7 ms·
What I don't understand is how e.g. Disney+ is losing so much money. It's Disney's content, has an enormous userbase, and somehow is bleeding billions?
by zamadatix 4y ago
What I don't understand is how e.g. Disney+ is losing so much money. It's Disney's content, has an enormous userbase, and somehow is bleeding billions?
- bcrosby95 4y agoIt's extremely cheap.
- no_wizard 4y agoMarketing. I also suspect that alot of Disney's most core userbase don't make up enough volume to make this profitable. I consider myself an ardent Star Wars & Marvel fan and I just couldn't keep up anymore, so I axed Disney+. Netflix still drops enough documentaries that I keep it around.
- chongli 4y agoYeah I think there’s a big Marvel and Star Wars fatigue factor that isn’t talked about enough. Only the hardest of the hardcore fans can keep up with all that stuff. Regular people and casual fans pretty much only see the big blockbuster movies and maybe watch the Mandalorian to see what all the baby Yoda memes are all about.
- darth_avocado 4y ago> It’s Disney’s content That is partly the problem. You spend hundreds of millions to make blockbuster movies and then release it on Disney+ in a few months for free (or sometimes directly). That costs money. Add to that over reliance on only Disney content creates two problems: 1. You can’t have enough new content every month, subscribers therefore don’t keep the subscription year round. 2. You have to pay money to create content. Vs the ability to buy content for cheap or add it for a few months. On top of that, Disney overseas also includes live sports in their packages which can get expensive.
- ghaff 4y ago>You can’t have enough new content every month, subscribers therefore don’t keep the subscription year round. I suspect that, in addition to ad-supported tiers, we'll see more annual subscriptions or at least subscriptions where annual is sufficiently cheaper on a monthly basis that it's essentially an offer a lot of people can't refuse.
- smachiz 4y agoalong with maybe a broader return to serialization and longer seasons again - but this only really is valuable for shows that capture the zeitgeist, otherwise most people will just wait until the season ends and subscribe for a month to binge and move on.
- lastofthemojito 4y ago> I suspect that, in addition to ad-supported tiers, we'll see more annual subscriptions or at least subscriptions where annual is sufficiently cheaper on a monthly basis that it's essentially an offer a lot of people can't refuse. I think they're already experimenting with things like that. I signed up for an annual subscription when Disney+ launched (I knew my wife and kid would love it) and when it came time to renew they offered a "Disney Drop Box" as a reward for signing up for another year. The box was a themed selection of Disney merchandise that they claimed was valued at ~$150, which is probably a stretch, but my kid loved it.
- ska 4y agoIsn't this basically what amazon does via prime membership? Apples and oranges I guess because it isn't "just" streaming, but does anyone pay this monthly?
- madeofpalk 4y agoOn top of the... 'opportunity cost' of not licensing out content that otherwise would have went to Netflix, ABC, whoever. If previously Disney made Daredevil and 'sold' it to Netflix for $1m (hypothetically), but now you're holding that back to stream yourself, you've got to account for that missing $1m somehow.
- phphphphp 4y agoContent is expensive to produce. Disney+ is not just a streaming platform for existing Disney content, rather, Disney produce content for it. Likewise, Netflix spends most of its money on content, operating the actual platform is comparatively cheap.
- tootie 4y agoYeah, D+ is churning out an enormous volume of what would be considered prestige content at other services. All the Star Wars and Marvel shows are star-studded and larded with top-tier visual effects. And some of them aren't really getting a lot of viewers from what the rumors say.
- thedrbrian 4y ago>All the Star Wars and Marvel shows are star-studded and larded with top-tier visual effects. I'm just going to throw this out there. What if these shows just aren't that good?
- vnchr 4y agoI’d say it’s a mixed track record, and that risk of disappointment is enough to deter customets from content they might actually like.
- JackFr 4y agoAlso if you’re not into superheroes and Star Wars, despite it being Disney there’s not a ton there.
