3 ms·
I feel you are making a valid point here, but I have to demur where you say “…just as language models can do.” Current LLMs do not appear to have any concept of
by mannykannot 4y ago
I feel you are making a valid point here, but I have to demur where you say “…just as language models can do.” Current LLMs do not appear to have any concept of self, let alone a theory of mind - the notion that other people think of themselves the same way as one thinks about oneself (in fact, they don’t appear to have have any concept of language as being about an external world that exists independently of what is said about it.)
An LLM can sometimes be prompted to give a response that looks like an explanation for how it came up with a previous response, but it is important to realize that the actual process by which it came to make the original response bears no relationship to the “explanation” it gave. Because everyone's experience with language has been with human-generated language, which is often not completely rational but, when it is not, often deviates in ways we intuitively understand, it is difficult to see the responses of current LLMs as being fundamentally different, even when we know they are.
- mansoon 4y agoYour intuitive understanding is an illusion.