5 ms·
KeenType: Pure Java typesetting system
- whartung 4y agoWhat a fascinating license. This is a particularly compelling line from it: 3. You must not distribute the modified file with the filename of the original file. Just in isolation, outside of the other aspects of the license, this is pretty much completely crippling for a Java program. Simply, if you change a file, you can't use the same name. Well, in Java, the name of the file is the name of the class. You can't have the file name differ from the class inside. That means you can't change a Java file in this codebase. Fascinating.
- ebruchez 4y agoAs a workaround, you could distribute the modified Foo.java as Foo2.java, and have your build system rename Foo2.java to Foo.java at build time. It might be all it takes (but IANAL).
- mqus 4y agoWHich would completely cripple IDEs or at the very least makes it difficult to work with
- KRAKRISMOTT 4y agoOr just use a shading tool (which comes by default with most Maven/Gradle builds). It is not a barrier for any experienced java developer.
- dcminter 4y agoHuh? Refactor the class name in virtually any Java supporting IDE and the file name and invocations will be changed along with it. The license term seems petty, and would be annoying, but the workaround is trivial.
- whartung 4y agoIf you do that, you have to rename every class file it impacts as well, because now those files are changed. A lot of refactoring systems don't take into account the ancillary files (like build files, start scripts, etc.). So, the workaround can be quite impactful in the end. Renaming the entirety of the code base, potentially.
- dcminter 4y agoOh, duh, now I get it. That's very annoying.
- layer8 4y agoIn principle, you could rename the classes on the class-file level after compilation, back to the original names. That wouldn’t violate the license. Moreover, under the following definition in the license: `Modification' of a file means any procedure that produces a derivative file under any applicable law -- that is, a file containing the original file or a significant portion of it, either verbatim or with modifications and/or translated into another language. …compilation would count as modification (“translated into another language”), and compilation also changes the file name (from .java to .class), so distributing the compilation output should be fine. Furthermore, any changes to the sources can be distributed as a diff patch, which also has a different file name.
- thangalin 4y ago> but the workaround is trivial. If you have a trivial solution to rename hundreds of Java classes and their references en masse without breaking the build and without renaming each file one-at-a-time, do tell. You can find more details about potential solutions I've tried here: https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75154524/bulk-rename-of-java-classes/ https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75154524/bulk-rename-of-... FYI, the following plug-in for IDEA supports regular expressions (as of Jan 20, 2023), so it may be a viable solution: https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/17455-rename-files-refactor-batch https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/17455-rename-files-refa...
- 4y ago
- bedatadriven 4y agoLooks like it was inherited from an upstream project that has a long history: https://github.com/jamespfennell/new-typesetting-system#license-and-changelog https://github.com/jamespfennell/new-typesetting-system#lice...
- thangalin 4y agoI've been looking high-and-low for a way to rename Java classes en masse without breaking the build. https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75154524/bulk-rename-of-java-classes/ https://stackoverflow.com/questions/75154524/bulk-rename-of-... A number of classes have been renamed to have the Kt prefix. There are other changes that don't yet have the new prefix applied because changing those classes would ripple into, essentially, the entire code base. Hence the search for a mass rename procedure that works. Suggestions welcome. Donald Knuth set that rule up so that "plain.tex" would be the same, world-wide. I don't know why the authors applied the same license to the entire Java application, rather than limit it to Knuth's work. I've also added a comment "// Originally" that indicates the original name of the class, rather than the name of the file. This minor license violation keeps its spirit if not its letter. Otherwise there'd be no way to extract an inner class.
