2 ms·
The great gas stove debate has been reignited
- dsq 4y agoEuropeans have more gas stoves per capita than in North America. Are Europeans more brain danaged than North Americans, on average?
- eesmith 4y agoThe main health issue is childhood asthma, not brain damage. I wasn't able to find mentions of any correlation between gas stove use and brain damage - could you provide a pointer? From what I could tell, childhood asthma statistics in Europe are very hard to compare as there are big differences in diagnostics. In addition to burning producing nitrogen oxides, carbon monoxide, formaldehyde, and microparticulates at home, there are environmental concerns as the production and distribution also leaks methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
- dsq 4y agoSure: https://slate.com/technology/2022/10/gas-stoves-brain-development-air-quality.html https://slate.com/technology/2022/10/gas-stoves-brain-develo... So the claim exists, the question is whether it’s true, especially given that many advanced nations use them.
- eesmith 4y agoYou linked me to an article written by a neuroscientist who is curious if there is an effect, so finds "only two studies [which] empirically weigh in on this question, both conducted by the same group in Spain". The first shows barely any effect, the second a slight negative effect. "To put it in perspective, having smokers in the household, or lead in pipes, would be far more damaging. ... “Lifestyle behaviors or genetic factors probably have a much larger impact on specific groups of people”." The author later writes "I’m more compelled by the studies linking gas stoves to asthma and respiratory problems, but even this literature isn’t a slam dunk." There's also this comment from the second paper, which the Slate author didn't mention: ] It is still possible that the associations we found in this study with nitrogen dioxide could be attributable to unmeasured indoor air contaminants, such as particulates derived from gas appliances. This is supported by the fact that, in Menorca, the principal source of gas appliances is butane bottles, a fuel more toxic than natural gas (36) This makes it hard to compare butane cooking use in Spain with, say, natural gas cooking use in the US. Further, they didn't conclude that there was brain damage. They found a correlation with "cognitive functioning and inattention-hyperactivity symptoms in preschoolers" and conjectured it was due to nitrogen dioxide exposure causing brain cell damage, so saying "brain damage" is going beyond the evidence. To answer your question, the resources you pointed to suggest 1) that the amount of brain damage is small and not well established, 2) that other factors play a much larger role in comparing brain damage between North American and European countries (eg, lead), and 3) that the link between gas burning and asthma and respiratory problems is a much more relevant topic to focus on.
- dsq 4y agoFirstly, thanks for the detailed answer. The article we are tesponding to itself has the text: “the stoves have also been linked to a slew of other health conditions from cardiovascular to cognitive issues”. Since the authors themselves raised the possibility, I saw it reasonable to suggest comparing European with American cognition. I also find it intuitively unlikely that it has any cognitive effect.
- eesmith 4y agoI totally missed that! I was looking for "brain" and "damage", and overlooked the phrase "cognitive issues" and its link. BTW, I went back to the article where I first read about this (a Mother Jones piece linked-to from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28402439 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28402439) and didn't see mention of "brain" or "cogn*" in the piece. I've read a couple other articles on the topic since then and don't recall seeing this specific point, but as you've shown, I could have overlooked those too!
- yyyk 4y agoContra common stereotype, as far as air pollution is concerned, Europeans are much less 'green' than the US - see dieselgate and diesel use in general.
- DemocracyFTW2 4y agoA rather sober and balanced discussion of that by Adam Ragusea: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNwcWe85Wnc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KNwcWe85Wnc
- photochemsyn 4y agoNitrogen oxide & dioxide (NOx) air pollution is certainly a problem, but in terms of policy and impact, diesel-burning engines are probably the greatest immediate problem. Fundamentally, the issue is that the atmosphere is 80% N2 and when combustion takes place at high pressure and/or high temperature, some fraction of that N2 gets converted to NOx species. Gas burns at a high enough temperature to drive this process, and internal combustion engines (especially higher-pressure diesel engines) do the same. Using gas-powered stoves and heaters can certainly increase indoor levels of NOx without a good ventilation and exhaust system. Poorly adjusted gas burners of all kinds can also generate carbon monoxide, CO, due to incomplete combustion, which kills about 400 people a year in the USA and accounts for 100K hospital visits (CDC). However, diesel (and older gasoline) engines generate an additional list of air pollutants that greatly increase asthma and other respiratory ailments: ozone and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), which undergo further reactions with NOx in the atmosphere to form things like PAN (peroxyacyl nitrates). This toxic cocktail makes up much of the smog that hovers over so many regions, and it definitely is a major cause of childhood asthma, certainly more so than indoor gas stoves. Hence in terms of regulatory approaches, replacing all diesel vehicles with electric ones would have a greater impact on childhood asthma than something like a ban on gas stoves would. Ensuring homes with gas appliances have good exhaust and ventilation would make more immediate sense. (2018) Diesel, children and respiratory disease https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5976105/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5976105/
- eesmith 4y ago> Ensuring homes with gas appliances have good exhaust and ventilation would make more immediate sense. Quoting a Mother Jones piece from last year, at https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2021/06/how-the-fossil-fuel-industry-convinced-americans-to-love-gas-stoves/ https://www.motherjones.com/environment/2021/06/how-the-foss... : ] The gas industry claims that proper ventilation can take care of any combustion fumes. Yet even among families who are aware of the potential health effects, many cannot afford to install a sufficiently powerful hood vent, and there’s certainly no regulation requiring it. Indeed, most stove fans do little more than move the polluted air about. Because of dated building codes and an unregulated market, low-income Americans, many of whom are renters, have to put up with invisible combustion byproducts in cramped living spaces. So it comes down to, who will pay for it? And who will face what penalties for not following those requirements? > than something like a ban on gas stoves would The proposed bans concern bans on gas hookups for new housing, which seems relatively inexpensive and doesn't require the infrastructure changes of changing all diesel (and older gasoline) engines to battery. It's also easier to tell the builder they cannot get gas hookups than to shut of gas to a house which doesn't have the wiring to switch to electric stoves and heat. > Poorly adjusted gas burners of ... kills about 400 people a year in the USA and accounts for 100K hospital visits. The CDC numbers I found give stronger support for reducing petroleum engines than for improving exhaust. Over half of those 400 accidental deaths due to CO poisoning come from automobile engines, and another quarter come from generators and engine-based tools. Less than a quarter (I couldn't find an accurate breakdown) come from poor ventilation of gas-powered stoves and heaters. The CDC numbers I found were for 50K hospital visits, and I didn't find a breakdown for how many come specifically from poor home ventilation. There certainly are some, and I support the proposal that HUD needs the funding to provide and maintain CO detectors for HUD subsidized housing, which would help. But I think the push for decreasing the number of gas stoves can be done on a different timescale, and in parallel, to the the push for decreasing the number of gas and diesel vehicles. And I think both can be placed primarily under the umbrella of reducing NOx exposure.
- nikau 4y agoUntil physical dials are the norm for induction gas is superior.
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoThere are lots of induction ranges these days with physical dials. I have a portable induction range with button settings and it's definitely the worst part of the experience for me.