3 ms·
Why not a smart missile rather than a nuke? Sites should only go completely dark for those users who appear to be geographically inside the district of SOPA-su
by gojomo 15y ago
Why not a smart missile rather than a nuke?
Sites should only go completely dark for those users who appear to be geographically inside the district of SOPA-supporting legislators. "Your legislator wants an censorship-without-trial kill-switch for internet sites, so we're on strike against your district today."
- DennisP 15y agoEven people outside the district can donate to opponents. There are also plenty of legislators who aren't committed yet, and it's probably even more important to pressure them.
- gojomo 15y agoOh, you show an interstitial to everyone. It's just milder for those in 'friendly' districts, medium-annoying when the legislator is uncommitted, and draconian when the legislator is pro-SOPA. And because of the large size of Senatorial districts (states) and how many Senators are PIPA supporters, plenty of people get the near-total blackout. The people who get, 'attaboys' for having better local legislators can still be directed to the nearest (or most vulnerable) problem legislators, or fundraising campaigns. I suspect the 'sting' of being in a bad district could motivate more emotion and action than just a blanket blackout. When people call their friends/relatives in other districts and find who does and doesn't have access, there could be more buzz. A worldwide blackout just annoys people overseas with silly American parochialism. A nationwide blackout educates, somewhat, but also could be seen as a sort of 'snow day', "ah, well, let's wait it out." Differential punishment serves to both agitate the relevant voters more – "why are we unable to access reddit when Suzy in Oregon can?" – and focus the emotion against specific actionable targets.
- eridius 15y agoThat's assuming the only reason for the blackout is to pressure users into calling their legislator. Blacking out the whole site worldwide is far more effective as a means of making a statement, and as a means of getting media attention.
- kevinh 15y agoIf someone can use a proxy to get to use the website, it harms the effectiveness of the measure.
- rplnt 15y agoAlso effectiveness of SOPA, doesn't it?
- danilocampos 15y agoBecause it's time to deploy a weapon of last resort. Big Content long ago declared Total War on the internet. Their bungling made this distasteful but initially limited its scope to courtrooms and extortionate settlements. But they've discovered their own nuke. They're going to do their best to drop it.