- counttheforks 4y agoIf you're fine using intellij then you can probably use its scripting to do this. It has access to most of the same API as plugins and can access intellij features such as its refactor rename. The (meager) docs on scripting: https://www.jetbrains.com/help/idea/ide-scripting-console.html https://www.jetbrains.com/help/idea/ide-scripting-console.ht.... The plugin docs & intellij source code (especially the unit tests) are a better source of information. And here's a script that will use intellij's refactoring to rename all classes recursively in a directory to add the prefix Renamed, correctly dealing with references & renaming files if necessary: @file:Suppress("NAME_SHADOWING") import com.intellij.notification.Notification import com.intellij.notification.NotificationType import com.intellij.notification.Notifications import com.intellij.openapi.actionSystem.* import com.intellij.openapi.keymap.KeymapManager import com.intellij.openapi.command.WriteCommandAction import com.intellij.psi.* import com.intellij.psi.search.* import com.intellij.refactoring.rename.RenameProcessor import com.intellij.util.ThrowableConsumer import java.io.PrintWriter import java.io.StringWriter import javax.swing.KeyStroke // Usage: In IDEA: Tools -> IDE Scripting Console -> Kotlin // Ctrl+A, Ctrl+Enter to run the script // Select folder containing target classes, Ctrl+Shift+A to open action menu, search for Bulk refactor //<editor-fold desc="Boilerplate"> val b = bindings as Map<*, *> val IDE = b["IDE"] as com.intellij.ide.script.IDE fun registerAction( name: String, keyBind: String? = null, consumer: ThrowableConsumer<AnActionEvent, Throwable> ) { registerAction(name, keyBind, object : AnAction() { override fun actionPerformed(event: AnActionEvent) { try { consumer.consume(event); } catch (t: Throwable) { val sw = StringWriter() t.printStackTrace(PrintWriter(sw)) log("Exception in action $name: $t\n\n\n$sw", NotificationType.ERROR) throw t } } }); } fun registerAction(name: String, keyBind: String? = null, action: AnAction) { action.templatePresentation.text = name; action.templatePresentation.description = name; KeymapManager.getInstance().activeKeymap.removeAllActionShortcuts(name); ActionManager.getInstance().unregisterAction(name); ActionManager.getInstance().registerAction(name, action); if (keyBind != null) { KeymapManager.getInstance().activeKeymap.addShortcut( name, KeyboardShortcut(KeyStroke.getKeyStroke(keyBind), null) ); } } fun log(msg: String, notificationType: NotificationType = NotificationType.INFORMATION) { log("Scripted Action", msg, notificationType) } fun log( title: String, msg: String, notificationType: NotificationType = NotificationType.INFORMATION ) { Notifications.Bus.notify( Notification( "scriptedAction", title, msg, notificationType ) ) } //</editor-fold> registerAction("Bulk refactor") lambda@{ event -> val project = event.project ?: return@lambda; val psiElement = event.getData(LangDataKeys.PSI_ELEMENT) ?: return@lambda log("Bulk refactor for: $psiElement") WriteCommandAction.writeCommandAction(event.project).withGlobalUndo().run<Throwable> { psiElement.accept(object : PsiRecursiveElementWalkingVisitor() { override fun visitElement(element: PsiElement) { super.visitElement(element); if (element !is PsiClass) { return } if(element.name?.startsWith("Renamed") == false) { log("Renaming $element") // arg4 = isSearchInComments // arg5 = isSearchTextOccurrences val processor = object : RenameProcessor(project, element, "Renamed" + element.name, false, false) { override fun isPreviewUsages(usages: Array<out UsageInfo>): Boolean { return false } } processor.run() } } }) } } If your project is large this will temporarily freeze intellij since it doesn't properly run on the background thread but just give it a minute. By the way, this should work on all languages that IntelliJ has a language plugin for, not just Java. Edit: Modified script to override isPreviewUsages to prevent intellij from opening confirmation dialogs
- hbn 4y agoNow I want to make a fork, DumbKeenType, where the first thing I do is append "Dumb" to the beginning of every class/filename. https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/dumb-starbucks-and-the-art-of-the-hoax https://www.newyorker.com/tech/annals-of-technology/dumb-sta...
- brazzy 4y ago> in Java, the name of the file is the name of the class. You can't have the file name differ from the class inside. Actually, I'm fairly sure you can. You just need a custom classloader.
