3 ms·
> laws that cannot be enforced in practice are bad laws; Who said they couldn't be enforced? The argument from the pro-AI team is that we shouldn't have those
by lelanthran 4y ago
> laws that cannot be enforced in practice are bad laws;
Who said they couldn't be enforced? The argument from the pro-AI team is that we shouldn't have those laws in the first place.
I'm saying, let's keep the laws we already have because they already work quite nicely if the content creators don't want their work included in any training data set.
Rushing to make new laws because "Muh AI" is silly.
- kragen 4y agoprobably before rushing to categorize people into teams and ridicule those you think are on a different team from you, it would serve you well to understand the basic principles of the field you are commenting on so that you are in a position to assess the factual claims people are advancing if you are failing to understand the factual claims, you have no hope of making sense of the normative claims for which you have such thirst
- lelanthran 4y agoI'm not on a team, but the notion from the pro AI people that licensors cannot add restrictions on their material is, frankly, childish in its logic. Almost all big companies routinely have licenses which heavily restrict how their software may be used, and the licenses have held up time and time again in various jurisdictions around the world. The only argument you appear to be presenting is "well and don't like it that way". Tough. It's already that way and has been so for dozens of decades .