned in the article. We could design many other less bad systems, but they're not on offer at the moment.
- verdverm 4y agoyou also referred to the link I sent and other ideas not in either while also making generalizations without supporting evidence > "you wouldn’t be taxed on your interest, dividends and capital gains" -- the things that wealthy people do with their money These are not things wealthy do with their money, rather the benefits of investing money into companies and properties. One would expect that purchasing a property would incur a consumption tax and the purchases made by the company with that money would also be taxed.