4 ms·
Has anyone ever used phone apps that purport to wake you up at the right time by using the accelerometer to detect how much you're moving in your sleep? Exampl
by danso 15y ago
Has anyone ever used phone apps that purport to wake you up at the right time by using the accelerometer to detect how much you're moving in your sleep?
Example: http://www.sleepcycle.com/ http://www.sleepcycle.com/
I've used this but only for a few times because it requires the phone to be activated all night, which makes it quite warm in the morning. But it seemed to make me less groggy...but I can't tell if that's just confirmation bias...
I haven't thought of using it for just 45 min spans though
- cburgas 15y agoI'm using it for nearly a year now. Its really nice if the app can wake you up while you are in light sleep but sometimes you are just not in that phase during the 30min period the app tries to wake you in. So worst case is that you wake up the same way you would with a normal alarm clock, but on the other days its pretty neat. But the 30% battery charge I lose overnight is sometimes a hassle because my phone is either near the 30% right before I want to go to bed or I know that I have no time to charge it in the morning... and I refuse to charge the phone while its laying next to me :)
- gwern 15y agoOne of the nifty things about the Zeo is that when it does that (the 'SmartWake' feature), it probably won't be mistaken because it's not going on your movements but more your EEG.
- lazerwalker 15y agoI tried using a Wakemate (a dedicated bluetooth wristband that talks to a companion iPhone app) and found it to be pretty close to useless for me -- I move around quite a lot when I sleep, and I found it was consistently waking me up within a minute of the start of the wake period. That doesn't mean that stuff like this isn't useful for normal people who don't flail around like an animal when they sleep, but an anecdote is an anecdote. I'd also imagine a more sophisticated piece of software might be able to learn your sleep pattern and adjust the sensitivity (i.e. calibrate the threshold based on how much you personally move when you sleep, rather than the hypothetical average person). (in Wakemate's defense, they have an awesome no-questions-asked 30-day return policy, so I was happily able to return it and get my money back when I wasn't satisfied. They were a true pleasure to deal with.)
- darkstar999 15y agoI used sleep cycle with success last summer, but I'm not sure how well it would work with a second person in the bed. Wouldn't their movement throw off the timer?
- Schwolop 15y agoYes, they most certainly do throw off the timer. This was the main reason I stopped using sleepcycle. A wrist-strap certainly seems like a better option.