3 ms·
I want to believe this is somewhat accurate given the names dropped in this... tootstorm, but then the more I read it, the more alarm bells went off. The whole
by TeMPOraL 4y ago
I want to believe this is somewhat accurate given the names dropped in this... tootstorm, but then the more I read it, the more alarm bells went off. The whole thing reads like a tired, old "critique" of a strawman of a group one doesn't like, with a mix of hocus pocus nonsense on top.
The last two toots make for a particularly clear example:
> Chapman calls this "fluidity", and that's what today's infosec community seems to be in: an acceptance of the coexistence of both "nebulosity" (boundaries are fuzzy, nothing is ever cut and dried, there are no universal truths) and "pattern" (form and structure still exist, things can still be "more or less" X or Y in a certain context).
I mean... this "fluidity" is literally what the bayesian stuff is for. Probabilistic reasoning isn't in opposition to "fuzzy boundaries", it's a formalization of it. From this description, "fluidity" isn't something new or superior, it's just informal baby steps in the direction of what later became Bayesian modeling.
> the infosec community may be ahead of society at large in understanding change, nuance, and complexity. The world is filled with conflicts over boundaries and meanings.
Not if it rejects reason and starts buying into mathematical equivalent of homeopathy.
> Some want to impose rigid norms, definitions, and structures on everyone in a flailing attempt to restore certainty and order.
It's definitely not those evil rationalists, given how rationalist movement is all about handling uncertainty (with maths!), and insistence on "rigid norms, definitions and structures" is the first thing it makes you unlearn.
EDIT:
Disclaimer is in order, I suppose - I'm triply biased here, because: 1) I have positive feelings towards the LessWrong flavor of rationality movement as it was in its heyday, and its intellectual contributions; 2) I have negative feelings towards the infosec industry in general, and 3) some years ago I actually worked on an infosec product and tried to add some provably correct probabilistic reasoning capacity to it, and found it to be an uphill battle against corporate and infosec cultures.
- nyolfen 4y agoi agree that it's a bit up its own ass but chapman is definitely worth reading on his own, and his writing is in dialogue with contemporary rationalism; his audience is also mostly rat-adjacent (typically labeled or self-identified 'post-rationalist', which also sounds pretty up its own ass, but so does 'rationalism')
- dnissley 4y agoJust to give concrete recommendation re: bayesianism (one kind of what he calls probabilistic rationalism), it specifically might be worth dipping into his metarationality writings here: https://metarationality.com/probabilism-applicability https://metarationality.com/probabilism-applicability
- lofatdairy 4y agoTruth be told, I don't think I fully understand all of the language of the original post, being unfamiliar with the infosec community and not having time to read all the linked articles, but I do have a bit of familiarity with postmodern thought. That said, the post uses some strange vocabulary that probably has additional connotations in the space, so it's possible I'm talking in a completely different direction than OP. >I mean... this "fluidity" is literally what the bayesian stuff is for. Probabilistic reasoning isn't in opposition to "fuzzy boundaries", it's a formalization of it. From this description, "fluidity" isn't something new or superior, it's just informal baby steps in the direction of what later became Bayesian modeling. I might just note here, because I might be wrong, but I'm not sure this is the same thing. I believe OP is trying to describe a limitation with language and its assumption of static meaning. Consider, for instance, trying to model gender probabilistically - it doesn't quite work. If that's not to your taste, then how the distinction between the political left and right seems obvious in aggregate, but 1) transcends a fully comprehensive definition in practice, and even if you define it 2) people tend to not fall neatly into one category or another on every issue. Even political borders between states have a sort of fuzzy history. I recommend Peter Sahlins' Boundaries, which goes into the border between France and Spain, but I won't beleaguer that point. But basically trying to set probabilistic distinctions is somewhat like trying to measure a coastline - things become almost infinitely detailed the more you investigate it, and the map looks less and less like the territory. Even if you say, modeled political affiliation w/ a statistical model and simply assigned a confidence score to a predicted affiliation, what it seems that the post is claiming is that the Infosec community seems more willing to critique the underlying definitions of, say, "left" and "right". Obviously, you could counter and say that operationally these definitions work well enough, and in practice you'd most likely be right, but the willingness to recognize that definitions are not historically or socially static is probably what's being meant by "the infosec community may be ahead of society at large in understanding change, nuance, and complexity. The world is filled with conflicts over boundaries and meanings". I'm not going to go as far as to say there's a Sausseurian or Derridean conception of language here, but if that's the case then it's a different sort of uncertainty than probablistic as well. That said, I skimmed the linked "fluidity" post and really hated it. Maybe there's a coherent thought buried in the thesaurus soup but even then the self-aggrandizing tone puts me off.