3 ms·
Let’s complain about about water damage from firefighting when the other option is to let it burn. Lithium mining causes extremely localized harm, ICE engines
by Retric 4y ago
Let’s complain about about water damage from firefighting when the other option is to let it burn.
Lithium mining causes extremely localized harm, ICE engines cause worldwide damage.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoIf you'd read the article you'd see they're arguing for decreasing car dependence whilst simultaneoisly making all new cars BEV. How you can manage to construe that as a bad thing is baffling. To use your analogy it's like attacking someone who wants to stop the arsonist while the firefighters do their job instead of building a new water reservoir.
- Retric 4y agoThere are many many reasons to reduce our dependence on cars such as reducing particle emissions from tire and break wear, lithium mining is again hardly worth discussing. Lithium mining is ~4 orders of magnitude less harmful than ICE engines. Perhaps someone could have improved the situation by rearranging deck chars on the titanic into a more aesthetic pattern, but it’s not the kind of thing that deserved their attention.
- defrost 4y agoConsuming less is still by far the best approach, better city layouts and greater public transport, etc. As for the Lithium production figures: > Let us consider, for example, electric cars. To give an idea of this effect, producing a battery weighing 1,100 pounds emits over 70% more carbon dioxide than producing a conventional car in Germany, according to research by the automotive consultancy Berylls Strategy Advisors. https://phys.org/news/2023-01-paradox-lithium-net-zero-emissions.html https://phys.org/news/2023-01-paradox-lithium-net-zero-emiss... which to be sure isn't a full life cycle comparison .. but let's be very clear, the full G20 country demand for an electric future creates an unreasonably high demand on copper and rare earth mining and directly impacts all manner of marhinalised people - the US has a $64 billion copper reserve in Arizona on sites considered sacred by Native American tribes. https://resolutioncopper.com/ https://resolutioncopper.com/
- Retric 4y ago> better city layouts and greater public transport Those are useful for other things, if you want smaller batteries add in road charging. Just don’t wait for perfection when you can dramatically improve things today. > 70% more carbon dioxide than producing a conventional car in Germany Only today. Manufacturing currently produces carbon dioxide due to things like a fossil fueled electric grid not as an inherent part of the process. Fixing the grid is also required.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThere's no need to 'wait for perfection' to stop legislating bigger cars and higher car modeshare. We can push for sane streets and phase out ICEs at the same time.
- Retric 4y agoUpdating cities alone is not enough to remove the need for long range batteries. It’s also a really slow and expensive process.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoYou're doing that thing where you pretend one person needing something somewhere invalidates improving anything for anyone anywhere else. The reality is the only thing stopping most trips from being made in a light vehicle is the unchecked externalities from the large ones. And only one long range vehicle is 'needed' per household
- Retric 4y agoMost households don’t always take long trips to the same places especially when you’re talking long trips in terms of small EV batteries. I am all for improving cities, but just as a baseline not everyone lives in cities. Any long term plan needs to consider everyone not just people who live in dense enough areas public transportation is a clear win. Sure, ban cars in the center of cities, just don’t expect that to change how large most people want their car’s battery to be. This article and discussion is doing the thing where you exaggerate a small problem to promote something that’s almost but not quite entirely unrelated to it. If you want people to use small batteries in EV’s electrify roads so people can travel on them without using a battery. If you want to reduce the need for cars do that, but don’t pretend lithium mining somehow requires changing cities. Because arguing from a false premise weakens your argument when people see through it.
- fewavewavewa 4y agoI love it. Localise and externalise the harm! Just hope the poor souls who have to work in lithium extracing and refining are paid well.
- Retric 4y agoThe US could completely source all it’s lithium needs internally and still be vastly better off. It’s got the 5th largest proven reserve of any country, but that’s understating things as lithium is surprisingly abundant we just haven’t had much use for the stuff before lithium ion batteries. In terms of total harm, even people working lithium mines are better off if that eliminates ICE engines.
- defrost 4y agoGood News Central North Americans !! Australia has long been the major supplier of raw lithium concentrate [1] - sending it on to either China or Malaysia [2]. Soon we'll be shipping concentrate to Texas [3] [4] [5] so that the filthy dirty toxic work of heavy rare earths separation can take place as close to the greedy end consumers as possible. [1] https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20221110-how-australia-became-the-worlds-greatest-lithium-supplier https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20221110-how-australia-be... [2] https://lynasrareearths.com/ https://lynasrareearths.com/ [3] https://www.mining-technology.com/news/lynas-heavy-rare-earths-us/ https://www.mining-technology.com/news/lynas-heavy-rare-eart... [4] https://thetexan.news/rare-earths-processing-plant-to-open-on-texas-gulf-coast-funded-entirely-by-department-of-defense/ https://thetexan.news/rare-earths-processing-plant-to-open-o... [5] https://www.miningmagazine.com/supply-chain-management/news/1446083/musks-tesla-posts-wanted-ads-for-lithium-refinery https://www.miningmagazine.com/supply-chain-management/news/...
- MoreSEMI 4y agoI am not sure if you are opposed to the idea of localized damage. That is the best thing you can do as then one can control it far easier. It is much easier to test for emissions from on coal plant powering all the EVs on the road for example than the other scenario of testing each ICE vehicle. As to externalities, no one said that there shouldn’t be taxes or rules in place that make sure that the consumers of lithium don’t internalize the cost.
- lm28469 4y ago> A false dilemma, also referred to as false dichotomy or false binary, is an informal fallacy based on a premise that erroneously limits what options are available. The source of the fallacy lies not in an invalid form of inference but in a false premise. This premise has the form of a disjunctive claim: it asserts that one among a number of alternatives must be true. This disjunction is problematic because it oversimplifies the choice by excluding viable alternatives, presenting the viewer with only two absolute choices when in fact, there could be many.
- Retric 4y ago> A false equivalence or false equivalency is an informal fallacy in which an equivalence is drawn between two subjects based on flawed or false reasoning. This fallacy is categorized as a fallacy of inconsistency. Colloquially, a false equivalence is often called "comparing apples and oranges." ICE cars cause damage and lithium causes damage so the damage from lithium must also be significant. Mining the non lithium components of EV’s cause more environmental damage than mining the lithium does. Large infrastructure changes take time. You can of course also improve infrastructure, in road charging largely eliminates the need for giant EV batteries, but waiting is losing. If people want huge big batteries in EV’s then build them, you can always recycle lithium in a few decades it doesn’t get consumed.
- lm28469 4y agoAll I'm saying is that no one puts a gun to our head and forces us to have a future with personal cars in the way we have it now But if we start with this (OPs) false dilemma then yes of course, let's all buy a tesla, just don't pretend it'll save the world
- Retric 4y agoBuying EV’s is a huge improvement over not buying EV’s because they last for ~25 years. The size of their batteries is basically irrelevant in comparison. Sure, after we have electrified highways and improved cities they become more viable and could hopefully be the norm. But, in the short term the biggest impact of small batteries is convincing people EV’s suck. Especially when they don’t last for the full lifetime of a car.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]