3 ms·
1) Shouldn't companies and schools be unlocking/wiping these before donating? Is there any reason that won't work 99% of the time? 2) If Apple had a back door
by crazygringo 4y ago
1) Shouldn't companies and schools be unlocking/wiping these before donating? Is there any reason that won't work 99% of the time?
2) If Apple had a back door to unlock these, then is there a security/crime risk that could be abused by thieves, spies, hackers, etc.?
3) Even if locked, can't these be sold for parts? Lots of people need a replacement screen or whatever.
I don't have the answers to any of these questions, but the article doesn't even attempt to ask them.
- detaro 4y agoThe article addresses multiple of these...
- crazygringo 4y agoNo, the article doesn't address at all why schools/businesses aren't unlocking. It doesn't address any risks associating with Apple having the power to unlock. And the article disingenuously claims MacBooks are being sold for "scrap" (which implies merely recovering materials like aluminum) and the intro scarily talks about processes for a part which "ground them into carcinogenic dust". The article doesn't even mention selling for parts until halfway through, and it presents that in a negative light rather than examining why that might be a tradeoff that makes perfect sense, especially since parts availability helps enable third-party repair. (I myself have sometimes found I could get significantly more money selling something as separate parts on eBay rather than as a working whole, which means it's actually better because there's more demand.)
- flumpcakes 4y agoYour third point sounds like the most reasonable use of these machines. I assume that's what the recycling companies are doing but it wasn't explicitly stated in the article.
- detaro 4y ago... it clearly says that in the article.