3 ms·
If it really turns out to be a problem then copyright holders are simply going to add in a not-licensed-for-training clause in all their licenses[1]. Sure, exi
by lelanthran 4y ago
If it really turns out to be a problem then copyright holders are simply going to add in a not-licensed-for-training clause in all their licenses[1].
Sure, existing works already licensed can still be used, but at least both parties (copyright holders and AI trainers) won't have anything to argue about.
[1] Anyone from CC reading this? Make it the default.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- CrimsonRain 4y agoIt is like adding a clause in the license that you are not allowed to read the license. The moment you share your creation/work to someone/the world, you are training their nn. You can not share something publicly and then demand "xyz" can not view it. Viewing is training. You are free to keep your creation under lock & key and only share with nn (of people and/or AI) of your choice.
- lelanthran 4y ago> You can not share something publicly and then demand "xyz" can not view it. That's nonsense. Licenses have clauses on how the content may be used. Clauses along the lines of "The content may not be used for ..." are common. I dunno where you heard that once you release something the license clauses no longer apply, but it's wrong.
- kragen 4y agomany of these clauses are legally unenforceable because you can violate them without infringing on any of the rights that copyright law grants exclusively to the copyright holder (who can license them)
- lelanthran 4y ago> many of these clauses are legally unenforceable because you can violate them without infringing on any of the rights that copyright law grants exclusively to the copyright holder (who can license them) That's news to Microsoft[1], who's shared source and various NDA licenses for the source code already has clauses restricting what you can do with it. [1] I think the problem is that the pro-AI arguments are coming from people who are not aware that clauses in licenses restricting how the content is used is quite common. For example, you were obviously not aware that they were so common that almost every big tech and/or software company of the past and the present already have those clauses in, and those clauses have already been found to be enforceable!
- kragen 4y agoof course people who agree to a contract are bound by its terms under common law; the question in the original article is what copyright law does or doesn't allow people to do without any sort of contract unfortunately you have descended from simply making vaguely ignorant comments to attacking me, which indicates that further engagement with you is unlikely to be useful to anyone
- lelanthran 4y agoThe license is the contract. Literally. And every nonFLOSS license and I've seen has restrictions on what the licensee can do with the material. Can you find one nonFLOSS license that doesn't have restrictions or limitations? I mean, you lead with obnoxious, then descended into condenscension, all while not realising that the whole point of the license is to restrict the licensee.
- throwaway675309 4y agoUntil such a time as a license containing a clause about not being used for "training purposes", whatever the hell that means, actually shows up in court, then adding this to your license has all the legal teeth of saying that you must sacrifice your first born.
- briHass 4y agoHow are you planning on proving a particular licensed work was used in a sufficiently large model? One of the commonly mentioned issues with current ML is the inability to reverse the output to figure out 'how it got there'.
- lelanthran 4y ago> How are you planning on proving a particular licensed work was used in a sufficiently large model? One of the commonly mentioned issues with current ML is the inability to reverse the output to figure out 'how it got there'. That's a different problem. Let's not get into the argument of "Just because the victim cannot prove something, we should remove the relevant laws." The current laws are sufficient; all that it takes is for licenses to have a non-AI-training clause. Lets solve the problem of "how do you prove" when we get to it[1]. [1] Right now, due to the systems already trained being given every single image on the net as training data according to the owner of those systems, in a civil suit the burden will be on them to prove that, on the balance of probabilities, a particular image was not used.
- kragen 4y agolaws that cannot be enforced in practice are bad laws; they work out to be a 007-style license to kill, but for businesses rather than people granting many such licenses is a recipe for social collapse
- lelanthran 4y ago> laws that cannot be enforced in practice are bad laws; Who said they couldn't be enforced? The argument from the pro-AI team is that we shouldn't have those laws in the first place. I'm saying, let's keep the laws we already have because they already work quite nicely if the content creators don't want their work included in any training data set. Rushing to make new laws because "Muh AI" is silly.
- kragen 4y ago
- kragen 4y agothat isn't how law works copyright is not a get-into-jail-free card that allows private parties to invent their own legal system and nonconsensually impose it on other private parties
- lelanthran 4y agoIt's not nonconsensual, if you want to use copyrighted content, or consume it in any way, you have to abide the the clauses in the license. Forbidding certain uses is a particularly common clause in most copyrighted material. Other than some FLOSS licenses, can you find one that doesn't have limitations on what you can do with the material?