3 ms·
> Medical care is the most highly regulated industry in the economy, and so nothing you see happening is going to bear very much resemblance to reality. You ma
by rdtsc 15y ago
> Medical care is the most highly regulated industry in the economy, and so nothing you see happening is going to bear very much resemblance to reality.
You make it sound like one follows from the other in an obvious way. Can you expand on why that would be?
- CWuestefeld 15y agoYou make it sound like one follows from the other in an obvious way. I think it does follow logically. I'm assuming that the regulations were intended to serve some purpose. If the system was working as the regulators/legislators wanted, there would have been no point in regulation. The regulations were created for the purpose of altering the way things would normally work out. By analogy, if we see a canal, it's probably a safe assumption that the waterway doesn't resemble the natural flow of water. The only reason to build the canal is that something was needed to be different from the water features that were present.
- saucetenuto 15y agoSpeaking as someone who doesn't know much about this stuff, your analogy reads more like, "the canal diverted the waterway, so tigers devoured the Pope". It may well be true, but you need to flesh it out more: explain how the new course flooded the tigers' habitat, forcing them to migrate to Rome.
- jellicle 15y agoThe person you're responding to believes that if medical charges are vastly different between providers it must be due to evil government regulation, because after all in other sorts of stores we never see wildly varying prices for the same item and healthcare, where people have plenty of time to comparison shop (even if you're choking on turkey, you still have a few minutes to contact the various local hospitals and determine which provides cheaper ER service before you pass out) is a perfect example of a transparent market.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoThe person you're responding to believes that The person he's talking to doesn't believe that putting a strawman argument into someone else's mouth is an honest debate tactic. This question has nothing to do with ideology. As a matter of pure logic, regulation changes what the market is doing naturally; that's the whole point of the regulation. This is a non-judgmental conclusion. One doesn't have to say that the market state was good or bad, or that the regulated state is good or bad. Simply that a regulated market differs from a free market. That's it. Now, given that the system is highly regulated, it's clear that the regulators have screwed up. However, this on its own doesn't tell us that the free market was good; it just tells us that the current regulatory regime is crap.
- intended 15y agoBit late to the conversation, and somewhat pedantic, do forgive - Going from : >>This is a non-judgmental conclusion. One doesn't have to say that the market state was good or bad, or that the regulated state is good or bad. Simply that a regulated market differs from a free market. That's it. to >>Now, given that the system is highly regulated, it's clear that the regulators have screwed up. is making a jump. It is not a necessary that the regulators messed up - it is also possible that the parties being moderated, are actively subverting the system. /pedant I will agree with your point behind it all - ie that in such a system it is LIKELY that there is fault by the regulators. This type of fault, the extent of responsibility for the final outcome, these are complex questions which need more than just stating that the regulators were out of line. You could say that X and Y are responsible for crime A. The punishment/responsibility would depend on a variety of factors. That is the question that requires answering.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoIt is not a necessary that the regulators messed up - it is also possible that the parties being moderated, are actively subverting the system. As I see it, that is a problem with the regulation. By analogy, when a hacker breaks into your system, you can't say, "our security checks weren't wrong; the users just weren't supposed to enter those inputs". It's your job to anticipate all the possible bad inputs, and guard against them. Similarly, it's the job of the regulators to anticipate all possible routes around the regulations, and account for those. Now, a bit of thought will lead to the conclusion that this is impossible except in all but the most trivial cases. I submit that this does NOT give us leave to shrug and just go through it anyway. Instead, it should force us to step back and consider whether the intended benefits of the regulations are great enough to counterbalance the cost of the complications that are certain to occur down the road. (and I note a certain irony in your pseudonym "intended", since the problem here is UNintended consequences)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- anamax 15y ago>> Medical care is the most highly regulated industry in the economy, and so nothing you see happening is going to bear very much resemblance to reality. >You make it sound like one follows from the other in an obvious way. Can you expand on why that would be? Two factors: incentives and information. Regulators do not, by definition and intent, have the same incentives as participants. They're also not involved, so they lack information. Here's another way to think of it. When a biz goes bankrupt, employees lose their jobs, owners lose equity, and regulators go to lunch as usual. If a regulator mis-estimates costs by 1%, that's fantastic. If a supermarket mis-estimates costs by 1%, it goes out of biz (because their margins are less than 1%).
- Symmetry 15y agoAs just one example, look at the RBRVS: http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/prescriptions/2009/09/the_fix_is_in.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/prescription... Paying people on a cost-plus basis provides them with an incentive to maximize costs, whether they're doctors or defense contractors. Then there's also the FDA's use of production quotas for drug production. We had a big shortage of Aderall recently because the FDA has to give permission ahead of time for a given amount of production of the drug for each company. And when the FDA decided that one of the producers wasn't up to snuff and was no longer allowed to make the drug, it failed to raise the quotas of the other producers to compensate. To the extent that you run a section of the economy like the USSR was run, you shouldn't expect it to be run efficiently. The US healthcare system would still have quite a ways to go before it becomes quite that bad, but its closer than most people seem to think.
- llimllib 15y ago> We had a big shortage of Aderall recently because the FDA has to give permission ahead of time for a given amount of production of the drug for each company. As I understand it, the DEA, not the FDA, sets the quotas. They're currently arguing publicly over the shortage: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/01/health/policy/fda-is-finding-attention-drugs-in-short-supply.html?_r=2 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/01/health/policy/fda-is-findi... The DEA claims there is no shortage (insert Star Wars hand wave here) while the FDA wants them to raise the quotas. (How Soviet does that sound?) No disagreement on the rest of your comment.
- _delirium 15y agoThe Adderall example is due to our drug-war paranoia more than due to healthcare regulation; Adderall is a Schedule II controlled substance whose production and distribution is micromanaged as a result. My guess is that those problems would remain even if we completely deregulated healthcare otherwise, because there is very little political support for widespread drug declassification (maybe marijuana will happen in my lifetime, but I doubt much else).
- defen 15y agoI think part of the problem is that "highly regulated" is an ill defined term. For certain definitions of "highly regulated", the NASDAQ is highly regulated, yet we don't see much price distortion there. The "problem", I think, is with the nature of the regulation, and the nature of the supply/demand equation for medical care. One simple example, which I don't really have time to explain here, is the health insurance system which makes it so that people generally do not consider price when purchasing medical care. Of course that is going to lead to price distortions. Another simple example is the inflexibility in the supply of doctors, which is ultimately due to government regulations (many would argue that this is a good thing)