- brabel 4y agoClass files don't actually care about file names so ClassLoader has nothing to do with this. The OP problem is the source. The Java compiler won't compile a source file if none of the classes (and the only public one) in the file matches the name of the file.
- brazzy 4y ago> Class files don't actually care about file names But URLClassLoader does, which definitely has something to do with this. True, before you get there, you'd first need it to compile - but modern JDKs have a compiler API that allows customization via the StandardJavaFileManager interface, and that looks like it should be able to do the job to make source file names follow a different convention.
- rowls66 4y agoYes, commonly used ClassLoaders do care about file names and directories. The Java compiler javac does not. The javac compiler compiles compilation units which are generally files, but name does not matter.
- teraflop 4y agoNo, the file names of compilation units do matter to javac. To quote the Java Language Specification, section 7.6: > If and only if packages are stored in a file system (§7.2), the host system may choose to enforce the restriction that it is a compile-time error if a class or interface is not found in a file under a name composed of the class or interface name plus an extension (such as .java or .jav) if either of the following is true: > * The class or interface is referred to by code in other ordinary compilation units of the package in which the class or interface is declared. > * The class or interface is declared public (and therefore is potentially accessible from code in other packages). and javac does indeed enforce this restriction, at least for public classes. It's an error to declare a public class called Foo in a file that's called anything except Foo.java.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- svat 4y agoFor some history/context on what this is based on: • During 1977–78, Knuth wrote the first version of TeX (now called TeX78) in SAIL and gave a talk[1] about it. Everyone was excited, and lots of people at other universities/labs starting writing their own ports of TeX. • During 1980–82, Knuth set out to rewrite a “portable” TeX using Pascal, the most widely available language at that time (actually he wrote his own macros/wrapper on top of Pascal; the resulting language is called WEB). This (TeX82 aka TeX) is the program still in use today if you invoke "tex". (Continues to be updated once every few years, but basically stable.) • During 1998–2000, there was a Java rewrite of TeX called the New Typesetting System (NTS)[2], which had an alpha release and then was basically abandoned: it had all the problems of TeX and was several times slower, so it was regarded by many as a failure. Meanwhile extensions of TeX like pdfTeX came into existence, which are the programs most people use today. • The code still exists though, and I imagine people must have tried it on and off. But since I can't find any earlier record, I'll provisionally take credit for the idea of resurrecting/resurfacing it, when I tried it in 2017: [3] • Recently (in the last few months), Dave Jarvis (user `thangalin` here) has forked/modernized this Java implementation and is trying it out. (I noticed when he left his comment on my TeX.SE question; I guess his post https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/672614 https://tex.stackexchange.com/a/672614 on another question is what led to it being posted here.) I'm excited about this; looking forward to see how it gets used. (Apologies if this long comment potentially takes attention away from the current state and future possibilities, but felt like the history is useful context…) ———— I'll also add some history about the license, as I see another thread about it. When Knuth wrote TeX, it was to solve a specific problem he had encountered in publishing: the second edition of TAOCP Vol 2 was turning out worse in appearance than the first, because the publisher was moving from hot-metal typesetting (with Monotype machines) to phototypesetting, and could not achieve exactly the same appearance. While being bothered by this, Knuth discovered that digital typesetting machines were starting to come into existence: now it was just 0s and 1s, and as a programmer he felt he could handle it. That was his motivation for creating TeX and METAFONT: the appearance of each page would remain reproducible forever into the future. Except: when he publicized TeX and various clones sprung up, the situation was heading towards merely re-introducing the problem: if different computer systems had different programs all called “tex” that made even subtly different choices about line-breaking or whatever, then someone could write a