5 ms·
Personally, I don't know any awesome engineers who sucked at school. I don't know if any of them would work at Canonical (which has exhausted most of its growth
by renewiltord 4y ago
Personally, I don't know any awesome engineers who sucked at school. I don't know if any of them would work at Canonical (which has exhausted most of its growth potential by now), though.
Nothing wrong with the question, imho, if you have lots of applicants. I doubt it adversely selects for the job. It drops a lot of legitimately skilled people, but every method does.
For interviewing, it makes sense to budget an amount of time you want to spend on interviews per unit time, an amount of time you're willing to spend per unit hire, and just optimize those metrics. If you're hitting those targets, there's no harm in all sorts of arbitrary selection criteria that don't hit protected categories. They do two things: help you hit the time budgets, and transmit your priorities to candidates.
Personally, I find it hard to be upset about someone else's selection criteria. That's their honest expression of what they care about. It's like people complaining about interview feedback. Why ask if you're going to fight about the answer? It's like that.
- vdqtp3 4y ago> I don't know any awesome engineers who sucked at school This makes me think you don't know many awesome engineers.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoOr any for that matter...the majority of schools educate for the lowest common denominator. Most talented individuals I know did supplemental education on their own outside of school systems.
- renewiltord 4y agoRight, it's exactly as you say. They educate to and test to the simplest form. Failing at even that means you fail at something the lowest common denominator, as you put it, passes at. That's a pretty strong indicator of something.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoThere are those who refuse to play the game because they don't see a poor schooling experience as useful and you're saying those people are the same as those who can't do basic math. Or at least you're not distinguishing the difference.
- renewiltord 4y agoYes, that is correct. I don't believe there is utility in attempting to distinguish that.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoYour comment speaks for itself so I won't elaborate further.
- yamazakiwi 4y agoWhat if their selection criteria is illegal?
- lll-o-lll 4y ago> Personally, I don't know any awesome engineers who sucked at school. To me this simply shows a lack of life experience. One of the best engineers I know left school before graduating. Has ADHD, was a bit messed up with drugs wrong crowd etc at that time. He’s also a genius, had his life together for over 20 years and a very senior person at my current company. Why should some bad decisions over 20 years ago have any relevance to the value he’d provide now? Why should anything you did over 20 years ago have any relevance, good or bad? This is unquestionably yet another example of ageism in an industry that is riddled with it.