7 ms·
512GB 14” M2 Pro MacBook Pro has slower SSD than previous model
- xiphias2 4y agoI'm happy that I stayed on M1 MacBook Pro. I wouldn't be surprised if these numbers translated to slower app startup times, a slightly faster CPU won't balance it out. Correction: somebody already noticed that Lightroom got slower.
- jemmyw 4y agoWhat do you mean by "happy you stayed on"? Do you usually upgrade your laptop immediately to the next one the moment it's released? Or do you mean you opted to buy an m1 after the m2 pro was already available?
- xiphias2 4y agoI was planning to upgrade, but I won't spend money for staying on the same TSMC process node (I hoped Apple waits for 3nm with M2). Right now though I feel that the new laptop is not even superior, it's similar category (still awesome).
- cevn 4y agoThat makes sense sadly. I imagine most people use LR on their desktops though. I can't fit half of my library on one of these SSDs.
- xiphias2 4y agoLot of people need it while travelling, and the cloud version downloads only the data you ask for.
- _aavaa_ 4y agoLet’s dwell a little on the insanity that Lightroom gets slow on an drive with ONLY 2.8GB/s read speeds
- joenathanone 4y agoIts probably more iops effecting performance than transfer speed, imagine going from a 4 lane highway to a 2 lane, of course reality is a bit more nuanced.
- Uncorrupt4319 4y agoI'm just happy that I finally found the courage to ditch LR and Adobe a few years ago. Seeing that their performance issues are still plaguing them doesn't surprise me in the least. Switched out to Photo Mechanic for cataloguing and Capture One / Affinity Photo for editing if anyone is interested.
- 0xakhil 4y agoFor ipad, Capture One subscription is way costlier than Lr.
- Uncorrupt4319 4y agoTrue, hence the Affinity Photo app. Good for on-the-go editing and syncing back to my laptop
- acdha 4y agoOne thing to remember is that random I/O did not get slower: the benchmark they used is a very simple one simulating writing a single 16GB stream as quickly as possible — unless your job is something like copying high-resolution video files around, you're unlikely to see it slower. That does affect a few people but consider what it means: you can fill the drive up in a little over 2 minutes on the M1 and a little over 3 minutes on the M2. The only way that's relevant to you is if you have some other high-end hardware which can stream data that fast _and_ you're doing relatively little processing on that data _and_ you don't actually store that data for very long (otherwise you need some kind of attached storage array). Lightroom is a terrible app so to the extent that it needs a high-end SSD to start up, that's telling us what we've already known for a decade: Adobe doesn't care about quality and it's a shame the very noticeably faster Aperture was discontinued.
- operatingthetan 4y agoHas OWC or some other company come up with SSD upgrades for these machines yet? Would adding another chip even increase performance?
- nickphx 4y agoAfaik the storage devices are directly soldered to the 'logic' board and are unable to be replaced by the end user.
- PBondurant 4y agoThe SSDs in these machines consist of NAND chips soldered directly to the motherboard; the controller aspect is handled within the main M* SOC. As such there's no way that a company could offer an internal 'upgrade' or expansion to these drives.
- operatingthetan 4y agoI think I was getting the config of the Mac Studio confused with the MBP.
- metadat 4y agoI thought these are soldered together as well? Am I mistaken?
- operatingthetan 4y agohttps://everymac.com/systems/apple/mac-studio/mac-studio-faq/how-to-replace-upgrade-mac-studio-internal-ssd-storage.html https://everymac.com/systems/apple/mac-studio/mac-studio-faq...
- zitterbewegung 4y agoThis is not true . The SSDs on this are not soldiered but are in distinct chips that can be removed but none of them have a discrete controller on them instead the controller is on the SoC itself. Basically they are NAND modules not full SSDs at all.
- jzb 4y agoKind of expected more than a tweet with two screenshots and "more to come."
- barbazoo 4y agoLoved the "BREAKING: ..." as if we should all drop what we're doing and pay attention to "more to come".
