5 ms·
I've seen this play out at my university in two different ways. The more obvious way is very obvious: we had a professor who told us he'll be grading us by fir
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
I've seen this play out at my university in two different ways.
The more obvious way is very obvious: we had a professor who told us he'll be grading us by first tallying up the answers, and then applying a bell curve to the scores, so that X% of the students get an A, Y% get a B, etc., and some Z% of the students will fail. As you can imagine, everyone was up in arms about how obviously unfair this is.
The less obvious case, but close to what you describe, was scolarships. For almost every "track"[0], scolarships were awarded for top X% of students. In the "track" I was in, and another one in our faculty, the scolarships were instead given to anyone who crossed a certain absolute grade threshold, in (IIRC three) tiers. The higher the tier you reached, the more money you got, independent of how other students fared (probably subject to budget constraints, though).
Now, I can't prove it, but there was one other notable difference between our "track" and that other one with same scolarship model, and every other "track" at the university I was aware of: ours were famously cooperative, everyone else was fiercely competitive. I don't think it's a coincidence. My university experience was that of everyone helping each other out, because it was always a win-win both socially sometimes financially. Everywhere else, this was unthinkable - helping other students created a risk of them getting ahead of you and taking your scolarship.
I'm dismayed to see the same thing repeating in companies too.
--
[0] - I can't seem to find the correct word to describe the set of students across the years who pursue a degree in a particular subject (e.g. "Computer Science") on a specific faculty. I.e. the vertical slice.
- abdullahkhalids 4y ago'Batch' is the term commonly used for the set of students who start a program at the same time. For instance, the CS MS batch of 2023, who are expected to finish their MS in CS in 2023 (So they all should have stared in 2021 assuming a two-year program).
- oso2k 4y agoDo you mean cohort or class? MBA programs in the US will use those terms.
- urthor 4y agoThose are far more common.
- drblastoff 4y agoI heard “batch” used often in grad school by my non-American classmates, but “class” seems far more common in the U.S.
- radicalbyte 4y agoI've heard cohort, batch, class and year used for both primary, secondary and higher education.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI thought it was just "class", as in "CS class of 2023"? The term I'm looking for, though, is the set of batches abstracted over time. That is, all students who take CS at particular faculty of particular university, regardless of the year they started. A sequence of "batches". Such students will share curriculum and specific teaching staff. This is in contrast to another such group that e.g. does Applied CS at the same faculty, or Theoretical Physics at different faculty. EDIT: perhaps a picture is in order. Imagine an university tallying up how many students started a given class on a given year, per class, across entire university. They could create a spreadsheet that looks like: | University of Example | |----------+---------------+-----------------------+-----------------| | | Division of | Division of | Division of | | | Telecoms & EE | Robotics & Bio | Social sciences | |----------+-------+-------+-------+-------+-------+-------|---------| | Class of | Appld | Tele | Biomd | Appld | Auto | Social| ... | | ↓ | CS | comm | eng | CS | matics| media | ... | | 2022 | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ... | | 2021 | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ... | | 2020 | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ... | | 2019 | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ### | ... | | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | The term I'm looking for is the one you would use to call a single column of ### here - e.g. "all classes (years) of Applied CS in Division of Robotics and Bioinformatics".
- abdullahkhalids 4y agoI don't think there is one word for what you are referring to. But you could have said: > For almost every major, scholarships were awarded to the top X% of students of that major.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoThanks, that seems closest to what I meant, perhaps exactly so. Could you look at the diagram I edited in after you posted your reply, and tell me if "major" is the right term for this?
- oso2k 4y ago[0] - I can't seem to find the correct word to describe the set of students across the years who pursue a degree in a particular subject (e.g. "Computer Science") on a specific faculty. I.e. the vertical slice. Many in the US would call it the Department of Computer Science. At my university this was within the College of Engineering, Computer Science & Technology. There was a dozen or so departments in this college, Electrical Engineering, Mechanical Engineering, Civil Engineering, etc. There were other colleges like Arts & Letters, Health and Human Services, etc.
- joncrocks 4y agoI've seen cohort used in terms of tracking performance of a year group as it progressed through a program.
- erik_seaberg 4y agoIn study design, they might be called the treatment and control groups.
- dekleinewolf 4y agoI think you're looking for 'major'.
- Scea91 4y ago> The higher the tier you reached, the more money you got, independent of how other students fared (probably subject to budget constraints, though). It worked the same way at my University with the same outcome as yours. 7 years after graduation we still maintain regular contact as a group with my classmates.