- saghm 4y agoEven if you are, there's the chance that the glut of the content coming out causes fatigue. I used to really look forward to new Star Wars things because it didn't come out super frequently (a new trilogy of movies every few decades, a TV show here and there), but it was enjoyable. Then they started coming out with a new movie and multiple TV shows year after year, and it just wasn't good enough to justify going out of my way to consume all of it. Marvel stuff seems the same way; I'd generally go to the movies maybe once or twice a year, so when there are half a dozen of them coming out for a single franchise within a year or two, it feels more like work than entertainment to keep up with it all. At this point, I'm not sure I'll _ever_ go to see a Star Wars movie in a theater again, which is extraordinary since even 5 or 6 years ago that would have seemed ludicrous to me.
- cjrp 4y agoIs it possible that Disney (Walt Disney Co) makes more money by providing its content via Disney+ rather than in theatres/via other streaming platforms? So while Disney+ itself might be losing money, Disney as a whole is benefiting.
- theptip 4y agoI don't know any detail on Disney's debt, but worth noting that a lot of "Disney's content" is stuff they just bought. E.g. they bought ESPN, the Marvel Cinematic Universe, etc. These are massive multi-billion purchases. Breaking even on the content purchases is hard work.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paxys 4y agoDisney's content library only appeals to very specific demographics. Mostly just kids and the Avengers/Star Wars crowd. Netflix has something for literally everyone.
- voisin 4y ago> Netflix has something [mediocre, that will be cancelled after the first season] for literally everyone. FTFY.
- subradios 4y agoA lot of the Netflix one or two season shows got cancelled when they were finally finding their legs too.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoI don't know if it's the same in the states, but here in Canada we get Stars with it as well, which is a huge bunch of Fox stuff, including It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia and American Horror Story, so it's a little more varied than you're making it out to be.
- adam_arthur 4y agoDisney has a lot of adult content as well (via subsidiaries), but as far as I know they have pushed most of this to Hulu. But yes, as a guy in his 30s, Disney+ provides nothing compelling to me. I do pay for Hulu though
- idontpost 4y ago[dead]
- pclmulqdq 4y agoI think you underestimate how much they hand out Disney+. For example, Verizon has a deal with Disney to give out free Disney+ with many plans. Comcast, I think, was also offering me free Disney+ access. This must eat into margins on some level while keeping the subscriber number up - there's no way that Verizon/Comcast are paying full price for that free subscription (in most cases, it's only a year free). Contrast that with HBO Max that has never had a sale of any kind except for a single free trial week. I also think that people underestimate the cost of serving streaming entertainment. It's very compute- and data-intensive. If you architect your systems badly, which I assume Disney did, you will be paying a LOT of money for this service.
- gratitoad 4y agoFWIW I used to get HBO Max free with my AT&T phone plan, so they have at one point given it “for free.” And I think you could be right about D+ architecture, they went from zero to a streaming service very quickly.
- Tommah 4y ago> they went from zero to a streaming service very quickly Disney basically bought MLB's streaming service and used that for Disney Plus.
- sharkjacobs 4y agoDisney+ doesn't just get all its content "for free" even though Disney owns it all. A company as big as Disney has to be able to look at its different subsidiaries and analyse how they're performing individually. So maybe Walt Disney Animation Studio spends money making movies and earns money selling the rights to those movies, and so Disney+ gets exclusive access to streaming rights, but it still has to pay for them.
- MisterBastahrd 4y agoI can watch Disney shows for a month, cancel for 4 months, and then come back and maybe have enough content for another month. We're talking one or two movies and a TV show. It's simply not enough. Disney+ is also a very specific fan-oriented service. Don't like Star Wars or comic books? Not a child? Good luck finding something worth watching that isn't a documentary.
- Fuzzwah 4y agoI have a pet theory, many families use D+ as a second streaming service mostly for the family content. Because of this there's no real concern about "profile contamination". So multiple profiles aren't needed for individuals who live in the same household. The profiles end up being used to share the account with other households. A grandparents single account is used in the households of all their grandchildren.
- baby 4y ago> It's Disney's content I have a feeling it might be that they don't have enough established TV shows. But this is the problem of pretty much everyone but Netflix, and this will most likely change in the next 2-3 years.
- LatteLazy 4y agoRemember that profit is basically just a made up number in accounting. The "profit" or "loss" made by one business unit within a group even more so.