4 ms·
It may be disingenuous to claim that Apple only seeks to know how purchasers of their computers are using them. The first reason is that Apple does not ask pur
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y ago
It may be disingenuous to claim that Apple only seeks to know how purchasers of their computers are using them.
The first reason is that Apple does not ask purchasers for permission to do this surveillance. It just makes it a default.
The second reason is that if purchasers applied the same standard to Apple, it is unilkely Apple would agree to such surveillance of its own computers.
Imagine hypotethically that purchasers shared data with Apple but every time Apple used the data, Apple computers would automatically make outbound connections from Apple's computers, over Apple's internal local network, through Apple's firewalls, over the internet, to purchasers computers so the purchasers could "understand how Apple was using their data".
Imagine further that Apple had no control over these connections, and that Apple was not allowed to "MiTM" the outbound connections made from Apple's computers to purchasers' computers to see what data/information was being sent.
What if purchasers argued that by using TLS certificates they controlled they were "only trying to protect the security of their ecosystem", e.g., the collection of entities with whom they share data. What if purchasers argued they were only trying to protect Apple against "MiTM attacks"^1 where, e.g., a third party might learn about Apple's activities, namely how Apple uses the data Apple gathers from Apple computer purchasers.
The point is that Apple might have concerns about others, including its hardware customers, knowing when and how it is using its own computers. Similarly, purchasers might have concerns about others, including Apple, knowing when and how how they are using their own computers.
1. "Tech" companies, acting as intermediaries, will claim they are using TLS to protect web users from third parties, the "MiTM", but curiously the "MiTM" never includes the "tech" companies themselves. In practice the "MiTM" actually includes the web user. WTF. In response to a web user who does not portray himself as a "developer" nor a "security researcher"^2 stating they wish to "MiTM" their own connections, a "tech" worker commenting in response might be dismissive.
2. https://www.bounteous.com/insights/2016/11/17/using-charles-proxy-inspect-and-debug-google-analytics/ https://www.bounteous.com/insights/2016/11/17/using-charles-...