- fsckboy 4y agowell, that is the definition of "breaking news", more is to come. You don't have to drop anything if the topic is not of interest to you, but if you're buying a laptop right now you might care. when dawn breaks, we have a whole day ahead of us.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoReally all we need is a chart with 4 or 5 scenarios and throughput/latencies for 90% of readers I think. I wish more blogger thought that way.
- skunkworker 4y agoMost likely from halving the number of SSD chips and no longer striping. Though to be honest in day to day use, I only notice SSD speeds when transferring/loading video files in the tens/hundreds+ of GBs. Otherwise, as long as the latency is low and the machine can load applications quickly from the disk, I never can perceive the difference. And with M1/M2 machines being able to start applications significantly quicker than my intel apple machines ever could, I'm not sure I could tell a perceivable difference in day-to-day use. But I am still disappointed that they are not using faster SSDs.
- lowbloodsugar 4y agoWell, I just tried that tool on my M1 Max and I got read speed of 2900MB/s. So I ran it again and finally put it in continuous mode: it did not keep an average and quartiles. I saw a read value over 4000MB/s. I would say that this tool is not a valid measure.
- thoughtsimple 4y agoThey should use AmorphousDiskMark. But I don't doubt the results in general. It looks like Apple has a hard time sourcing new 128 GB Nand chips.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thoughtsimple 4y agoSame as the M2 MacBook Air with 1 256 GB Nand chip. The 512 GB M2 Pro has 2 256 GB Nand instead of the previous 4 128 GB. Probably no big deal for most users.
- hot_gril 4y agoNo wonder I was having deja vu.
- _cenw 4y agoThese machines are still insanely fast. If you actually notice anything get substantially slower, you are either running very specialized workloads or you can forward the blame right to the developer of said application.
- hedgehog 4y agoIt seems pretty unlikely that many people have a workload that is highly sensitive to read throughput, has a disk footprint so small it fits on a 512GB SSD, and where the cost of slower disk outweighs a 20% faster CPU.
- hot_gril 4y agoIf I select 200 files and make a zip, that's probably an impacted workload.
- hedgehog 4y agoAs in 20% faster on the M2? At least for gzip defaults the per core throughput on my M1 is around 50MBps.
- hot_gril 4y agoAs in, possibly slower on the M2. Zipping a complex file tree can be disk-constrained, particularly if there are many small files.
- hedgehog 4y agoFor scale we're talking > 2TBps linear read and probably > 500MBps random 4k read in both cases, compared to on the order of 50-500MBps limit on the CPU side depending on threading etc. So still CPU limited. If there's any problem with big file trees it's probably macOS's relatively slow filesystem so again, advantage to the faster CPU. It sounds like LightRoom startup is a little slower but if you use it for editing you're going to get that back in faster workflow. In general modern NVMe has removed disk as a significant bottleneck for normal peoples' workflows, even on Mac. That includes backups, zipping up collections of files, git compaction, etc. What scenario are you imagining here?
- louwrentius 4y agoThis kind of "Breaking" news is creating drama where there isn't one. The 'slower' SSD is still pumping out gigabytes of data per second. Gigabytes! The real drama is that they focus on the wrong metric: they should focus on random IOPs and latency performance, throughput above certain thresholds is meaningless. I repeat, nobody is going to notice ever.
- bakugo 4y agoSomehow, I'm not surprised at all to see Apple users openly defending the fact that they get worse hardware when they buy the newer, more expensive model.
- postalrat 4y agoI am a bit surprised. Do they think they are getting points from apple to redeem for a lunch with steve jobs or something?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 7speter 4y agoIf apple allows their ssds to get any slower I’m afraid those off the shelf nvmes might start being the faster option…
- rowanG077 4y agoIs there any way to tell how many SSD lanes you have without opening up the device?
- worldsavior 4y agoWhat about the 256GB version?