3 ms·
Do you honestly put any stock in that stuff? We have had decades of research into child rearing and education in the west. If it was actually reliable, it shoul
by rayiner 4y ago
Do you honestly put any stock in that stuff? We have had decades of research into child rearing and education in the west. If it was actually reliable, it should have produced better behaved kids that do better in school and have better outcomes. The absence of any evidence of that is glaring.
The greatest generation that built this country into what it is were subject to corporal punishment. Today, Asian immigrants use corporal punishment and their kids vastly outperform the children of native born Americans. Maybe there is no correlation between those things, but that is much more concrete evidence than some papers in a psychology journal.
- tptacek 4y agoYes, I do: parental corporal punishment is, unfortunately, most common in the families with with the worst outcomes. Asian American parents are among those least likely to employ corporal punishment. That's unsurprising to me; I have a generally favorable opinion of the parenting culture you're alluding to (even though I wouldn't have considered it for my own kids), and corporal punishment is (what's the right word?) stupid. As my sibling commenter notes, we have a neat little case study here, too: we allow corporal punishment in public schools in a minority of states. Overlay outcomes by school district; how's it working out?
- vidarh 4y agoIf violence was effective, we should have plenty of comparative proof from the US states where it's still allowed. We don't
- fzeroracer 4y agoAs another poster said, multiple states have corporal punishment as not only allowed but encouraged, and so far we haven't seen the better outcomes you claim in terms of better behaved kids. So in the absence of any evidence that corporal punishment works, the obvious answer should be to not do it.