3 ms·
Torture is literally worse then nothing, because you've wiped away the ability to engage in meaningful interrogation in the time you have Then I'll add a furth
by CamperBob2 4y ago
Torture is literally worse then nothing, because you've wiped away the ability to engage in meaningful interrogation in the time you have
Then I'll add a further complication to the scenario: all of those avenues have been exhausted. E.g., the torturer is a low-level cop, hired for his loyalty, bravery, and modest IQ. He is not a "good cop" at all, so the only tool he has is the proverbial $5 wrench. An interesting question is, having used the tool, what should happen to the cop if it succeeds?
They absolutely tortured that guy, but he had already disclosed the intelligence they needed before they did any of it.
I think I was pretty clear that I was condemning that. Right there with you. But I don't agree that there are no conceivable circumstances in which torture or mass surveillance is appropriate. They just don't arise very often. I wouldn't be surprised if they never have, outside of a Batman movie or Tom Clancy novel.
As for torture always being ineffective, terrorists often fail to live up to their stated ideals. Someone who plants a bomb may see it as a painless, instantaneous ticket to Paradise, but the chair he's tied to doesn't look much like a holy stargate or whatever, and the upset cop standing there with a wrench doesn't look like a virgin. It's unrealistic to assume that the cop's chance of success is 0%.
- autoexec 4y ago> It's unrealistic to assume that the cop's chance of success is 0%. It's realistic to assume that they'd have better odds of getting what they want by putting down the wrench and trying something other than torture : https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/slightly-blighty/201701/does-torture-work https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/slightly-blighty/201... https://nationalinterest.org/feature/the-ticking-bomb-dilemma-how-effective-torture-11950 https://nationalinterest.org/feature/the-ticking-bomb-dilemm...
- CamperBob2 4y agoAgain: this particular cop doesn't read Psychology Today.