11 ms·
>I cannot get to data on 'my' system There is not a great way for a phone to know whose system it is. Possession of the device doesn't necessarily mean that it
by charcircuit 4y ago
>I cannot get to data on 'my' system
There is not a great way for a phone to know whose system it is. Possession of the device doesn't necessarily mean that it is theirs.
>But if I want to back them up, i.e. because steam blocks my account for 7 days if I change to a new device, I want an option to get them!
Do you not see the irony in this? If you make it possible to switch to a new device without the 7 day lock then an attacker can bypass it too.
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y agoThere needs to be some way to tell the device that the user is authorized, otherwise it can never do anything that could possibly be security sensitive - forget taking a backup; why should the 2FA app give you a one-time code if you could be an attacker? Edit: Thinking about it more, I suppose it all comes down to a cost/benefit analysis. It's true that taking a backup of 2FA secrets does give an attacker more than a single code. But when that trade is leveraged against the legitimate user being unable to control their own device, I think it's a terrible trade, to the point that I'm not convinced it's ever worth taking. And of course my real objection is that the user is rarely if ever actually asked; rather, a company tells the user that they can't control their own device, which is unacceptable.
- charcircuit 4y ago>why should the 2FA app give you a one-time code if you could be an attacker? Because the app aims to prove that someone has possession of the device. If someone has the key instead they can give back the device and generate codes later without possession. They can also resell the key online without having to ship a physical device. They can sell the same key to multiple people.