4 ms·
The Reddit thread on the study you’re referring to aptly summarizes the problems with it: https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2014/10/02/why-asian-american-pa
by rayiner 4y ago
The Reddit thread on the study you’re referring to aptly summarizes the problems with it: https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2014/10/02/why-asian-american-parents-dont-spank-their-kids/ https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2014/10/02/why-asian-a...
One, this seems to rely on GSS data, which is conducted only in English and Spanish. Just 44% of for example foreign born Chinese Americans are proficient in English. So the GSS data is going to heavily skew towards assimilated, affluent Asians.
Two, the survey question is idiomatic English. It refers to a “good hard spanking.” I don’t think any of my immigrant family would say they do that to their kids, even they do use physical discipline. Non-native English speakers are going to be much less likely to understand what “hard” (or even “spanking”) means in this context.
Three, the survey is of Asian Americans, not immigrants. A survey of Latinos showed that the percentage that use corporal punishment drops dramatically in the second generation. I wouldn’t be surprised if that was true for Asian Americans also. But by the second generation, Asians enjoy no advantages in outcomes relative to other native born Americans.
Apart from that, even Asians who don’t use physical punishment use “socio emotive” discipline that people in this thread would deem emotional abuse: https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2014/10/02/why-asian-american-parents-dont-spank-their-kids/ https://thesocietypages.org/socimages/2014/10/02/why-asian-a...
What’s your standard for “fine?” It’s shocking how hard it is to keep kids from sopping up the worst aspects of American culture. Unfortunately I think there’s a good chance that one of the three will end up childless, unmarried, or divorced. Where I’m from I would have a reasonable expectation that none of those three would happen.
- tptacek 4y agoYou linked the same thing twice, so I don't know which Reddit thread you're referring to. "Asian" is more than half the world's population; the "model minority" thing is problematic in part because lots of Asian families have poor socioeconomic outcomes in the US. But the cohort captured by the study overlaps pretty completely the cohort of children you're implying have unusually good outcomes. And, of course, the other half of the argument is hard to knock down: incidence of corporal punishment clearly doesn't track good economic outcomes. The opposite is much closer to the truth; it probably is the truth, for in part mechanistic reasons (hitting kids damages them, impedes their ability to succeed).
- rayiner 4y ago> You linked the same thing twice, so I don't know which Reddit thread you're referring to. Sorry meant to link this Reddit thread the first time: https://www.reddit.com/r/asiantwoX/comments/2ibwkq/why_asian_american_parents_dont_spank_their_kids/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf https://www.reddit.com/r/asiantwoX/comments/2ibwkq/why_asian... > "Asian" is more than half the world's population; the "model minority" thing is problematic in part because lots of Asian families have poor socioeconomic outcomes in the US. But the cohort captured by the study overlaps pretty completely the cohort of children you're implying have unusually good outcomes. Closer to the opposite is true. Well assimilated second and third generation Asians don’t do any better than similarly affluent white Americans. It’s the kids of poor Asians—children of Indian gas station owners or Chinese restaurant workers, etc.—that have unusual outcomes. Asian kids raised in the bottom 20% of the income distribution are 2.5x more likely to end up in the top 20% as comparably situated white kids: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/27/upshot/make-your-own-mobility-animation.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/03/27/upshot/make-y.... It’s true that the “model minority” label is misleading as applied to Chinese or Indian people who come here under H1B to work at Google. The fact that those people do well is just filtering. But don’t forget that the American immigration system is one of chain migration. Those immigrants bring over family who often aren’t affluent. But the kids of those people also tend to do very well. And then there are the myriad groups who mostly didn’t come to America through systems like H1B that filter for educated, affluent people. The poverty rate among Vietnamese, who came here as refugees, in 1980 was higher than among black people. Today the median household income of US-born Vietnamese is significantly higher than for white Americans. The same is true for Filipinos.
- tptacek 4y agoI don't disagree with the thread that the headlines about the survey are bad and generalize ludicrously about a huge group of people with totally unrelated cultures. My point is that when you allude to the academic success of Asian American families, you are discussing exactly the cohort that thread complains is overindexed in the study. The study (and the thread) support my argument, and gravely undermine yours. Hitting children is not a good way to improve academic outcomes. All the evidence we have right now suggests that, at best, it does nothing; at worst, it damages children and leads to markedly worse outcomes.