4 ms·
...when you measure things like life expectancy, Britons are as healthy as Americans. That gives you an idea of how much money is going down the tubes due to ad
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
...when you measure things like life expectancy, Britons are as healthy as Americans. That gives you an idea of how much money is going down the tubes due to administrative inefficiency.
It's hardly clear the money is going down the tubes due to administrative inefficiency. It might just be spent on unnecessary medicine, and costs might be higher in the US.
According to one fairly decent source, administrative inefficiency is a pretty minor contributor - the biggest contributor is outpatient care.
http://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/what-makes-the-us-health-care-system-so-expensive-%E2%80%93-conclusion/ http://theincidentaleconomist.com/wordpress/what-makes-the-u...
- llimllib 15y agoI'm also certain that much of the unnecessary medicine is provided because of the legal climate in the US; doctors practice under the assumption that they will be sued if they don't provide unnecessary medicine.
- jbooth 15y agoAlso, if you pay a bajillion dollars for an MRI machine, then you amortize the cost over the number of times it's used. The times you use it, it's just the cost of electricity. So there's an incentive to use it a lot. That still doesn't explain being charged several thousand for an x-ray, though. That's 150 year old technology, this isn't like Dr. House and a team of neurosurgeons at work here.
- llimllib 15y ago> That still doesn't explain being charged several thousand for an x-ray, though If you want to try and understand this stuff, you have to abandon the idea of the charged cost of a procedure relating to how much it cost to provide. It's truly depressing. This econtalk podcast does a good job diving into the nightmare of non-prices in the medical system: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2008/12/lipstein_on_hos.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2008/12/lipstein_on_hos.htm...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jbooth 15y agoA couple things, first off, if costs are higher in the US, they shouldn't be, we're not living in a radically different reality in the UK. Market forces should be lowering those costs, but they're not, because the actual cost centers are completely insulated from any market whatsoever by the insurance system. RE: administrative inefficiency, from my limited experience (laying off teachers in local gov't back in 2004 because healthcare premiums were going up by 15-18% a year), the administrative overhead in actually managing the insurance is pretty small as a % of the costs paid to hospitals. But then you step back and think, well what the hell, why are the costs paid to the hospitals so high? Because the whole system's broken. So if you try to measure administrative overhead, it looks small, but the general administrative system is creating this environment where the costs themselves are through the roof. Some is unnecessary medicine, a lot seems to be the completely arbitrary price structure. In the linked article, one hospital charged 6 bucks for a treatment, another charged several thousand. That's not a market.
- fauldsh 15y agoOne of the reasons it costs less in the UK is because the NHS bargains the costs of drugs (and machinery etc) it buys down. This works partially because they can and do refuse to buy the drugs deemed too expensive. I don't have any statistics to back this up, but because the US system ends up spending as much as the pharmaceutical companies can possibly charge meaning they pay more for the same drugs. Somewhat of a perpetuating system, as the US pays more the pharmaceutical companies can handle the NHS bargaining the prices down some more. It's vaguely analogous to how the lesser paying medicare is subsidized by private insurance.
- wisty 15y agoNote the theory of second best - 2 monopolies (i.e. a union and the owner of a company town; or a health service and the monopoly owner of a patented drug) can negotiate a better and fairer deal than 1 monopoly and a fragmented party. 2 fragmented parties is best (in theory), but that doesn't always happen. But most economists don't learn this in school. They just learn "monopoly = bad, government = monopoly".
- 15y ago
- tankenmate 15y agoYou could argue that the reason outpatient care is so high in the US is because people who can't afford, insurance or otherwise, for "normal" care only go to the hospital when their condition becomes acute and emergency departments that can't turn away people have to treat them. You could probably argue that in this case acute treatment cost is higher because the primary condition has been left untreated for so long ; xref the stories of poor children dying from tooth abscesses, something that could normally be treated with $15 worth of antibiotics and $25 worth of dental work; tooth pulled, hardly aesthetic but it works. That $40 of timely intervention is probably hundreds cheaper than a child presenting to emergency with septicemia.
- jellicle 15y agoWell, yeah, if you ignore all the studies and only read libertarian blogs, then it's hardly clear. Administration accounts for 31% of healthcare costs in the U.S., and 16% in Canada, for example.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThe views of the bloggers at the incidental economist tend to be moderate liberal. Seriously, go read the blog, and find me a single post indicating libertarian views. I'm sorry that data driven liberalism conflicts with mainstream ideology and your favored talking points.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- krschultz 15y agoThe Incidental Economist is the premier healthcare policy blog as far as I can tell. I've been reading it for years, and it is anything but libertarian. They actually have several posts on why competition based schemes will not reduce posts - pretty much the exact opposite opinion of a libertarian. In fact they have two series of posts (one being what Yummyfajitas posted) that are basically required reading for anyone interested in discussing the healthcare problems in the US. I would also recommend their 10 part series on healthcare quality.