paper/book on one computer, fine-tune the typesetting, then send the .tex file to their colleague / editor / publisher who used another computer, and no longer be confident that they would get the same result. This was one of the reasons he used the rewrite to create a portable TeX, going to great pains to use only a common subset of Pascal (Pascal had widely diverging compiler and language features), wrote a very demanding conformance test suite called the TRIP test[4] and insisted that any program would need to pass this test to be called "tex" — that way, everyone using "tex" could be sure they were writing something that would always produce the same result everywhere. If you wanted to make different choices in the program you could, as long as you changed the name. When he announced in 1990[5] that TeX would be stable (no more features), this is what he wrote: > My work on developing TeX, METAFONT, and Computer Modern has come to an end. I will make no further changes except to correct extremely serious bugs. I have put these systems into the public domain so that people everywhere can use the ideas freely if they wish. I have also spent thousands of hours trying to ensure that the systems produce essentially identical results on all computers. […] > […] anybody can make use of my programs in whatever way they wish, as long as they do not use the names TeX, METAFONT, or Computer Modern. In particular, any person or group who wants to produce a program superior to mine is free to do so. However, nobody is allowed to call a system TeX or METAFONT unless that system conforms 100% to my own programs […] > I welcome continued research that will lead to alternative systems that can typeset documents better than TeX is able to do. But the authors of such systems must think of another name. That is all I ask, after devoting a substantial portion of my life to the creation of these systems and making them available to everybody in the world. I sincerely hope that the members of TUG will help me to enforce these wishes… etc. And NTS derives a similar licence, and this project (being forked from NTS) simply carries over the license. Of course such a license is unusual today, and thousands of pages' worth of ink have been spilled over whether or not this counts as “free software” (predating GPL / MIT license etc), and (finally) grudgingly accepted to be. You can read about the history of the LaTeX project's similar license (LPPL) and all the debates on Debian/FSF mailing lists etc if you're morbidly interested[6]; the discussion usually proceeds on similar lines and I hope it doesn't get repeated here. :-) [1]: Gibbs lecture, “Mathematical Typography”: https://doi.org/10.1090/S0273-0979-1979-14598-1 https://doi.org/10.1090/S0273-0979-1979-14598-1 [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=New_Typesetting_System&oldid=1088610456 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=New_Typesetting_S... [3]: https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/385645/is-nts-new-typesetting-system-the-java-implementation-of-tex-usable-today https://tex.stackexchange.com/questions/385645/is-nts-new-ty... [4]: http://mirrors.ctan.org/info/knuth-pdf/tex/tripman.pdf http://mirrors.ctan.org/info/knuth-pdf/tex/tripman.pdf [5]: https://www.tug.org/TUGboat/tb11-4/tb30knut.pdf https://www.tug.org/TUGboat/tb11-4/tb30knut.pdf [6]: https://www.tug.org/TUGboat/tb32-1/tb100mitt.pdf https://www.tug.org/TUGboat/tb32-1/tb100mitt.pdf
- PeterCorless 4y agoHello. Old Compugraphic 8400 typesetting operator here [welcome to the 1980s]. Also old hand at PageMaker and Quark Xpress. If it doesn't support kerning, it's not really a typesetting system. I would call this a "mathematical formula editor" but not a "typesetting system." To be more conformant to my expectations for a typesetting system, I'd suggest to add more information to the docs so you can understand how to specify things like font face, font size, horizontal and vertical element positioning and line spacing, etc.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- TeaVMFan 4y agoIt would be interesting to build this with TeaVM to allow high-quality typesetting for online papers and interactive web content. TeaVM transpiles Java to JavaScript. I used it to convert a Java interactive fiction project to run natively in the browser: https://frequal.com/java/RestoringA19YearOldGameWithTeaVm.html https://frequal.com/java/RestoringA19YearOldGameWithTeaVm.ht... More background on TeaVM: https://teavm.org/ https://teavm.org/ https://blogs.oracle.com/javamagazine/post/java-in-the-browser-with-teavm https://blogs.oracle.com/javamagazine/post/java-in-the-brows...
- tenaf0 4y agoThere is also Google’s closure compiler that can compile java to js.