4 ms·
The author is Chemdelic. I was expecting a video by Nile Red, but I was not disappointed. (As the video explain, don't try this at home unless you have a degree
by gus_massa 4y ago
The author is Chemdelic. I was expecting a video by Nile Red, but I was not disappointed. (As the video explain, don't try this at home unless you have a degree in Chemistry or something. That invisible fumes looks nasty.)
- O__________O 4y agoAgree, surprised there are not more warnings on the video, especially given the video’s title. As a comparison, here’s NileRed’s version: https://youtube.com/watch?v=j-PrAczOGb0 https://youtube.com/watch?v=j-PrAczOGb0
- gus_massa 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L23akTkDqTM&t=79s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L23akTkDqTM&t=79s :)
- petre 4y agoDefinitely do not try this at home without a Chemistry degree. Why? It's easy to accidentaly produce phosgene (WWI chemical weapon, smells like freshly cut grass) by combining chloroform fumes and oxygen under UV light or chlorine with carbon monoxide from a gas burner (yellow flame).
- kortex 4y agoActual chemist here: it's actually pretty hard to accidentally produce phosgene via chloroform. Obviously don't deliberately try to oxidize chloroform in an unventilated space, but you should be fine in a fume cupboard with basic science hygiene. Don't attempt this without an understanding of general lab/workshop hygiene (ALWAYS wear glasses, gloves, labcoat or smock, no polyester, use proper ventilation, put hair back). But this is a pretty basic beginner chemistry experiment.
- ok_computer 4y agoEven doing this with a chemistry background is incredibly irresponsible. There’s more than personal know how at work in industrial and academic labs. Fume hood stacks well above grade and incinerators and permits or registration. Plus the waste disposal issue and byproducts. This brand of youtube entertainment is super bad. Same thing with people extracting mercury or whatever. Like what is the best end case: you’ve done bench work in your neighborhood and are a point emitter of byproducts and create a product that have no real end use. Chlorinated solvents are no joke and making a carcinogen for youtube views is beyond dumb. I’d call the cops if I saw my neighbor doing some home cooking like this it’s not well thought out and just selfish and irresponsible.
- girvo 4y ago> Chlorinated solvents are no joke I mean, you're right, but I can also literally walk down to Bunnings and buy some, so I'm not sure these YouTubers are really tipping the scales.
- ok_computer 4y agoI'm not offended by the volume he's producing, just the act of doing low value chemistry work at home making something gross, it will get repeated by less capable viewers in uncontrolled environments. On the other hand, I always thought things like anarchist cookbook and erowid type stuff is great for knowledge sharing. I don't think there should be a monopoly on knowing how to do stuff but this is different, maybe the youtube viewership monetization, I cannot place my finger on it. I'm saying this is a dumb synthesis to show off, there is no value in the product, if anything it is a disposal liability, and it's in a home lab. One mistake and you get a chlorine cloud or an organic solvent spill in a residential setting. It glorifies understanding where the electrons or protons jump but its super basic. Like how hungry for validation do you need to be to show off your recent degree or internet recipe scavenging. Solvents are commoditized. Chlorinated solvents need to be phased out. Whereas, in industrial settings that are vilified for justifiable reasons there is increasing scrutiny on any solvents introduction to processes especially chlorinated types for good reason. I'm saying it's a dumb thing to do and totally misses the mark for educational videos. That guy who makes chips in his garage with nasty etch gasses, high voltage magnatrons, photoresist, and projector litho I'll admit is really cool and impressive but may pose a greater neighbor threat if a mishap happens.