4 ms·
Bayes Theorem for project managers (2010)
- MeteorMarc 4y agoPM says: yeah, this is for other projects, my project is different
- jiggawatts 4y agoReality: “Don’t worry, this is just a quick one-hour planning session, and the times are just estimates anyway.” …a month passes… “We need to have a conversation about why you’re falling behind on your deliverables. It’s too late to alter the deadline, it’s a hard date that has been circulated and accepted by all stakeholders!”
- barbazoo 4y agoUgh, I worked at places like that. Usually the more enterprisey ones are like that in my experience.
- darreninthenet 4y agoYou mean there are places not like that???? What have I been doing with my life
- apwheele 4y agoAt work, we have a team that is working on various agile dashboards for project metrics (acceleration or burndown or whatever, all the stuff I would guess the majority of folks commenting on Hacker News dislike). I've wondered if having structured input from various people + some training on making calibrated predictions (Hubbard's How to Measure Anything is a good resource relevant to project management), wouldn't be better. At least from a global perspective of "are we going to deliver on time".
- Buttons840 4y agoJust give everyone on the team access to an anonymous survey app of sorts. Let everyone on the team anonymously report the percentage of work they believe is completed. If you care about a deadline, let everyone anonymously report whether they believe the deadline will be met. Maybe weight the individual votes by how accurate they've been in the past. (To be clear, only those doing the actual work get a vote here.) Middle management will hate it, but perhaps upper management might find it helpful. Is this similar to what you are suggesting?
- apwheele 4y agoPretty much. Some things to ease the process are to make the questions asked specific as possible (no good if the question can be ambiguous sort of in the end), and to have feedback (plus initial training to help people understand to make calibrated predictions). Feedback is important, so people get better at guessing over time.
- bee_rider 4y agoFeed everybody’s estimates into a Kalman filter, haha.
- chrisfreder 4y agoGod I want this. Started to work on a project management app where I'll eventually add it. The book super forecasting really influenced my viewpoint on estimates of things and averaging these sorts of surveys are essentially the idea of the book.
- plasticchris 4y agoWhen I was young I would try to give confidence intervals for my estimates, and they would always be ignored.
- skirmish 4y agoMe too, that's how I learned to take my honest time estimate and always multiply it by \pi.
- kuhewa 4y agoWow is that a thing? I've learned from a supervisor to always * by 3 (they had been doing it to my estimates for a while without telling me) but I reckon the extra is a good idea
- blamestross 4y agoSame. If only project management tools took distributions as inputs.
- Jtsummers 4y agoMany can, and they can also run simulations based on those distributions. Many PMs don't know how to use these tools, choose not to, or answer to managers who want the answer and not a fuzzy answer.
- chrisfreder 4y agoI started building a project management tool where each task is given a "type" to auto generate distributions based on past projects / tasks. Having each task just be some block of text makes it hard to estimate distributions for each task. I'm not sure if this is futile though. Nobody likes hearing about uncertainty even if it is true. Schedule delays are a company culture problem and not a tech problem. Used to piss off my manager by giving ranges and uncertainty for most estimates. Then picked something closer to the 80th percentile timeline only to be told it was always too long of an estimate. Had to switch to giving the best possible time things would finish by because delays were easier to explain than accurate deadlines.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ggm 4y agoWhen everything is an estimate (nail) Then Bayes looks like the answer (Hammer)
- physicsguy 4y agoI can just imagine my PM’s reaction if I sent them this article