4 ms·
"The issue of recommendations arises in this case because the complaint alleges the defendants were recommending ISIS terrorist recruiting videos, which under c
by layer8 4y ago
"The issue of recommendations arises in this case because the complaint alleges the defendants were recommending ISIS terrorist recruiting videos, which under certain circumstances could give rise to liability under the Anti-Terrorist Act,"
It seems to me there is an issue with the notion of “recommendation” here. There needs to be a difference between an intent to promote specific content, vs. a content-agnostic algorithm that just lists what “other users who liked what you liked also liked”. If (say) some Reddit moderators promote terrorist content, they should certainly be liable (or the editorial rules that require them to do so, if any). But when Reddit or YouTube shows you stuff based purely on statistical correlations of what you and other users viewed/liked in the past, then that mechanism in itself shouldn’t be an issue.
- tjr225 4y ago[dead]
- zwkrt 4y agoThis doesn’t make any sense at all to me. If the video itself is a problem, it shouldn’t matter if it was recommended by a human with human intents or by an algorithm designed with capitalistic intent. It would be hard to convince me that the intent of the system that recommended the video should be heavily considered. At least in the US we have a highly consequentialist legal system.
- layer8 4y agoIMO the question of whether some content should be allowed to be available at all is orthogonal to the question of liability for “recommending”. I was only addressing the latter.